4 ms·
It's a little thing called fun. Doesn't have to be referring to the same topic to make a joke reference. In fact, it works better if it's from an unrelated doma
by coldtea 4y ago
It's a little thing called fun. Doesn't have to be referring to the same topic to make a joke reference. In fact, it works better if it's from an unrelated domain
- AprilArcus 4y agoIt's not fun, it's scary and tacky. Those red hats represent a movement that really wants to hurt people like me and my friends.
- AviationAtom 4y agoI'm not surprised to hear someone say such, only disappointed.
- coldtea 4y ago[flagged]
- xibo9 4y agoIts really not helpful to degrade conversation in this fashion. Maybe rephrase in a more helpful and less combative way?
- coldtea 4y ago[flagged]
- kagakuninja 4y agoWhether MAGA want to hurt millions of people, that is the result of conservative policies. 1 million+ unnecessary deaths during the pandemic. Targeting of LGBTQ people, blacks, teachers, librarians, politicians, election officials and even doctors (wtf?). Forced "detransitioning" of trans people. Banning all forms of abortion, even in the case of rape, minors and incest. Banning life-saving abortions, forcing women to carry unviable fetuses to term. And that is just today, they have more plans in store...
- aksss 4y agoThey probably (seriously) feel the same way about you. The solution is to stop demonizing and dehumanizing your political opposition and be okay with difference of opinion while communicating. Also recognize it's a tired game of both ends of the political spectrum to convince people the other side is full of monsters who want to destroy them. Look at wartime propaganda. There's plenty of room to disagree with each other and be passionate about our convictions without involving that element. If your response is, "no but really..", start reading from the top again.
- kstrauser 4y agoThis is all off-topic, but that's a ridiculous take. I'm a straight white guy. Literally no one is seriously proposing laws that would make my life more difficult in the slightest. No one is trying to make it illegal for me to be married to my wife, or to use the right bathroom, or to tell my kids it's OK for them to be straight. There's no legitimate "but both sides...!" here.
- coldtea 4y ago>This is all off-topic, but that's a ridiculous take. I'm a straight white guy. Literally no one is seriously proposing laws that would make my life more difficult in the slightest. Except if you're working class, then all bets are off. People can laugh at you, dismiss you as white trash, kill your livelihood and tell you to "learn to code" when businesses still getting huge tax cuts "outsource", and your local jobs die, and so on.
- roydivision 4y agoI agree, there is nothing fun about MAGA. The reference is tone deaf, off point, and totally unnecessary. I suggest the author reflect on what it really means to a large portion of the population.
- lapcat 4y ago> It's a little thing called fun. Nobody thinks it's fun, except the people who wear the red hats.
- coldtea 4y agoYou'd be surprised. People who aren't partisans one way or the other could not give less fucks. But even bona fide leftists have used red hats ironically and in comic sketches ever since they appeared. If anything, it's probably people who wear the red hats who would be "insulted" ("oh, you're making a mockery of our slogan!")
- lapcat 4y ago> People who aren't partisans one way or the other could not give less fucks. The author appears to be Canadian, so maybe he's just oblivious. > But even bona fide leftists have used red hats ironically and in comic sketches ever since they appeared. Of course. But the article author doesn't appear to be mocking the MAGA movement, just using an ill-advised expression and photo to make an unrelated point. An author has to know their audience. Whether or not you personally believe that MAGA revulsion is "justified", it's a mistake to put off a large portion of one's audience, even if that was unintentional.
- coldtea 4y ago>Of course. But the article author doesn't appear to be mocking the MAGA movement, just using an ill-advised expression and photo to make an unrelated point. The author is just using it as a meme-template of "Make X great again", repurposing something considered tacky as a joke, as countless others have done. Obviously ironically, the same way people would use "Just say no" or other slogans ironically. In fact, it's pretty obvious they're anything but sympathetic to the original thing to use it jockingly like this. It's time to stop being so negative to anything that's not sterile corporate speak, sanitized six ways from Sunday by HR and marketeers.
- lapcat 4y ago
- thih9 4y agoSure, but it relates to an ongoing controversial and distracting topic. Basically, “too soon”.
- bitwize 4y agoMAGA is a buzzphrase for racists and an immediate red flag. Referencing it casually is like referencing Nazi or KKK slogans casually -- it's in poor taste and further marginalizes communities who've been marginalized enough.
- junofan 4y agoIt’s an economic message. Let’s not further marginalize poor rural people by making those comparisons.
- bitwize 4y agoIt's a message straight out of Hitler's playbook: create a cult of personality by radicalizing rural people and the working class and using them to create a voting bloc powerful enough to dismantle the very democracy that gave them that power in the first place. Godwin's law doesn't apply; Godwin himself said that comparing people to Nazis was appropriate when those people are actually behaving like Nazis. If you do not look at Trump and his memetic strategy and see the rise of fascism in the USA, you have not been paying attention.
- coldtea 4y ago>Godwin's law doesn't apply; Godwin himself said that comparing people to Nazis was appropriate when those people are actually behaving like Nazis. Of course that's also what everybody making a bad comparison would say. "I'm my case it's justified". In fact, if Hitler was re-incarnated in the 21st century, something he would have added "my opponent is literary Hitler" to his playbook - dehumanizing the other side. But of course those who do that only do it becaue they're "justified" in doing it.