3 ms·
Amen! The concept that your own health is somebody else's job to take care of & protect has always seemed strange to me.
by sliverstorm 15y ago
Amen! The concept that your own health is somebody else's job to take care of & protect has always seemed strange to me.
- tptacek 15y agoThis is probably true for dental, for a lot of reasons, including the routinization of dental care, the degree to which dental expenses are preventable, the fact that fewer people have dental insurance than health insurance (and so the market for dental care is less distorted), and the extent to which dental care can be cosmetic. The same isn't true of health care. The health care market is totally distorted by insurers, who collude with providers to set prices. Services fall into two buckets: routine "checkup" type stuff that costs so little it's not worth arguing about, and hospital/specialist services for which there is no pricing transparency and which, purchased by anyone other than an insurance company, is catastrophically expensive. It is perfectly reasonable to advocate for single-payer health care even if one believes firmly in moral hazard. There are other interventions one could advocate for instead. But any way you slice it, the "market" we currently have is busted.
- stretchwithme 15y agoThere was single payer before the tax code subsidy for insurance came along. It was called "cash". The subsidy is responsible for a lot of distortion. It has separated cost and benefit in the minds of employees. And it hands more of a subsidy to people who make more money. Taking insurance from your employer is a bad deal if you don't make enough. Which is why many employers of lower paying jobs don't offer it.
- _delirium 15y agoHealth also has significant variance in outcomes, much more than the variance in dental costs, so it makes sense to pool risk. However, the fact that events aren't uncorrelated like a lightning strike makes it hard to deal with as an "insurance", the usual risk-pooling strategy, because in many cases the event has already happened, so no sane insurer would insure against it (how is it insurance if it has an 100% chance of occurring?). For example, an American friend of mine has a congenital heart defect which will over his lifetime cost probably $1m or so; I had better luck and was not born with one. It seems sort of problematic imo that this sort of thing isn't risk-pooled across the population. It's already bad enough that he has to have surgeries/etc. for it, but due to our health system it also impacts areas of his life that shouldn't be affected, like choice of career. For example, he can never start a startup or do freelance/consulting work, because he wouldn't be able to buy individual health insurance; so he has to work at a large company with a good group-health plan, and can never be unemployed for longer than the 18-month COBRA limit.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- _delirium 15y agoSure, people can't be the same, but I see paying for major healthcare problems as just one of the basic "civilized society" baselines. I mean, in most of those other cases you have other choices: can't be an air force pilot, do something else. And we do make some baseline effort to ensure that you have some ability to choose a career, by providing free public education. But if you have a heart that doesn't work without medical treatment, you don't have an alternative to "get medical treatment". I guess I don't at all mind paying an equal share of those kinds of expenses, either. To me, not having heart defects, leukemia, down syndrome, or any of a number of things I might've had is its own reward, because my quality of life is better and I don't have to get surgeries and whatnot. I don't see a need to also come out financially ahead of those who had the misfortune to need the surgeries, so I win the health lottery twice and they lose it twice. The moral-hazard problem also seems pretty weak, at least when it comes to major things like surgeries; I doubt there are many people who would've avoided getting cancer if they had to pay for it, but if it was free decided hey what the heck (that is, the suckiness of major illnesses is already a bigger disincentive than the expense of treatment). Moral hazard might come into it more with things like overprescription of antibiotics for routine/minor illnesses.
- sliverstorm 15y agoSorry, deleted not realizing you had replied. For reference: It's not Kosher, but the thing that always pops into my mind is- you've got the body you were given. Are we now also in the business of equity across our mortal coils? Plenty of people can never be air force pilots; they need glasses, or are too tall/short, etc. The same goes for athletes, and so on.