7 ms·
Bitcoin is a solution looking for a problem
- rntn 4y agohttps://archive.is/LDppt https://archive.is/LDppt
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wslh 4y agoIn many places in the world it is a solution solving a previous problem. That is a fact, not an opinion (e.g. Argentina). It is important to highlight that now stable coins have replaced part of the original Bitcoin vision and that for many people it does not matter if the solution is decentralized or not, just if it is accessible.
- dragontamer 4y agoStablecoins are just sketchy online banks pretending they have dollars, with users pretending they're spending dollars. The minute the illusion is ripped out, it gets LunaCoined and collapses. The illusion can be held seemingly perpetually at 0% interest rates, but now at 4.75% FFR, I have my doubts that stablecoins make much sense.
- wslh 4y agoSketchy or not it is usable. BitTorrent protocol is used for piracy but it is also used.
- dragontamer 4y agoMy excel spreadsheet with money that I pass between my friends during a vacation is also usable to determine settlements. Which is more than the accounting going on at FTX by the way. And that's why those depositors lost everything. -------- Many thousands, maybe 10s of thousands or even 100s of thousands have lost their entire accounts at FTX, Celsius, and other "cryptocoin" schemes or "stablecoin" schemes like Gemini. This is well documented and understood. Its a very simple issue: cryptocoin bros lie, your money isn't safe or kept with any kind of accounting practices with them. And with all the bullcrap about "decentralized" or "trust-free" accounting, its all just lies to get people to deposit more money into shady accounts.
- wslh 4y agoAs i said in another comment in the same thread: we are looking at a very tiny timeframe. Crypto was an opportunity for fraudsters, there were similar opportunities in the past for the financial system. Fraudsters are incredible fast, more than entrepreneurs. Just look at other shady schemes in CeFi.
- dragontamer 4y agoYou know that the US Dollar (and the banking system) survived 19% FFR interest rates in the 1981, right? 4.75% isn't even that much by historical standards of the past century.
- wslh 4y agoRome also survived a lot of things.
- ChainOfFools 4y ago> trust-free "trust us, it's trustless. " -kleptocurrency huckster gospel pg 1 verse 1
- SkyMarshal 4y agoExactly. Stablecoins are a misnomer. They’re stable until they’re not, then they implode.
- wslh 4y agoCeFi systems have the same problem, it is just that now DeFi is more extreme.
- dragontamer 4y agoWe haven't seen anyone lose a true FDIC-insured dollar in over a hundred years. Furthermore, there have only been rare occasions where Money Markets have broken the bank, less than 5 in the past century. That's dropping from $1 to $0.98. Meanwhile, Tether regularly (every couple of weeks) drops to 98-cents or less. Celsius, Gemini, and FTX all imploded with 100% losses (at least, my friend's "stablecoins" in those accounts were completely lost and no one has given his money back yet)
- pibechorro 4y ago*yet
- dragontamer 4y agoUSDC literally reached 91-cents just 3 weeks ago dude. There is an alarming frequency at which stablecoins break the buck. I'm pointing out imperfect dollar instruments like Money Market Funds that have no insurance and are free to invest into riskier bonds... but even these risky MMFs are far more stable in practice than USDC or Tether, or any other stablecoin for that matter.
- wslh 4y agoUSDC issue was connected to the CeFi world. It is important to highlight that assuming USDC has 100% in banks they will recover the lost money for the interest they receive in normal banks, this is not translated to USDC holders.
- psychlops 4y agoI want to argue with you, but this is true. It doesn't have to be, but it has been the reality. It's also correct when applied to global currencies that peg to the dollar, not just cryptocurrencies.
- kkielhofner 4y agoI spent years in the crypto space and emerged more-or-less a crypto hater. I don't need to rehash that journey. I acknowledge the plight of people in situations like Argentina, Venezuela, Lebanon, etc. I have many friends who fled such situations and Bitcoin/crypto absolutely would have been of benefit to them. However, when looking at the numbers helping people in these situations is easily still a net negative when zooming out and tallying what crypto has done to the population generally. For every person that was able to maintain some wealth in these situations there are 100 people who have gambled away everything they have and enabled an entire cast of charlatans, scammers, cybercriminals, and oppressive regimes like North Korea. I don't even want to think what the actual human impact is from suicides, ruined families, etc. I've provided data in multiple other comments and the fact is there has been tens if not hundreds of billions of dollars invested in crypto over more than a decade for a tiny number of people (one half of one percent of global internet users) to use this stuff for anything (mostly crime and speculation). Oh yeah, plus the ridiculous environmental and broader societal impact of the complete insanity that is proof of work resource utilization. Crypto is overwhelmingly evil and an absolute scourge.
- anonym29 4y agoCan we also acknowledge that US state governments are also deliberately, willfully, and maliciously harming those who gamble away everything they have on state lotteries, if "allowing people to voluntarily ruin their own lives gambling" is a sin? No disagreement on the charlatans, scammers, cybercrims, NK's of the world, etc, FWIW.
- kkielhofner 4y agoThe old saying "money is the root of all evil" often does generally apply and lotteries are an excellent example of state-sponsored financial ruin. I especially like the John Oliver pieces[0][1] on that one. I see it everyday - video poker "cafes" and here in Wisconsin the cultural acceptance and actual embrace of weird things like "pull tabs" and "dice games". Las Vegas is an entire city that has been built on financial ruin. But we can simultaneously criticize, express concern, and work towards fixing multiple issues at the same time. [0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PK-netuhHA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PK-netuhHA [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HKMNKS-9ugY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HKMNKS-9ugY
- simple-thoughts 4y agoBitcoin has serious problems - it was the first cryptoasset and since it was developed many superior cryptoassets have followed, many of which are targeted to extremely specific use cases. I tend to agree with this article that buying Bitcoin versus one of the other 20,000 major cryptoassets is likely a mistake. But, it’s important to understand that Bitcoin has some specific advantages still. It has the most liquidity, the highest brand recognition, and the most resistance to censorship due to the massive amount of hash power behind it.
- zkldi 4y agoall three of those advantages are the same thing - popularity.
- simple-thoughts 4y agoYes, so it’s not really a stable situation. BTC has a good chance of going close to zero.
- pibechorro 4y agoIts not a bitcoin vs other coins. These are layers of tech. This website is running html, javascript and all the other server side and browser side protocols. They stack. Bitcoin is a single purpose blockchain and its essentially the html out of which other crypto tech layers extra features without compromising its value (security, consistency, etc). The idea that a single blockchain needs to solve all use cases is silly. We just need layer 2, 3, etc. The biggest hurdle to this tech evolving is not btc or there being better options that do the same, its regulatory which is severely hamstringing transactions because of capital gain reporting etc.
- meltyness 4y agoI hate to walk into proselytizing but: I mean if your intent is speculation, this is how the rest of the internet has been built. TCP and OS security are so bad they ripped the internet a whole Cloudflare, but they all still exist and find their uses in real systems. No comment on regulatory or legal frameworks in place since I have no idea what's gone on in the courts on that front. It's like entropy though and I have doubts that there's any long term value in trying to stop it. Banks beget banks, because banks only invest in diversified quasi-banks, basically stockpiling non-cash assets, feast or famine. A reasonable structure for much of human history, if you like (often) dry, safe, grain/peas in the winter. Before global transport was fast and risk-free. In vogue right now: "all the PCs, all the business software, all the electrification efforts/grid modernization, all the goods manufacturers storefronts, all the films, all the personal sites, all the web pages." Maybe not such a relevant capability (large stockpiles) outside of, well, contingency. Bitcoin, the machine, only invests in progress, cheaper more plentiful energy and faster processors or you lose. It has scarcity and inherits supporting stockpiling. Ethereum? Presumably cooperation and transparent software, also good things! Perhaps in the next century proof of health, proof of satiety.
- psychlops 4y agoFunny timing about articles like this after the past few weeks have put on display the flaws of the current system. The war on alternatives currencies is surfacing in multiple ways, not simply the mysterious shutdown of Signature bank. Everyone will be chained into the current system until eventually sinks.
- itsoktocry 4y agoIf you want to own Bitcoin, great. But a currency you can't print would make the current problems worse.
- anonym29 4y agoA "currency" with a fixed supply would make inflation worse than a FIAT "currency" for which 40% of the entire supply was printed in 2 years? A "currency" with no physical representation, that physically cannot spread infectious pathogens (like COVID) the same way physical paper notes and coins do is worse than paper notes and coins for public health? A "currency" with wide open and auditable transaction records is worse for combatting government corruption than briefcases full of paper notes with no auditability at all? If you want to own FIAT, fine, but don't pretend BTC is automatically the root of all evil.
- intalentive 4y agoIt would make them worse in the short term, perhaps. But if you were engineering a system from the ground up? Bad design choice IMO. Too easy to drive into the ground a la Zimbabwe.
- stanleydrew 4y agoThe past few weeks have also demonstrated the benefits of the existing system. Excessive risk taking is a human phenomenon. Sometimes that results in a bank failure. Sometimes that results in a stablecoin failure. With the existing system, we have various backstops in place to ensure the return of bank deposits that people assume are safe.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zabzonk 4y ago> Peter Thiel threw $100 bills into the crowd from the stage at a cryptocurrency conference in Miami is there some sort of race to the bottom between all these vile super-rich goons?
- Dreako 4y ago>vile super-rich goons? Reddit moment
- zabzonk 4y agonot sure what you mean by that
- kkielhofner 4y agoIt's a lazy way to attempt to discredit someone or their argument. I, for one, appreciate your use of "goons".
- zabzonk 4y agoThanks. But does that mean that Peter Thiel has a fan? Who would have thought?
- anonym29 4y agoFIATbux? No thanks! /s
- lowkey 4y ago“Chancellor on brink of second bailout of the banks” - Financial Times, encoded in the Bitcoin genesis block “The problem with money is all the trust that is involved” - Bitcoin Whitepaper We can debate whether or not Bitcoin has truly solved the problem it set out to solve, but the problem Satoshi Nakamoto intended to solve was clearly articulated in the Bitcoin Whitepaper and immortalized in the genesis block. Bitcoin was designed to solve all the trust required in the system, trust in institutions that have proven again and again not to deserve that trust. With traditional currency you have to trust the bank not to lose your deposits through speculation. You have to trust that the bank holds a sufficient fraction of your deposits to remain liquid and solvent when you go to withdraw “your” money. You have to trust central bankers not to print more money out of thin air and dilute the purchasing power of you money, etc.