2 ms·
>> It plays games with words to make plausible-sounding English text, but any statements made in it are liable to be false > Well, that could also be perfectly
by gus_massa 4y ago
>> It plays games with words to make plausible-sounding English text, but any statements made in it are liable to be false
> Well, that could also be perfectly applied to any human.
I agree completely with that part.
> The difference being that humans may make purposefully or not false statement (i.e. by lying or by ignorance), whereas the AI will only make false statements by ignorance.
Sometimes it's difficult to be sure if a humans is overconfident or trying to sound smart, and classify the answer as a honest error, bullshit or a lie. (And sometimes the answer is a mix of them.)
Most of the times human don't lie for fun, but because they have a secret objective. The problem is that ChatGPT has no objective (except trying to sound smart bulshiting plausible-sounding English text).
It's better to discuss about an AI that has an objective, like AlphaStar that "wants" to win a StarCraftII game. Can AlphaStar lie?
* Can AlphaStar send an empty transport plane to the right so the player tries to defend that fake attack, and then AlphaStar attack at the left with real troops?
* Can AlphaStar create fake hallucinate troops that look real for the player but actually can't attack, so the player gets scared and run away or attack the fake troops instead of the real ones?
Is that lying or ignorance?