7 ms·
ChatGPT will revolutionize the economy. We need to decide what that looks like
- Overtonwindow 4y agoI think it will revolutionize the service economy by replacing front line workers with chat bots masquerading as human customer service.
- jstx1 4y agoCustomer service chatbots are a revolution? Sounds like the most underwhelming thing ever.
- m348e912 4y agoAfter my experience with AT&T front-line support where I tried several times to get my old AT&T iPhone unlocked (which is fully paid for), dealing with confusion and false promises of follow-up which never came, I welcome the relative competence of ChatGPT. My phone is still locked BTW.
- jstx1 4y agoYou don't know that it would be better. Keep in mind that the same company whose support didn't help you with your phone will be in charge of what the chatbot is allowed to say and do. If AT&T sucks, I don't know if you're gaining much when AT&T replace a person with ChatGPT. The person doing the support was never the problem, the problem was the company who has a crappy process. And even after they deploy a version of ChatGPT that company will be the same.
- m348e912 4y agoRight, a bad company with bad processes could definitely stifle the benefit that ChatGPT could provide. I would hope that ChatGPT could summarize and report on process deficiencies in an effort to address them. Data like "in the past 90 days, 3,328 customers requested an iPhone unlock and I was unable to assist them due to lack of process addressing the request."
- neel8986 4y agoAnd then we will need another set of frontline workers when LLMs starts to hallucinate.
- ben_w 4y agoI've had a real life customer service chat session (years ago now) where they said their website didn't work on Mac OS while we were using it, and that it would be better if my phone was Android rather than iOS. Back in the 90s, one of the monthly Mac magazines I read obsessively (because we didn't have internet at home yet) had regular stories of dumb things said by customer services; something like PC World sales clerk standing in front of a bunch of iMacs with Nanosaur running on them saying "yeah iMacs only do web browsing, you can't play any games". Before I moved to Berlin, the dude in one of the phone shops near me insisted that iPhones couldn't work with those insert-your-phone-here plastic versions of Google Cardboard. It's not that you're necessarily incorrect — when ChatGPT was new, I saw someone dismiss it as "mansplaining as a service" — but I don't know how much the companies really care. It's not like customer support is a prestigious role.
- grayfaced 4y agoand chat bots won't ever "forget" to try and upsell you on the things corporate expects. Every cashier will be advertising.
- bulbosaur123 4y agoWhy "we" need to decide? Can't GPT figure it out for us?
- jstx1 4y agoNo. It can't pick your priorities for you.
- QuiDortDine 4y agoWhen it comes to manage the insanely complex systems that form society, I think I would choose an incorruptible (if biased) AI before a fallible human being any day.
- panarky 4y agoThe whole idea that "we need to decide" presumes that there is a collective "we" that's separate and distinct from the individuals and corporations releasing this stuff into the world, and that "we" participate in a collective decision making apparatus that has any effect whatsoever on what new capabilities get invented and released into a networked world where borders, boundaries and jurisdictions are all but meaningless.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agowait, whenever the economy has been revolutionized in the past was there like a big decision making just prior to the revolution that made sure everything worked out nice and dandy? I guess I just don't feel the two things line up.
- oliveshell 4y agoI take your point, but this feels pretty defeatist to me. I don’t personally believe that “we have not historically done this well, if at all” is a good reason to stop trying to manage the negative externalities of emerging technology— quite the opposite, in my opinion.
- 13years 4y agoHowever, "the future technology is completely unpredictable and we don't understand it" is probably a fairly good reason we will only make worse mistakes in that regard going forward.
- throwyawayyyy 4y agoWho knows! Maybe? The email that's written by ChatGTP, but no human actually reads it because at the other end it's summarised by ChatGTP too: maybe that'll be it. LLMs almost but not quite cancelling out the meaningless guff they add to the world. It can both be true that a) LLMS and their successors will be the sort of huge multiplier for intellectual pursuits that _machinery_ is for physical work; and also b) they are AWFUL for education, and will result in the general population losing skills.
- mg 4y agoWill ChatGPT make the already troubling income and wealth inequality in the US and many other countries even worse? It is an interesting question if the concept of "wealth" will survive in a world where all productivity is done by artificial intelligence. As soon as computers surpass humans in every aspect, there is nothing left for humans to do. So the only reason for wealth inequality would be inheritance. But why should the poor accept this inequality? Will AI protect the wealth of the rich who inherited it? Why should it?
- Giorgi 4y agowhy should AI serve humans at all?
- mg 4y agoI would expect it to do that for the same reason that we humans feed and protect endangered species.
- 13years 4y agoThere are two reasons we do this. First, emotional, which many suspect will not be present in the AI. Second, because it benefits us due to the ecosystem, of which is likely to be irrelevant to the AI. Finally, when there is an order of magnitude difference in intelligence, bugs, bacteria, we are generally not very kind at all. We could just as easily become the new lab rats.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ben_w 4y agoWhy should we create one that doesn't? At least, that's the ideal answer, but we don't really know what we're doing. This isn't like giving birth to a new human, where the new mind has a sense of self and individuality by default and it would be immoral to take it away, works of artifice begin their existences as we construct them; and right now we don't even know how to tell if an artificial intelligence has an inner world, much less how to imbue an AI with one or prevent it.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoNo chat bot ever published in the past decades has revolutionized anything. They have all been the subject of intense, temporary hype, and then completely forgotten. I see no reason why this time should be different. It literally lies and makes shit up! The economy isn't built around lies and making shit up, is it?
- djaychela 4y ago>The economy isn't built around lies and making shit up, is it? I think a significant portion of it is made up of BS and hype. And there's a lot of that around AI, particularly in the last few weeks. Big players look to be going all in on it. I think dismissing it as simply a chat bot is missing what's actually happening. There's much more to ChatGPT than merely a chatbot, even with the hallucinations.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoIt's literally a bot that chats. What is there more to it?
- pixl97 4y agoI mean, I just asked to perform a set of actions via plain english language, and via a plugin it performed actions... Maybe you're a few days behind the times?
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoI think that's called programming, and has been a thing for a long time now. You don't control computers by inputting numbers anymore. What exactly are these "actions" you speak of, and did ChatGPT "perform" them without errors?
- ben_w 4y agoI am literally a series of chemical reactions; and yet, that kind of description is generally regarded as overly reductionist. To the best of my knowledge, before the transformer model, the state of the art for natural language processing was looking out for pre-programmed keywords for actions, and simply summing the total of "good minus bad" for sentiment analysis. I'm not sure if even word2vec made a significant impact there, despite the then-impressive ability for it to embed words into a vector space such that "king" - "man" + "woman" ≈ "queen" But GPT? Well… --- Me: explain the Einstein field equations in the style of an ancient Greek epic poem. Write in Greek. ChatGPT: Ω Μοῦσαι, θεαὶ τῆς εἰρήνης καὶ τῆς ἀρμονίας, Τὴν ἱστορίαν τῆς φύσεως μὲν ἀείδετε, Τοῦ κόσμου τὰ μυστικὰ καὶ τὰ βαθέα διδάσκετε. Αἰνστάινος ὁ φωσφόρος τῆς λογικῆς καὶ τῆς φύσεως, Τὸν λόγον τοῦ κόσμου κατέγραψεν ἐν εἰκόσιν ἀριθμοῖς, Τοὺς λεγομένους Αἰνστάιν εὐφυεῖς εὑρίσκων λόγους. Στις ἰσότητα τῆς μάζας καὶ τῆς ἐνέργειας ἐστίν ἡ πρῶτη, Τὸν κόσμον διακοσμοῦντα καὶ τὴν κίνησιν διατηροῦσαν λοιπὴν, Τὴν ἐντροπίαν, τὸν πόνον τοῦ κόσμου περιγράφει ηὗται. Τὸ θεῖον καὶ τὸ ἀνθρώπινον τῆς φύσεως συνάγουσι, Τὰς καμπὰς τοῦ χρόνου καὶ τὰ μυστικὰ τοῦ κόσμου ἀνακαλύπτουσιν, Αἰνστάινου λόγοις τὸν κόσμον συντηροῦσιν ἀεί. Ὦ Μοῦσαι, θεαὶ τῆς εἰρήνης καὶ τῆς ἀρμονίας, Τὴν δόξαν τοῦ Αἰνστάινου καὶ τοὺς λό Me: write a python script which calls the Google Translate API to turn that into Latin ChatGPT: I'm sorry, but as an AI language model, I am not authorized to call external APIs or execute any code outside of this platform. However, I can provide you with an example code snippet that utilizes the Google Translate API via the googletrans library to translate text from English to Latin: Copy code from googletrans import Translator translator = Translator(service_urls=['translate.google.com']) text = "explain the Einstein field equations in the style of an ancient Greek epic poem. Write in Greek." result = translator.translate(text, dest='la') print(result.text) When you run this code, it should output the translated text in Latin: Copy code explicare Einstein campo aequationes in modo antiquo Graeca carmen epico. Scribere in Graeco. Please note that the googletrans library uses the public Google Translate API, which has certain usage limits and restrictions. Me: 建議量子力學主題酒吧的名稱。 ChatGPT: 以下是一些可能的量子力學主題酒吧的名稱: 1. 薛定谔的酒吧 2. 量子酒馆 3. 希尔伯特的饮料 4. 波粒二象性酒吧 5. 能量溢出酒吧 6. 纠缠酒廊 7. 费曼的小酒馆 8. 量子跃迁酒吧 9. 亚当斯的指南酒吧 10. 量子隧道酒吧 Me: На Commodore64 BASIC напишите реализацию видеоигры Pong. ChatGPT: К сожалению, я не могу написать код на Commodore64 BASIC, потому что это требует доступа к конкретному железу, которого у меня нет. Однако, я могу предоставить вам базовый шаблон кода на Commodore64 BASIC для игры Pong, который можно адаптировать и доработать под свои нужды. Copy code 10 REM PONG 20 REM SET UP VARIABLES 30 X=160:Y=100:Z=60 40 S=10:C=1 50 I=5:J=5:K=0:L=0:M=0:N=0:O=0 60 GOTO 1000 70 REM DRAW SCREEN 80 PRINT "{CLR}";:FOR A=1 TO 24:PRINT "{DOWN}";:NEXT A 90 REM DRAW PADDLES 100 PRINT "{HOME}";"{RIGHT}";"{DOWN}";"{UP}";:PRINT "{UP}";:PRINT "{LEFT}";:PRINT "{DOWN}";"{RIGHT}"; 110 REM DRAW BALL 120 PRINT "{HOME}";"{RIGHT}";"O"; 130 REM GET JOYSTICK INPUT 140 Q=PEEK(56320) 150 IF Q=11 THEN K=-1:GOTO 160 160 IF Q=14 THEN K=1:GOTO 170 170 REM MOVE PADDLES 180 I=I+K:J=J+L 190 IF I<=5 THEN I=5 200 IF I>=15 THEN I=15 210 IF J<=5 THEN J=5 220 IF J>=15 THEN J=15 230 REM MOVE BALL 240 X=X+C:Y=Y+O 250 IF Y<=7 THEN O=-O 260 IF Y>=22 THEN O=-O 270 REM COLLISION WITH PADDLES 280 IF X<=5 AND Y>=I-1 AND Y<=I+5 THEN C=1:O=S(Y-I-2) 290 IF X>=30 AND Y>=J-1 AND Y<=J+5 THEN C=-1:O=S(Y-J-2) 300 REM SCORE KEEPING 310 IF X<=0 THEN Z=Z-1:GOTO 350 320 IF X>=35 THEN Z=Z+1:GOTO 350 330 REM REPEAT GAME 340 GOTO 60 350 REM GAME OVER 360 PRINT "{CLR}";"GAME OVER":PRINT "{DOWN}{DOWN}";"FINAL SCORE:";Z 370 END 1000 REM SET UP GAME 1010 X=160:Y=100:Z=60 1020 S=10:C=1 1030 I=5:J=5:K=0:L=0:M=0:N=0:O=0 1040 REM INTRODUCTION SCREEN 1050 PRINT "{CLR}{DOWN}{DOWN}{DOWN}";:PRINT "PONG":PRINT "{DOWN}";:PRINT "PRESS FIRE TO BEGIN":PRINT "{UP}{UP}{UP}";:WAIT 198 1060 IF PEEK(56334)=255 THEN 1060 1070 WAIT 198:GOTO 70 Это базовый шаблон, который необходимо доработать и оптимизировать под ваше железо. Он также может содержать ошибки, которые могут потребовать дополнительной отладки. Если вы не зн --- I'm not going to edit this comment so the BASIC formatting shows up correctly; each line number has a line break before it when I pasted it here. I also can't test if that C64 BASIC will run, as I can't find an emu that accepts paste nor get Apple Script to successfully inject fake key presses, but hey, that Russian contains a disclaimer warning it might be buggy. I will however say that it did an acceptable job (given how little a description I gave it) of the same in JavaScript when I asked it to.
- albertopv 4y agoNot going to happen for many, many jobs, if only for tons of private data not available to ChatGPT, e.g. highly sensitive code not on github.
- ben_w 4y agoPrivate data yes, but I don't think code is that much of a secret special sauce. Apart from anything else, too many engineers moving between different roles and sharing what they learn. Even with medical data, which I at least hope is much better protected, some of that ended up in the training sets used by the current bunch of text-to-image AI.
- albertopv 4y agoYes, but probably that code won't train the AI. Also, I think medical data is less private than a lot of code.
- neel8986 4y agoHow exactly will ChatGPT will revolutionize economy. The best it is doing is summarisation of search result. And search engines exist from 2000s. Yes instead of visiting wikipedia now we get the result directly. At max it can decrease the number of links to click. It is going to change the economy as googles answer box has changed economy, On the other hand the way they hallucinate you still need to double check any thing they tell you. So we can not automate the decision making. Best of luck to you if you want to replace a lawyer or doctor by LLM where they have accuracy of 80%
- pixl97 4y agoWhat is doctors and lawyers failure rate?
- avereveard 4y agoeven if it doesn't provide that much intelligence, it provides intelligence at a surprisingly low cost and intelligence that has almost zero barrier to entry this will do to text task and machine learning task the same thing that squarespace did to web development. that is it will not replace the high end, but suddenly the long tail of businesses will be able to afford the entry price and start getting benefits that would have been totally out of their price range before.
- olivermarks 4y agoSurely not 'chatGPT' but AI & AGI? ChatGPT is ephemeral.
- whyenot 4y agoWhat is so interesting to me about generative AI is that the jobs that are the most difficult to automate are trades like plumbers and electricians. The group that is the most vulnerable is knowledge workers. It’s a lot easier to replace a person with AI when much of what they do is virtual — on a computer screen. Trade jobs are often looked down on by the privileged class who went to some costly and exclusive college. Will that change? There is a lot of experience and training needed to do a trade job well. In fact (having done both), I think in many cases they need more training that a job in tech requiring a college degree. This is going to be really disruptive and I’m very curious to see how it all plays out.
- machinekob 4y agoHow much plumbers will we need in a future? I'm pretty sure that it'll end with oversupply on traders (especially in stagnant economy) if AI will cut most of the knowledge workers the world will have to move into some sort of utopia/dystopia and people will just don't have to work at all or it will be 0.1% vs 99.9% scenario but with brainwashed people cause of social media and maybe AI censorship. But its worst case scenario in my mind AI will make jobs just more specialised and output of knowledge worker a lot faster.
- sublinear 4y ago> AI will make jobs just more specialised and output of knowledge worker a lot faster. If the user is skilled enough at prompt engineering to get good answers (i.e. code that compiles and does what they want) the answers can still be objectively worse than search results for stackoverflow or github in many cases. Seems like the current state of chat bots is that it's slower than either making a regular search or simply just knowing what to write in the first place. Shouldn't be a surprise, but a mid to senior engineer doesn't spend their whole day googling stuff to copy and paste. They read the docs for about 5 minutes and then get things done in the precious couple of hours they have between meetings. I don't think it gets much faster than that. I sincerely doubt the nontechnical people in the meetings would get a good enough answer from ChatGPT that fast and they certainly wouldn't want to slam their head against a wall learning everything the dev already knows, no less in a higher level and imprecise "natural" language.
- afavour 4y agoI’ll openly admit that I’m a cynical person but I’ll believe economic revolution when I see it. The advent of the personal computer also caused lots of huge proclamations of computers doing our jobs while we sit back in sun loungers sipping drinks. Yet somehow, here we are. The people in charge of the AI systems are the same (class-wise at least) as those in charge of the economy so there’s no incentive to rock the boat. I expect AI to be something similar: it’ll change the way many jobs work, hopefully for the better. But people will still be working in sweatshops making clothes because it’ll still be cheaper than the alternative.
- gremlinsinc 4y agoBut do you equate AI to the advent of: A. The internet? B. Electricity? C. The wheel? Personally, it's somewhere between the wheel and electricity in my opinion, or a combination of the industrial revolution/assembly lines and electricity. How much did the wheel revolutionize society?
- the88doctor 4y agoThe economy serves humans as the end users of goods and services. Even if an AI can learn to design a house that is more earthquake-proof than any human design of the same cost, the AI can't decorate the interior without understanding human psychology both at the general level of the average human and the specific level of the human who will be using the house. I didn't realize how much happier I was when I worked next to windows (as opposed to working in the interior of a room) until I was in my mid twenties. How would an AI know to tell me to design my home office with a big window when I didn't even know that was necessary myself? The AI couldn't have learned from me (since I didn't consciously know that), and the AI couldn't have learned that sitting next to windows generated happiness for itself either. That means some other human being would be necessary to input that as a design constraint into the AI's architecture program. The inability of AI to experience human feelings for itself means it will have to rely on humans to help it provide economic goods and services that are maximally useful. That means there will be a role for humans in the economy for quite a long time (possibly forever).
- gremlinsinc 4y ago> The pursuit of human-like capabilities, Brynjolfsson argued, has led to technologies that simply replace people with machines, driving down wages and exacerbating inequality of wealth and income. It is, he wrote, “the single biggest explanation” for the rising concentration of wealth. I think, assuming it doesn't kill us - the faster we get to an economy where only 5-10% of the people are employable, the faster we get to post scarcity, and MORE equality/egalitarianism (if accelerationism doesn't lead to the opposite outcome, walled cities for elites, wastelands for everybody else) ... but the transition... it's going to be bumpy/painful. Part of me is worried, part of me says rip the bandaid off, let's get to UBI, and other programs --as people can't stay rich or get richer if nobody can buy products. What's the point of better productivity at Ford or GM if nobody is buying cars anymore? The world of the next 20 years, is going to change as much as the change from before electricity to the 1920s when it was mainstream. We can't really stop it, even if we tried - other actors good/bad are going to be using AI, it's part of our lives now for better or worse.
- dusted 4y ago"But the fisherman simply went about his daily routine, casting his nets and patiently waiting for the fish to bite." Yeah, revolutionary. (That's GPT-4, by the way)