3 ms·
> His claim was just one of roughly 60,000 that Dopke denied in a single month last year 60,000 / 20 workdays in a month / 8 hours in a workday => this guy rej
by loeg 4y ago
> His claim was just one of roughly 60,000 that Dopke denied in a single month last year
60,000 / 20 workdays in a month / 8 hours in a workday => this guy rejected about 375 claims per hour, on average. Over six claims a minute. He spent less than 10 seconds on each claim, for a full month of work time.
- Centigonal 4y agoLess than 10s/claim is actually an upper bound, since chances are there's meetings, coffee breaks, and other overhead.
- prepend 4y agoI mean supposedly the doctor also approved some so their review rate is even higher.
- SapporoChris 4y ago"A Cigna algorithm flags mismatches between diagnoses and what the company considers acceptable tests and procedures for those ailments." "Cigna said its review system was created to “accelerate payment of claims for certain routine screenings,” This sounds like simple automation with an error rate that is acceptable by Cigna. Of course it's not acceptable to anyone wrongfully denied a claim. Now that's an issue I don't see in the article. How many claims were wrongfully denied? I can't get worked up about the situation when critical information is missing.
- ahi 4y agoThey are not legally allowed to automate this. These cases MUST be reviewed by qualified medical personnel.
- magicalist 4y ago> Now that's an issue I don't see in the article. How many claims were wrongfully denied? Well gee, to actually estimate that you'd need a medical expert to review the claims.
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y agoNot only the automation is a problem. Cigna is the only one that knows the rule set. This forces the patient or biller to try out multiple combination of codes until he strikes told. This is why healthcare is so expensive. Remove cpts and icds and the admin overhead syatem goes away But that requires insurances to be there for catastrophic care only (I.e. reverse lottery) , and this is not palatable with the govt crowd
- colordrops 4y agoThis rate is pretty ridiculous. I wouldn't be surprised if there is automated software or a farm of non-medical staff working behind the name of the doctor, similar to how shady contractors will "rent" the license of a legitimate but retired contractor.
- itsTyrion 4y ago... it literally says in the article they have a program that goes over claims, says deny if it "thinks" it's "not needed" and humans confirm it in batches of 50.
- hotpotamus 4y agoI wonder how many claims a minute GPT4 will be able to achieve?
- CogitoCogito 4y agoDr. Cheryl Dopke should lose her medical license.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoHer employer should be jailed as well, all the way to the top of the company. Such behaviour cannot exist without at least the tacit agreement of everyone higher in the chain of command.
- conductr 4y agoYep. This may be legal but has to be against the hippocratic oath
- 01100011 4y agoSoon, a GPT/LLM will auto-deny an order of magnitude more than that!
- dragonwriter 4y agoThey are already being autodenied, the human is in the loop only for superficial compliance with rules requiring a qualified medical professional “reviewing” before denying.
- conductr 4y agoThis alone should be grounds for a class action lawsuit. It’s ridiculous they do this in an obviously automated way. If they want to raise the bar on requirements of “submitting a claim “ that’s fine, our healthcare admins can figure it out. But patients should be allowed to be dragged through the mud like this.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoIt's funny when it comes to the law including civil disputes, us commoners are always told "oh no the judges look at the intent behind the deal, and consider what a reasonable person would expect" when it comes to explaining why bank errors and such don't work in our favor. No reasonable person would ever enter into a contract for health insurance with a company that would reject their claim after a doctor looks at it for literally 10 seconds, but apparently when it comes to the big end of town, the exact letters of the law become much more important.