3 ms·
In my view, the steel industry deliberately confuses arc furnaces (mostly used for recycling steel - effectively just melting it down) with making new steel in
by londons_explore 4y ago
In my view, the steel industry deliberately confuses arc furnaces (mostly used for recycling steel - effectively just melting it down) with making new steel in blast furnaces.
This lets them do things like claim "steel made in USA" when in fact the steel was made in China, then brought to the USA, melted in an arc furnace, and suddenly it's "made in USA"!
I suspect there are people chucking brand new steel into an arc furnace simply to change its origin country, and to take government subsidies for setting up new 'steel factories'. It also conveniently works around steel import tariffs - because you actually import 'scrap' steel, tariff free.
- simplotek 4y ago> (...) brought to the USA, melted in an arc furnace, and suddenly it's "made in USA"! I don't think this assertion makes sense. Making steel is way more than getting iron and mixing it up with some carbon. You need special manufacturing processes to get specific alloys and treatments to get the properties and reliability you expect. Recycling and importing steel is like importing a raw material. Your comment reads like "This let's them do things like claim burger made in USA when in fact the burger buns were made with corn from Ukraine and meat from Argentina".
- ethbr0 4y agoI'm guessing the implication is that it allows concealment of CO2-intensive new steel production. If you take "raw" steel and process it, you can look green from your operations... ... just ignore the upstream producers using the lowest-cost but carbon-dirty processes.
- akiselev 4y agoRecycling steel in an arc furnace is cheaper and uses less power than making new steel. The only reason we’re not on 100% recycled steel is because demand outstrips supply. Those upstrram processes are more expensive!
- londons_explore 4y agoI don't think anyone is arguing against recycling steel. The argument is against producing new steel, shipping it across the world, and then immediately scrapping and recycling it, as a way to claim it is both green and locally produced.
- credit_guy 4y agoDoes this actually happen, or it's just a hypothetical? (in other words, do you have some links?)
- TheSoftwareGuy 4y agoBut if the recycled steel is cheaper, who would spend a bunch of money to take an expensive input, and create a cheap output? It doesn’t economically make sense
- akiselev 4y agoAbsolutely no one does that. Even the cheapest, dirtiest iron ore from Brazil or Australia can't compete with steel scrap in the US or EU because recycling uses less than quarter of the total power and produces a fifth of the emissions that producing virgin steel does. You can't greenwash something when the green version costs way less than the polluting one. It'll be written on the price tag!
- twic 4y agoBut as you said, demand outstrips supply.
- simplotek 4y ago> and then immediately scrapping and recycling it You seem to be confused. Using steel as a raw material is not "scrapping and recycling". The value of steel in engineering applications is that you can trust that the properties of a particular alloy used to make a particular part will comply with the specs. Steel from China is renowned for being unreliable and failing to comply with standardized properties. https://www.cdmg.com/building-faqs/why-using-cheap-steel-is-unsafe https://www.cdmg.com/building-faqs/why-using-cheap-steel-is-... You avoid that risk by importing steel as a raw material and use that to actually produce reliable steel. If low-quality steel is cheap enough so that after recycling it you can still make a profit then it's a sound business decision and the whole economy benefits.
- simplotek 4y ago> If you take "raw" steel and process it, you can look green from your operations... I'm not sure the people complaining about Chinese steel imports are thinking about environmental footprint. It's all a chain of simplistic economic reasoning to complain that they import a product instead of producing it.