3 ms·
In other words, "suffering is bad and we should prevent it, but we don't know how"? What a brave and profound statement to make! /s
by gruez 4y ago
In other words, "suffering is bad and we should prevent it, but we don't know how"? What a brave and profound statement to make! /s
- andsoitis 4y ago> In other words, "suffering is bad and we should prevent it, but we don't know how"? What a brave and profound statement to make! /s That's not what I'm saying at all. What I am saying is that there probably isn't one solution that would work on every part of the planet and further more that in practical terms there isn't a single "we" on the hook to solve. There are probably many different strategies, from restricting private companies from extracting water at low cost and making huge profits, to building water infrastructure in places where there are none, to desalination, to eradicating cholera, etc. etc. But what I do believe is that ability to pay for water should not be a limiting factor to having access to clean water because it is a basic ingredient of life and so nobody should profit off of access.
- gruez 4y ago>But what I do believe is that ability to pay for water should not be a limiting factor to having access to clean water because it is a basic ingredient of life and so nobody should profit off of access. Do you, as a "über capitalist" also believe the same to be true for food?
- andsoitis 4y agoyes. people will squabble about how much and what quality is minimally required, but I would love to see every society prioritize guaranteeing basic nourishment to not only survive, but to have a healthy mind and body.
- gruez 4y agoMaybe I'm misunderstanding what you meant by "über capitalist", but someone who advocates for total state ownership over food production (which is essentially what you're arguing for, given that you don't want profits) is certainly on the socialist/communist side of most countries' political spectrums, and therefore can hardly be called an "über capitalist".
- MrOwnPut 4y agoYou can support a basic food aid while also supporting private food production. I didn't interpret GP to say "total state ownership over food production". Their keywords were "basic" and "minimally required". That should have told you that they were supporting food programs where basic foods are guaranteed. None of that means they support "total", as you say, nationalization of food production. History has shown us that nationalization of food production leads to the starvation and death of millions. Free market production has led countries to excess foods, such as grain, which can be and is shipped across the world to combat global starvation.
- andsoitis 4y agoPrecisely.
- Ekaros 4y agoI think it is entirely reasonable to tax or even heavily tax private property and profits so that we can supply necessary water, food and shelter to all of the population. Reasonable amount of water and food should be in reach of every citizen. Does not mean production of those have to be privatized, but maybe margins can be limited when it is bought from open market.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoHousing? Healthcare? etc