3 ms·
So say they ban TikTok, and Apple and Google remove it from their app stores. How do they stop people from using the TikTok website instead? I've never used T
by tzs 4y ago
So say they ban TikTok, and Apple and Google remove it from their app stores.
How do they stop people from using the TikTok website instead?
I've never used TikTok other than occasionally clicking a link that takes me to a video on their website, but from what I'm gleaning from a little Googling what using one of their mobile apps gives you really just one big difference:
• You can shoot video from within the app, and add music and do some editing, and upload to TikTok.
If you just use the web you can upload video, but it is up to you to find something to shoot it, add music, and edit.
So...not as convenient for the people creating the content since there will be more steps involving more separate applications, but it doesn't sound like the website will be much of a downgrade for people who just ant to watch.
Also, what happens in a year or two when Apple releases a new version of iOS that allows using third-party stores and side loading to comply with EU regulations? Do we think Apple is going to maintain a separate version of iOS for the EU and the rest of the world, or will they allow the third-party stores and side loading everywhere?
- Zigurd 4y agoThere is a web interface to TikTok. For consuming TikTok it is not quite as fast and fluid as the app, but that's good enough to satisfy the non-creators using it as an entertainment medium.
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoThe convenience of making new content is everything to Tiktok. Tiktok is all about flipping through a constant stream of stuff and spending a very short amount of time viewing it. If users constantly see old videos when they scroll due to no updated content, Tiktok would pretty much die. The userbase does not have the attention span or long-form video culture of YouTube.
- tzs 4y agoWould a separate short video making app work? Something that integrates filming short video, adding music, and editing, along with the ability to automatically upload to your TikTok account (and/or YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, etc accounts)?
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoCreators would love it. Platform owners would hate it.
- grecy 4y agoBan TikTok at the DNS level? Plenty of governments do this for sites like the pirate bay... does the US do it for any sites right now?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoAsk Epic Games the cost of being off the app store. At scale over time TikTok would die.
- mistermann 4y agoI think there's a lot more going on here than most people appreciate - imho, the BIG/REAL reason the US government wants TikTok gone is because of it's potency for propaganda - specifically, just regular people, American and global citizens, communicating with each other in a format that just so happens (by chance basically, but it makes sense in retrospect) to be WAAAAY better for effectively transmitting ideas from one human mind to another human mind. It seems like this is "just" videos, but that's not necessarily correct - it is true that it "is videos", but "it's just videos" presumes that there is no noteworthy metaphysical pheomenon going on.....but if you are on TikTok, and got these congressional hearings into your feed (tons of my feed was yesterday, since I hearted every one that came up), seeing video after video of congress people OBVIOUSLY reading from a coordinated script, OBVIOUSLY lying/acting, the emperor OBVIOUSLY having no clothes.....it is surreal. Video after video of different congress people doing the same thing, literally putting on a performance, demonstrating that American politics IS IN FACT fake, a literal illusion / magic trick, unmistakably....this is DEVASTATING from a geopolitics perspective. And in trying to put this genie back in the bottle, my feeling is that they may have shot themselves in the foot. What I have experienced is being experienced by millions of other people (lots have made videos mocking their politicians, but I don't think many people see through it as much as I, see my "Boiled Frog" reference above) - the cat is out of the bag. A MASSIVE exploit in the armour of the US regime has been revealed, analogous to Luke Skywalker blowing up the Death Star. Nothing so dramatic will happen here at least in the short run, but the idea is now out in the wild, to some degree. And that's why TikTok is so dangerous: it's ability to transmit ideas from the mind of one human being into the mind of another human being - this is The Way. Of course, "duh, that's 'just' communicating, get out of here with your conspiracy theories[1], etc etc etc", I've heard it all before. This is sub-perceptual heuristics not just perceiving reality, but generating reality. Now if THAT idea ever got out into the wild, they'd have even more trouble. May you live in interesting times! [1] One of the most potent remotely callable algorithms that has somehow ended up in the mind of most every single node in this system we're stuck in - one of many. It would be a real shame if people started to figure out how this system runs, if they somehow learned how to think outside of the invisible box that's been built around them. Humans are very much like ChatGPT, it can be observed, in massive quantities - people are going to start noticing things like this, and I think there is a very good chance the puzzle pieces will start to fall into place...and then maybe, the gig will finally be up. If citizens of all nations came to this realization more or less simultaneously, I think it could literally change the world. TikTok may not accomplish it, but ~~the~~ A path to it is now known. Even worse (for those running the show): these large language models are also revealing many interesting nuances about reality that were formerly very difficult if not impossible to see.
- raincole 4y agoI'm sure you're not the target audience of TikTok (which is probably a good thing). > not as convenient for the people creating the content... Yeah, and that little inconvenience is day and night. That's why TikTok got popular at the first place. Convenience. Pepople can always record videos and share them to others since digital camera is a thing.
- aggie 4y agoThat may have been critical to forming the network but not for maintaining it. As long as the consumer UX is good (which is a big assumption I have no idea about), the creators will do whatever they need to to reach that audience. You lose some at the margins but that's probably low-quality content anyway.
- sprucely 4y agoThe web app appears to be deliberately hobbled. It doesn't even give you access to the bookmarks you saved in the mobile app.
- supriyo-biswas 4y agoHave ISPs intercept unencrypted DNS requests as well as drop TLS connections where ClientHello.ServerName ~* '*.tiktok.com'.
- okdood64 4y ago> If you just use the web you can upload video, but it is up to you to find something to shoot it, add music, and edit. If you don't actually use it regularly then you don't know. Their in-app editor tools is best in class for rapid, convenient social media content (as compared to YouTube, Snapchat or Instagram).