3 ms·
Reality can't be wrong, only our understanding or modeling of it can be wrong. So a paradox is either: - our "intuitive" mental model of the world which says o
by jodrellblank 18y ago
Reality can't be wrong, only our understanding or modeling of it can be wrong. So a paradox is either:
- our "intuitive" mental model of the world which says one thing can't become two of the same thing without using any more material, is wrong
- the mathematical model that says you can do that, is wrong
- the mathematical framework on which the model is built, is limited.
In other words, while I can't follow the maths, I would have no problem believing the mathematical weirdness is self consistent because I don't believe it would have any rational link to the real world anyway.
- jodrellblank 18y agoThinking about it a bit more, that a mathematical model created by humans on a mathematical framework created by humans comes out with weird results sometimes - that fact is not even slightly weird or difficult to believe. That such a human model can be as accurate and precise as quantum mechanics is, now that's hard to believe!
- jerf 18y agoYour last paragraph seems to imply that you believe that somebody, somewhere is claiming this result is "real". In fact, nobody claims the theorem has any applicability to "reality", because the real world is quantized. You can't cut an electron in half. (So far as we know.) Everybody knows the theorem isn't real. Now, I'm not just being pedantic here, because the fundamental and obvious failure of the theorem to have any connection to the real world is at the heart of one of the philosophical questions about the nature of math it engenders, along with its good friend the Axiom of Choice. While there's nothing wrong with either thing mathematically, does it really matter when anything that invokes the Axiom of Choice basically just opted out of concrete reality entirely? Basically, I'm saying that the contents of your post are true, but trivial; there's no interesting argument about correspondence to reality to be made. The fun lies at the next level. I have no easy answers for you there. (Personally, I have no problem breaking math into "Things that Might Be Practically Useful" and "Things to Entertain Mathematicians", especially since the latter tends to migrate to the former at quite surprising times, but many people seem to have trouble with giving such a rich meaning to the single word "math".)
- jodrellblank 18y agoI don't see. It doesn't matter a jot when something "just opted out of concrete reality entirely", but it's also not especially interesting. Talking about pink elephants and how they can double in size may be internally consistent in a story, but it's not something that's "true but really difficult to believe in" anymore than "dividing by zero equals infinity" is difficult to believe in. If the fun is at the next level, perhaps that's where I ought to go...