4 ms·
Freedom of religion doesn't mean "freedom to take any random thing you like and claim that it's a religion", though.
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
Freedom of religion doesn't mean "freedom to take any random thing you like and claim that it's a religion", though.
- yamazakiwi 4y agoReligions are claims so I don't see a difference if the person truly believes it. I don't know if your definition of religion is important to what people consider their religion.
- brewdad 4y agoOk but what happens when my religion says no one should be allowed to live past age 50? I have a "strongly held" belief that all of the world's problems are caused by older people and removing them from the planet is a necessity. There have to be some limits on what is allowed to be a protected religious belief. Otherwise we get into the realm of ranking which human rights matter more and that path leads to madness. The path of "silly" religious beliefs is no better. My religion requires that Coke Zero be the one true soda. If the employee cafeteria offers sodas, you must accommodate my beliefs by serving Coke Zero. Also, Pepsi is the root of all evil and must never be allowed in the same room as Coke products.
- yamazakiwi 4y agoOf course we as humans should create limits to protect ourselves from crazies but let's be clear; the "silly" religious beliefs are generally nothing but an inconvenience. That is completely different than thinking outsiders of your religion should die. My point is that those that hold religious beliefs would ignore limits if they targeted their beliefs anyway. Additionally, the action of defining what is and is not religion is usually done by those with self-righteous attitudes. Humans regularly decide if they like someone based on what they believe and an unbiased definition will never be possible in our current state.
- ndsipa_pomu 4y agoUltimately, religions are about the behaviour of the members of that religion. Attempting to make others conform to your own religion is generally a bad idea and leads to violence and wars. If you truly believe that over-50s are against the will of <insert-deity>, then it is up to you to remove yourself when you hit that age. Similarly, it is up to you to only consume Coke Zero and not be tempted by the evils of other sodas. If you feel strongly enough about it then you boycott any cafeterias that provide alternatives. Religions that prescribe the behaviour of non-members are merely a means to control other people and such religions should be shunned by society due to the historical problems that they have caused.
- yamazakiwi 4y agoI completely agree and would add that if I am not supposed to drink soda, I would appreciate additional drink options for beverages at work, but I would not expect the company to ban drinks I am choosing not to have based on my beliefs. It is my free will that allows me to follow my religious teachings. When I affect the free will of others based on what is ideal for me, I am being selfish.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoBecause claims that you don't believe aren't your religion. And you don't get religious protection for things that aren't your religion. I don't get Fridays off just because Muslims do, because I'm not Muslim.
- runlevel1 4y agoFor the purpose of argument: If it's a sincerely held belief with the strength of traditional religious views, then what's the difference?
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago"Sincerely held belief" is the rub. If I don't like Windows, and think maybe I could get out of it if I claim that it's against my religion, that's not a "sincerely held belief". It may be a sincerely held preference, but that's not the same thing. If I have sincerely held beliefs that, say, closed-source software is immoral, and therefore it's morally wrong for me to use it, that's at least arguably religious. The problem is to tell the two apart, especially when someone in the first category knows that they have to sound like they're in the second in order to pull it off. Still, my point stands: Just wanting something, even wanting it strongly, and finding a way to wrap that in religious language, does not qualify for "freedom of religion" protection.
- getoffmyyawn 4y agoI can simply claim that my religion was revealed to me in a vision in which a supreme being told me personally to never use Windows or I will suffer damnation. You can't ask me to prove it unless you are going to ask the same of every person claiming religion by revelation. And even so, there is no way to prove someone did or didn't have a personal vision. Seems like a very slippery slope.
- ndsipa_pomu 4y agoPeople should have the right to practice their own religion/beliefs regardless of whether other people consider it to be sincerely held or not. However, that doesn't mean that they have to follow the requirements themselves. If a religion prevents a person from working on specific days, then that person shouldn't be forced to work on those days, but similarly, a workplace shouldn't be forced to employ them if they can't arrange a suitable compromise (e.g. they don't work Saturdays, but they can cover all the Sundays).
- evandale 4y agoThat's exactly what religion is though. Pick a random thing, worship it, call it a religion. Moreover, the random thing doesn't even have to exist!
- CodeWriter23 4y ago> Freedom of religion doesn't mean "freedom to take any random thing you like and claim that it's a religion", though. First Amendment “Congress shall make no law respecting establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people to peaceably assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances” IANAL but pretty sure that means we do have the "freedom to take any random thing you like and claim that it's a religion”