3 ms·
BNPL targets people who wouldn't otherwise qualify for a credit card or personal loan. Here's a simple test – if everyone paid their balances on time and in fu
by paxys 4y ago
BNPL targets people who wouldn't otherwise qualify for a credit card or personal loan.
Here's a simple test – if everyone paid their balances on time and in full, credit card companies would still survive. BNPL would not.
- crazygringo 4y ago> if everyone paid their balances in full and on time, credit card companies would still survive. That goes against my understanding. Do you have a source for that? I'm pretty sure credit cards make their money off of interest. It's not from the interchange fees from people who pay their balance each month, as those often go straight back to consumers through rewards programs, and just administration costs generally. The card I use most has no annual fee but 2% cash back on everything.
- scottLobster 4y agoThe ratio depends on the credit card issuer, but often times the rewards are just a fraction of the fees charged. American Express in particular makes more of their money from transaction fees and membership fees than interest. https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets/012715/how-american-express-makes-its-money.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets/012715/how-ame...
- crazygringo 4y agoYes, but American Express is very much an outlier and always has been. It's also why many shops don't accept Amex, because it charges higher transaction fees.
- nunez 4y agoAMEX allows you to have a rotating credit line now on those cards.
- soco 4y agoCashback is not really a thing around me (Switzerland) and other rewards are just practical jokes - like overpriced black socks subscriptions offered slightly less overpriced. Yet credit cards thrive.
- crazygringo 4y agoYes but interchange fees are far lower in Europe. In the US they're around 2%. In Europe they're more like 0.3%, which is why cashback/rewards aren't a thing. My point is that interchange fees aren't where credit cards make money, it's on the interest of people who don't pay in full.
- medvezhenok 4y agoSome cards like AMEX Gold/Platinum don't allow you to carry a balance at all, and make most of their money via interchange fees. There is a spread between rewards provided and actual fees (fees are closer to 2.5-4%, rewards usually top out around ~2%)
- finfrastrcuture 4y agoI'm by no means a BNPL advocate, but this isn't true. BNPL providers have proliferated because they offer the merchant a new avenue to win new businesses (aka get consumers who wouldn't buy to buy) and in exchange receive a heft % commission of the purchase, much higher than card interchange. They also are fighting to reposition themselves as marketplaces in their own right, and earn associated merchant marketing fees, rather than be just a button a check out. According to the BNPL industry, fees and interest make up a small portion of their overall revenues. Whether that's wholly accurate is another story. In sum, they would indeed exist. Its more a question of how large and profitable they would be. Check out Klarna's financial reporting to get a sense of this: https://www.klarna.com/international/press/klarna-reports-fourth-quarter-results-and-2022-annual-report/ https://www.klarna.com/international/press/klarna-reports-fo...
- thwayunion 4y ago> According to the BNPL industry, fees and interest make up a small portion of their overall revenues. Whether that's wholly accurate is another story. It may also be irrelevant; I'm more interested in their forward-looking forecasts than their current revenue sources.