3 ms·
My experience was different than yours. I had an existential crisis, and it only got worse the more I used it. To be clear, I did not think ChatGPT was ready to
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
My experience was different than yours. I had an existential crisis, and it only got worse the more I used it. To be clear, I did not think ChatGPT was ready to replace me now (and, mind you, I only used the 3.5 version of ChatGPT). But it was so easy for me to see how in just a few years it can accelerate its pace of learning.
I was discussing a bug with a colleague, so for curiosity's sake I decided to plug a similar question into ChatGPT. I was quite impressed with the solution it gave, and interestingly, it had the same subtle bug that our code had. What blew me away is that when I pointed out the bug, ChatGPT fixed the code by itself. On one hand I felt "phew, at least it needed me to point out the bug", but then I thought "I just (perhaps stupidly) provided training data so that down the road ChatGPT would get it right the first time."
- creeble 4y agoBut did you? Does it store and re-train on all of that input?
- groestl 4y agoIt will, rest assured. There is a reason that you have a history of chats in the free version, and it's not because it's so handy for you.
- matesz 4y agoWow how about people using paid api. Can OpenAI retrain on data provided there? ps. ChatGPT: "You should only share information that you are comfortable with being stored or potentially used as training data."
- sharemywin 4y agoThis video kind of scared me even more. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0dBq9sKTKTY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0dBq9sKTKTY
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoHoly fuck. I don't see how people can see stuff like that and say "oh, it's just a fancy Markov chain generator" or "it can't reason". Even if that stuff is nominally true, how can people not be totally blown away by this? Just a couple years ago I think people would have been amazed that it can have totally natural, grammatically correct conversations. Moreover, for nearly 3/4 of a century the scientific community has pretty much coalesced on only using the output to define intelligence (aka the Turing Test). While I understand that ChatGPT may not 100% be there yet, I see no reason to believe that all this interaction people are having with it won't be fed back into it to drastically improve its responses over time.
- jltsiren 4y ago> Moreover, for nearly 3/4 of a century the scientific community has pretty much coalesced on only using the output to define intelligence (aka the Turing Test). It's more like the scientific community has spent the last 50+ years criticizing the Turing Test. Passing as a human is a nice engineering goal, but there has been a lot of doubt of using input/output behavior as the only measure of intelligence. If you took a basic AI class before machine learning became popular, the chances are the class spent more time on the criticism than on the test itself.
- ChatGTP 4y agoDid you watch the video ? You got punk’d
- magpi3 4y agoI watched the video. Chat GPT is impressive, but exactly as the person creating the video mentioned, the deeper you get into the project, the easier it is for Chat GPT to get confused. And Chat GPT has no idea it's confused. You have to point out each individual error, and the Chat GPT scans for it, makes a correction, and potentially introduces more errors. I don't see how you could use it with any confidence on a project with sufficient complexity. EDIT And here is something else that just struck me. The errors in the code are obvious the minute you run the program, particularly in the beginning when the population dies off after day 1. Chat GPT is apparently incapable of running the simulation to check if its code actually makes sense. It needs someone to tell it. Think about that for a second. Can you imagine a fellow programmer handing you a piece of code without bothering to try to run it first? I can see Chat GPT as an advanced assistant who can save a programmer a LOT of time right now, but definitely nothing more than that.
- IanCal 4y agoYou can also just ask it to check if its result matches the spec or check it for bugs. I've done that and had it find things without me telling it what was wrong.