3 ms·
> I'm originally from a country that has proportional representation. Let me tell you - it's a total disaster. Your former country may be seem a disaster to yo
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> I'm originally from a country that has proportional representation. Let me tell you - it's a total disaster.
Your former country may be seem a disaster to you, but it has been studied fairly extensively, and, among modern democracies, proportionality is very much associated with both positiive measures of function and with positive perceptions of function from those who are subject to them.
> Two-party states are better in that the population can punish party A by voting for party B and vice versa
In a mulitparty system you can pubnish any party by voting for any other party, whereas in a two party system you can only punish part A bv voting for party B, which means a strategy that makes both parties look worse but the other one by slightly more is a winning PR strategy. The results are predictable.
> The other serious issue is that each party has a completely unaccountable and opaque system for deciding on a list of representatives.
That's not a product of proportional representation, its a product of one particular system of achieving it, “party list proportional”.
Most PR advocates in the US (or Canada) are advocating systems with by-district elections, which mean you still have locally-elected by-name specific representatives, either Single Transferrable Vote (almost always this in the US) or Mixed Member Proportional.
- FredPret 4y agoVoting for party B only punishes party A if it increases the chance that A loses an election to B. Which seems like a no-brainer, but I found most of my erstwhile fellow citizens voting not for B but for B, C, D, ad infinitum. Because parties B - Z are now tiny parties, they get no momentum, and nobody votes for them... because nobody else votes for them. Leaving a huge voting block for A, who happily keeps ruling regardless of being unpopular with all but 30% of the population. Better to have two parties that are balanced on a knife edge, and they have to perform or they lose.
- oehpr 4y agoI'm reading though your responses trying to figure out what mysterious force is present in this hypothetical proportional representation country that prevents a majority subset of parties B - Z from forming a coalition. Can't figure it out. On the assumption that Party A just simply has the majority still? This objection lakes cogency, so maybe you could make this general objection more concrete by citing a country that finds itself in your abstract scenario?