12 ms·
America’s online privacy problems are much bigger than TikTok
- Overtonwindow 4y agoSocial media really has become more harmful than good for society. Privacy is just a new buzzword. https://archive.is/Y4RsD https://archive.is/Y4RsD
- thricegreat 4y agoit's not necessarily social media itself but the underlying structure and the ways it's misused that makes it harmful. it says more about american values than social media itself.
- imwithstoopid 4y ago[flagged]
- syzarian 4y agoChina has been waging a cyber war with the U.S. for some time now. The conflict is already existing . China is not a media created adversary. They limit the types of U.S. businesses that can operate in China and it it’s not unreasonable that we respond in kind.
- Avshalom 4y agoneither of those mean much with regards to tiktok specifically though.
- proudeu 4y agoLooks like hatred instilling propaganda worked well on you
- syzarian 4y agoIt’s possible that I’m a victim of propaganda and it’s possible you are. The way to determine who is more likely to have fallen for propaganda is to compare respective beliefs against known facts. It is indisputable that Chinese hackers have stolen U.S. technology secrets and that China prevents/restricts who can operate there much more so than the U.S. Given this and China’s overt human rights violations on a grand scale in the western part of the country it’s clear that a conflict exists as a clash of both culture and national security.
- imwithstoopid 4y ago[flagged]
- myko 4y ago> willingness to engage in a war the US and Taiwan might very well lose (badly) with Americans dying Based on Russia's performance in Ukraine and China's military might seemingly less than Russia's I doubt the US Navy has a tough time keeping China out of Taiwan, let alone the entire military might of the US
- imwithstoopid 4y agoI recommend looking up the Battle of the Chosin Resevoir....worst military defeat ever suffered by the US (worse than Bastogne imho), the Chinese didn't even have one gun per soldier...some didn't have boots...they DEMOLISHED the best equipped army in the world (and this was during Korea when the US military was the unquestioned top dog) and btw if you are going to go look at casualty counts, don't bother, its well understood that the Chinese lost ten men for every US soldier killed...they still won
- myko 4y agoHard to definitively claim victory for either side in the battle you mention. The Chinese outnumbered the US 4 to 1 and still got blasted, the Chinese unit was out of commission for months following the battle while the US forces maintained unit integrity. In the years since the gulf between capabilities has grown, and especially seeing how Russia can't crush Ukraine using castoff NATO gear China will be wise to not poke the bear.
- janalsncm 4y agoThis isn’t about actual harms or actual privacy risks. Facebook directly interfered in the 2016 election and no laws changed, no one went to prison, Mark Zuckerberg had a few cringe moments in front of Congress and then they pretty much forgot about him. So the message I’m getting is, no actual existential harm will come to a social media company that allows that to happen.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Facebook directly interfered in the 2016 election Is this a reference to Cambridge Analytica? Their electoral effects were mostly dismissed.
- pessimizer 4y agoMostly because they were exaggerated claims from Cambridge Analytica's own marketing material.
- SllX 4y agoThat’s because you cannot lay the result of the 2016 election at Facebook’s doorstep. Functionally they were used for five things: 1. Political advertising, which is what all campaigns engage in. 2. Discussions of the election by our own citizens, sometimes critical, more often an echo chamber or virtual throat stabbing contest. 3. News about the election which is free name recognition for all of the candidates the media considers worth talking about. 4. Market research by the campaigns. 5. A platform for foreign propaganda including psy-ops, which is bad and should be addressed, but not even close to bad enough to effect the outcome of an election as much as many might want to think that it did. You can’t really pin the 2016 election on Facebook specifically since any information on there competes with any information not from there and there was a lot more not-Facebook information involved in that election, but Facebook by that point made for a nice scapegoat that nobody has any real sympathy for. Remember too that it was real Americans that actually filled in their ballots that decided the election for every single candidate on the list.
- pessimizer 4y ago[flagged]
- Avshalom 4y agowell I mean we're doing it to them too. it's not paranoid to assume large countries are engaged in just-barely-sub-causus-belli levels of shit against each other. But that doesn't make trying to ban or force the sale of tiktok anything more than a depressing/transparent sinophobic propoganda exercise.
- syzarian 4y agoIt’s not paranoia to think that China and the U.S. are engaged in a cyber conflict. For quite some time China has engaged in cyber warfare to steal American technological secrets and to spy on the U.S. We spy on them. Both nations are adversaries of each other and it’s not paranoia to recognize the blatantly obvious.
- imwithstoopid 4y ago[flagged]
- syzarian 4y agoI don’t live in the world of extremes that you do. There is room for other emotions between hate and love. In arrogance neo-liberals thought China embracing market reforms and “free” trade would liberalize/weaken the CCP. It did not work. We have long passed the point whereby China can be viewed as anything other than an adversary. China has engaged in state sponsored hacking and theft of American technological secrets and in a cyber war with the U.S. It’s not a conventional war.
- Atlas22 4y agoDo you believe the same for the US involvment in the ukraine conflict? The wars in the middle east? Vietnam? Korea? and so on? If not, what differences made you arrive at a different conclusion? To be clear I'm not implying you are wrong in terms of a conflict is being setup with China, just curious if your criticism is consistently applied. Many if not most news outlets are saying exactly what you are, but only make this distinction for China.
- imwithstoopid 4y agoI'm more than happy to go through that list, but I suspect I will be downvoted anyway for merely explaining my own beliefs (which is what you are asking for) - Ukraine - a contrived proxy war and we are very generously and bravely assisting in the avoidable deaths of as many Ukrainians as possible. I'll go even further - neoliberal support in the US is comes from this notion that Trump and Putin are penpals, so if we punch Putin, its like punching Trump - Middle East Wars - worst geopolitical decision since ww2, probably ruined the US forever - Vietnam - a massive mistake...and I mean MISTAKE. this was not evil on the US part, but a legit misunderstanding. We mistook a civil war for a Red Wave - Korea - neutral...but it was the last time we faced off against China militarily and although we massively outgunned them, they probably delivered the single worst military defeat in US history (Chosin Resevoir). By any rational assessment we should have demolished the Chinese, instead they demolished us.
- Atlas22 4y agoThank you for explaining, I certainly wont downvote (not that I know how to anyways). Sorry in advance if you get nuked just for answering my question. Those are certainly opinions that seem consistent to me and are not just the usual parroting of <choose a media outlet> that seems to be so prevalent now. You've restored my faith in the free thinking public just a little bit today, so thanks.
- stevenjgarner 4y agoLOL. Are you sure this arhive.is url is not in violation of copyright? - see "Judge Decides Against Internet Archive" [1] on HN today [2] [1] https://file770.com/judge-decides-against-internet-archive/ https://file770.com/judge-decides-against-internet-archive/ [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35297117 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35297117
- micromacrofoot 4y agoCongress barely understands the internet, let alone the sheer amount of privacy that's being given up to use it. They just happened to have TikTok in the crosshairs because of the fear of China. The broken clock strikes again.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoWeChat (a far more pernicious threat) was also in the crosshairs but then they just forgot about it. This is all just a performance to make a show of "doing something". Domestic companies are doing the same manipulative invasion as the Chinese apps. Any regulation would hurt the surveillance capitalism business model.
- pb7 4y agoWeChat is almost entirely used by Chinese people. It doesn't have broad penetration in the US unlike TikTok.
- eloisius 4y agoI think that threat was more specific to Chinese-Americans who use the app to stay in touch with family
- ridgered4 4y agoThat doesn't sound like something that powerful US corporations are that worried about so I'm surprised we talked about it at all.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoIt's a national security threat. WeChat is used to manipulate Chinese Americans in sensitive positions.
- henrikschroder 4y ago
- janalsncm 4y agoIt’s pretty simple for me, really. Either forced technology transfers are bad or they’re not. Forcing TikTok to be sold to a U.S. company, which Bytedance will if given no other option, is a forced technology transfer.
- SllX 4y agoThey are bad. That fact also has to be weighted against the completely one-sided nature of social networks between the PRC and United States where American social networks are firewalled from PRC subjects in the mainland but still made use of by the Party and Government there if it assists them in propaganda abroad. This is not an equal exchange founded on principles of free trade and respect for any kind of free speech. So it is not simple either. This (probable) technology transfer shouldn’t be happening but not because this shouldn’t now happen; we should never have been in this position to begin with but we are.
- yamtaddle 4y agoExactly. That kind of unequal ruleset isn't free trade, and it's not a good idea to permit it unless you're trying to subsidize the development of a foreign state (or, if you simply have no leverage to stop it without harming yourself way more than it's worth). Responding in kind is absolutely appropriate, depending on what you're trying to accomplish. It's ridiculous (and unpopular, in a pretty bipartisan fashion, among actual voters) that we've allowed China to "defect" on trade matters this long, without pushing back hard.
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoOverall, China is not "defecting" on trade. American companies have a very large presence in the Chinese market - moreso than Chinese companies in the American market. Apple is the largest smartphone brand in China. GM is a major car brand in China. China has bought huge numbers of Boeing airplanes. I could go down the list, but you get the point. Social media is a special case, because China has political censorship, which Facebook and Google were unwilling to go along with.
- learn_more 4y agoChina's ability to influence US mass psychology via TikTok is a greater threat than the privacy considerations.
- nailer 4y agoThat's a legitimate concern. We've recently had examples of the US government influencing US mass psychology via Twitter, including examples where Twitter was asked to suppress information the government stated was factually correct. The CCP is trash, and the US government is far better (it has elections, for one thing) but I suggest we should be concerned about any attempt to manipulate the populace.
- ryandrake 4y agoBeing a representative democracy, the USA's critical weakness is that it is ruled by stupid people that are voted in by the stupid people they represent. So yea, the US government is better but dumb, and it is vulnerable to misinformation and manipulation. Our global rivals know this. It shouldn't be a huge surprise that we're being (at best) pen-tested (and at worst) attacked through things like tiktok and troll farms.
- JPws_Prntr_Fngr 4y agoIt's ruled by monied people, who manufacture consent amongst the stupid people partly by convincing them that the executive and legislative branches are somehow answering to the stupid people, and not the monied people. This works, because we're stupid.
- waboremo 4y agoSure but the obsession regarding China is leaving everyone vulnerable and blind to the methods being utilized by everyone else. It's not as if TikTok is using some alien technology here that nobody else has access to. Cambridge Analytica anyone? Did we all just forget? That wasn't even Chinese influence and still it had tremendous impact on the US (and how her citizens view each other).
- 4y ago
- abeppu 4y agoSo the point is that actually adopting data privacy laws is politically difficult but shouting about tiktok is cheap. But why can we not make the data privacy issues less contentious politically? I feel like it should be possible to have a cop-out, like "Online services doing business in the USA must offer US-based users data and privacy rights which are at least as strict as those of any other national jurisdiction in which the service does business." The tag line for press appearances would be "Americans using online services should have just as much control over their data as Europeans." The line for industry lobbyists is that by effectively adopting GDPR, multinationals don't actually have a meaningfully increased compliance cost.
- sleepybrett 4y agoYes but maybe shouting about tiktok allows the next conversation to happen. 'TikTok was very bad, but we should be asking ourselves if even american companies should have this much insight into our citizens'.
- ketchupdebugger 4y agoThese companies are saying they are committed to safeguarding user data by spending $X dollars on a privacy project. In reality this is just companies policing themselves. They can always circumvent this in the future and just claim there is a bug with the privacy code. Without any form of legislation or regulatory body from the government there are literally no consequences. Getting grilled on capitol hill is just optics, looks good for the camera. Congress would literally need to spin out something like the SEC but for online privacy, but I dont see that happening.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI don't know how to untangle it. It's obviously possible- BAE Systems Inc. (an American defense contractor) is owned by BAE Systems plc. (a British company). It's doable when you keep everything separate, only hire US citizens, add lots of locked doors, and put people in jail if they leak. I can't picture this working with data that's not considered classified. I'm wondering if it's not about the data at all. It's about who gets to control the information space. They don't even have to delete information critical of China, just weigh it down so it's essentially never seen.
- qqtt 4y agoThe thing about politics is that it is the art of compromise. I think it makes sense for policies to discuss the foreign influence angle separately from the domestic influence angle. Further, it makes sense to sub-divide the foreign influence angle along certain dimensions, such as, generally friendly allies (like the British) versus adversarial powers (like China). Dividing problems these ways makes the conversations easier to happen, and from a political perspective, legislation tends to happen with a scalpel rather than a knife. People always seem to want to say "if X is a problem, why don't we talk about Y instead" - in this case, if data sharing is a problem, why don't we talk about the bigger problem? The issue when it comes to politics is that the system is almost by design resistant to big sweeping changes. There is a lot of value in continuing to have conversations about privacy. About domestic privacy. About foreign privacy. And all the sub-divisions possible along those lines. The perfect is the enemy of the good, especially in politics. Instead of seeing certain targeted privacy legislation (like potentially against TikTok) as bad, see it as part of a larger conversation and movement towards tougher privacy legislation. As public sentiment turns more and more towards privacy, we can continue to evolve other dimensions of the problem space - including domestic.
- tzs 4y agoSo say they ban TikTok, and Apple and Google remove it from their app stores. How do they stop people from using the TikTok website instead? I've never used TikTok other than occasionally clicking a link that takes me to a video on their website, but from what I'm gleaning from a little Googling what using one of their mobile apps gives you really just one big difference: • You can shoot video from within the app, and add music and do some editing, and upload to TikTok. If you just use the web you can upload video, but it is up to you to find something to shoot it, add music, and edit. So...not as convenient for the people creating the content since there will be more steps involving more separate applications, but it doesn't sound like the website will be much of a downgrade for people who just ant to watch. Also, what happens in a year or two when Apple releases a new version of iOS that allows using third-party stores and side loading to comply with EU regulations? Do we think Apple is going to maintain a separate version of iOS for the EU and the rest of the world, or will they allow the third-party stores and side loading everywhere?
- Zigurd 4y agoThere is a web interface to TikTok. For consuming TikTok it is not quite as fast and fluid as the app, but that's good enough to satisfy the non-creators using it as an entertainment medium.
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoThe convenience of making new content is everything to Tiktok. Tiktok is all about flipping through a constant stream of stuff and spending a very short amount of time viewing it. If users constantly see old videos when they scroll due to no updated content, Tiktok would pretty much die. The userbase does not have the attention span or long-form video culture of YouTube.
- tzs 4y agoWould a separate short video making app work? Something that integrates filming short video, adding music, and editing, along with the ability to automatically upload to your TikTok account (and/or YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, etc accounts)?
- robg 4y agoYeah, failing to see how TikTok is any different or worse than Facebook or Google. Could someone enlighten me?
- everly 4y agoCommon arguments are that those two you listed are American-owned; that China bans US tech giants; that the CCP has outsized control of Chinese companies (and the data that they collect); and that TikTok's algorithm purposefully promotes content that will result in an uneducated, divided population in countries outside of China. I am not saying that those are true or that I agree with them, but those seem to be the typical arguments.
- robg 4y agoReally helpful, thank you. Still don’t see the problem, other than the need to educate kids on digital hygiene. But like anything, I bet they already know the harms of overconsumption.
- rcpt 4y ago> kids Not sure it's just kids
- WeylandYutani 4y agoI decided on a "paradigm shift" into a healthy lifestyle about 10 years ago. Cut down on American media and culture. I was an adult who thought drinking coke was normal. Now I drink water.
- sumedh 4y ago> Still don’t see the problem China can access some target in the US who is on tictok and get their realtime location.
- t-writescode 4y ago
- zackmorris 4y agoI don't know how I didn't know this, but today I learned from nickdrom on TikTok that you can type in the name of anyone in congress to see which (social media) companies they invest in: https://www.capitoltrades.com https://www.capitoltrades.com Is it any surprise that they want to ban the tool that not only is the biggest competitor for their investments - which pay them hundreds of millions of dollars - but also tells its users where to find the very corruption that they try so hard to cover up?
- SllX 4y agoTikTok can offer that feature because Congressional investments are public information. Do you want to try testing that feature out on the upper echelons of the CCP?
- p_j_w 4y agoWhat an absurd thing to say. What's that got to do with GPs point? Should we ignore this criticism of congress because it's not allowed in China?
- SllX 4y agoI think you need to start with making a case that it’s a problem that members of Congress make investments at all, including into social media companies since making investments and making investments specifically into social media companies are likely not severable disputes. I don’t think there’s a strong enough argument to make there, nor was one attempted. It looks bad, there’s probably a conflict of interest, but a conflict of interest over people who are regularly in conflict with each other doesn’t keep me up at night. It is a problem that we have an unequal exchange with the PRC over social media companies, and that the situation with American businesses under American law and situation with PRC businesses under PRC law subject to the Politburo of the CCP are equivalent, and shouldn’t be ignored by Congress because they’ll look bad or look like hypocrites. They already look bad and like hypocrites on a daily basis, but they still have a responsibility to the American people to investigate what appears to be an asset of the PRC government that only appears to be a private business operating in the American market and address it through law if necessary. Don’t forget these are the same people who spirited away Jack Ma until he toed the party line. There is no such thing as a private corporation in the PRC whilst it is subject to the CCP’s political regime. Congress sucks, but it is a notable distinction that despite how much they suck, they also make their investments public information per laws they chose to pass.
- RobotToaster 4y agoCase in point, the Washington post has 17 different ad trackers and 30 third party cookies... https://themarkup.org/blacklight?url=www.washingtonpost.com https://themarkup.org/blacklight?url=www.washingtonpost.com
- juniordev7 4y agoWSJ let's ads and opinions pieces with full of lies published but their tagline is democracy dies in darkness. Everyone of these think they are the great champions of Humam rights and democracy but in reality all are bad
- RobotToaster 4y agoThe best reason to ban tiktok is to teach zoomers how to sideload apps.
- isopede 4y agoCan somebody explain to me how banning TikTok is not obviously unconstitutional purely on first amendment grounds?
- advisedwang 4y agoDespite media portrayals, virtually every constitutional question has at the core a conflict where different rights or different parts of the constitution conflict. In that case you can't absolutely follow every constitutional dictum because they are mutually exclusive. To some extent legal principals can be used to resolved these conflicts, but they provide huge maneuvering space for political machinations. In this case, there's a conflict between the first amendment on one side and the congressional power to regulate foreign relations and largely judicially constructed executive powers around national security. Of course there's a very strong legal argument you can make that the first amendment clearly trump the congressional power, and the national security powers are (to me) obvious bullshit from the outset. But this is largely irrelevant because it's much more convenient for all branches of government to pretend that this it's a gray area and decide it how they wish.
- inconceivable 4y agothere's plenty of precedent for just throwing the bill of rights out the window for asian americans. 99% of americans simply don't care, or actively encourage it. the supreme court agrees. look up the case law. so why not? nobody will ever receive any significant pushback for throwing them under the bus whenever it's convenient. they might even say "it's for their own safety." the reality on the ground is the only reality that matters. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_Exclusion_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_Exclusion_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_Americans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_America... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wen_Ho_Lee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wen_Ho_Lee <-- taiwanese, lol. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_Initiative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_Initiative
- Kon-Peki 4y ago> throwing the bill of rights out the window for asian americans. 99% of americans simply don't care, or actively encourage it. Since 7.2% of Americans self-identify their ethnicity as Asian, I guess what you are saying is that a minimum of 70-80% of Asian-Americans actively encourage the removal of their own rights. I find that a little hard to believe...
- nektro 4y agothe issue with Tiktok is China, not privacy concerns
- idiotsecant 4y agoRespectfully, that doesn't make much sense. If we're worried about bad things an app can do why don't we make legislation prohibiting apps from doing those bad things? If your model is that bad things are OK if American companies can do them and bad if Chinese companies do them then you still end up getting abused, it's just by Americans in stead of China. Radical suggestion: stop everyone from doing bad things.
- conanbatt 4y agoProbably so, but while you are thinking of those details, a country that sends people to gulags and internment camps is collecting data at scale of important people, their families and the people that work around them. I personally struggle understanding adults installing this app at all, and the fact that it targets mostly oblivious youngsters is pervasive.
- mrkurt 4y agoi think the argument is: TikTok is a tool China will use to push propaganda. The problem is that a nation state is using a viral, addictive app for its own purposes. So the thing to stop everyone from is "letting a maybe-hostile foreign power push an agenda via a software platform." I don't think there's easy to ban behavior here.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- another_story 4y agoHow do you know what bad things will be done? Do we have laws against tweaking an algorithm to display more anti-American videos or videos on eating Tidepods or other harmful things? How do you even prove it? We can easily react to American companies doing something like this, but how easy is it to go after a company which is based in another country and has been hostile towards America and American business for decades?
- Karunamon 4y agoThere is something I don't understand about the legal/political (theatrical?) wrangling surrounding TikTok: Can't they just sanction the parent company if they want to kill it that badly? Control of the sanctioned entities list is under the executive branch, so all they have to do is place Bytedance on that list; no CDN in the country or App Store is allowed to do business with them, TikTok is gone overnight. The website would probably be accessible and there is always the sideloading gambit but it would perform like crap. What am I missing?
- supriyo-biswas 4y agoUnlike the Huawei and ZTE sanctions, I believe they do not have strong evidence or reasoning for Bytedance, which is why all that politicians can do is being angry at Tiktok for their addictive algorithm and their China-based ownership, and realistically only the latter because "addictive algorithms" are everywhere, including FB.
- black_13 4y ago[dead]