3 ms·
It's a pity the keyboard design never seriously improves even for the niche laptops. Like, the space to the sides is useless here, but if you could split the k
by eviks 4y ago
It's a pity the keyboard design never seriously improves even for the niche laptops.
Like, the space to the sides is useless here, but if you could split the keyboard and move that space to to the middle - well, know you've moved one step closer towards more ergonomic typing! Or better yet, you could move all those pinky keys there so that instead of moving your right pinky to hit backspace you'd just move your right index finger
The huge space is also a waste
etc., etc.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoYou might finally get your wish. This laptop is the first laptop designed to allow the keyboard to be upgraded, with fully open specifications.
- pimterry 4y agoI don't know if the standard keyboard they ship with will change, but the flexible layout here does open a lot of space for keyboard experimentation and alternative options in future. The Framework CEO says there are already prototypes of an alternative ortholinear keyboard option (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35280168 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35280168) and split keyboard like you describe is totally possible here too (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35283252 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35283252)
- eviks 4y agoThanks for the links, wasn't aware of that, great to see that Input Module innovation come to fruition
- nrp 4y agoWe see interesting use cases for the small modules on the left and right as well if you are not some who wants to slide the keyboard to the left and put a numpad on the right. We’re showing a prototype of an LED Matrix that can be used for low res information display, but other things like a row of extra buttons, a narrow LCD, a capacitive slider, and others are possible too. As a sibling comment noted, it is also possible for a module developer to create a full width keyboard with a different layout.
- CarVac 4y agoAs I mentioned yesterday, I really hope that it becomes possible to DIY designs, whether with thin-enough modular scissor keys, or by opening the thickness requirements of the keyboard. Perhaps there could be alternate tall hinges and a thicker bezel filling the gap to make room for discrete keyswitches without sacrificing thickness for normal users?
- eviks 4y agoWith a properly designed keyboard (ortho-staggered or ortho-linear without a huge spacebar) the numpad is not needed, you can have it right around your home row) But am very glad to hear there is at least potential for innovation here!
- wkat4242 4y agoHmm Apple really put a ton of money into making their touch bar work and even they couldn't manage to make it actually useful. If they couldn't do it, framework has no chance. I would have been a lot less critical about the touch bar if it hadn't replaced the function key row though. That one is mandatory for me, and there was more than plenty room on MacBooks to have both at the same time.
- ris58h 4y agoUnpopular opinion: we shouldn't use F-keys at all except for old software like Midnight Commander. Alphanumeric shortcuts and Key Sequences should be used instead. http://xahlee.info/kbd/banish_key_chords.html http://xahlee.info/kbd/banish_key_chords.html
- wkat4242 4y agoI totally disagree. I think direct shortcut keys without difficult to remember combinations are much preferable to me. And also much handier (e.g. when drinking something you can press a single button with the other hand). For this reason I also use the big old 100% keyboards with numpads, and I remap the entire numpad to other functions such as a 3x3 desktop switcher. For me there can't be enough dedicated keys. By the way the link you are quoting actually advocates using single keys as the ideal option :) It literally says the following: > of these, in terms of efficiency and hand health (Repetitive Strain Injury), the single key is the best. Key sequence of single keys is second best. Key chord is the worst. I suffer from RSI also which is another reason to prefer this. However it is really a matter of preference of course. Some people love their 60% keyboards and that's ok too. Just won't work for me. But what I disagree with is the "should be used" part. Nobody should tell me what to prefer :) This is one of the reasons I switched away from Apple. They are very strong in their opinions (to the point of actually building opinionated software).
- Qwertious 4y agoA lot of laptops need to reserve the space to the side of the keyboards, for their ports - in fact, whenever you see a laptop where the keyboard is kissing the edge of the laptop, it usually has a dire shortage of ports (typically 1 USB port, a charger, a headphone jack, and nothing else). This makes sense if you realize that it's a choice between keyboard girth and thin-ness; you can either have the keyboard on top of the ports, or you can squish the keyboard to the side and be potentially ~4mm thinner. Or just don't have ports. I'm starting to think that the future of laptop keyboards is the old thinkpad butterfly design: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nRVJCtREW38 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nRVJCtREW38
- eviks 4y agoNot really, the bigger laptops don't need to preserve more space for the ports, right? Yet they all expand the space sideways instead of adding space between the keyboard halves I mean, even with the same width, moving backspace between halves has no impact on the ports, where is that useful innovation for the few of us that make typos? Or replacing the spacebar with a few thumb keys - that is also port-effect-free