3 ms·

This is a super super super beginner question, but what's a good resource for learning the "correct" fingerings? I took 9 years of piano lessons, but I was ver

by smeej 4y ago

This is a super super super beginner question, but what's a good resource for learning the "correct" fingerings? I took 9 years of piano lessons, but I was very young (I quit when I was 12, 25+ years ago), so I have a vague memory that there's a "right" way to do things, but no idea where to go to re-learn it. I quit as soon as my parents would let me because I thought sight reading was supposed to be as easy as reading written words, and if I hadn't been able to master what I thought of as the most basic skill in 9 years, I must be hopeless. Now I understand that sight reading is actually a much more advanced skill, so I probably wasn't hopeless after all.

NineStarPoint 4y ago
The annoying truth is that what the correct fingering is changes depending on your hand size. So the real thing to learn is “what’s the right way to hold your hand and body at a keyboard to not cause long term damage” and then see what fingerings come out from that for your hand size. Unfortunately, don’t have a good resource there.
ofalkaed 4y ago
Correct fingering is determined by context, where is that hand coming from and where is it going next on the keyboard? So you read/play through a few times and figure out the optimal fingering to make sure you are not tripping over your hands. Teachers tend not to explain this until the student points out that the correct fingering for that chord was different in another piece.
- smeej 4y ago
  I guess the problem is that I'm slow when I'm plucking my way through something, so it takes me quite awhile to get going fast enough that there's clearly movement from one chord to the next, rather than stopping and resetting. Maybe I'm just trying to restart at the wrong level.
  - ofalkaed 4y ago
    As long as you are progressing I would not worry too much about it. Mix some easier pieces in so you also get practice at playing in/on time but keep at that harder stuff, you will not progress as a musician without pushing your boundaries. Personally I always have at least one piece which is completely beyond my ability that I work on, sometimes I give up on them, sometimes I get them down and I always learn a great deal from them.

by smeej 4y ago

NineStarPoint 4y ago

The annoying truth is that what the correct fingering is changes depending on your hand size. So the real thing to learn is “what’s the right way to hold your hand and body at a keyboard to not cause long term damage” and then see what fingerings come out from that for your hand size. Unfortunately, don’t have a good resource there.

ofalkaed 4y ago

Correct fingering is determined by context, where is that hand coming from and where is it going next on the keyboard? So you read/play through a few times and figure out the optimal fingering to make sure you are not tripping over your hands. Teachers tend not to explain this until the student points out that the correct fingering for that chord was different in another piece.

smeej 4y ago
I guess the problem is that I'm slow when I'm plucking my way through something, so it takes me quite awhile to get going fast enough that there's clearly movement from one chord to the next, rather than stopping and resetting. Maybe I'm just trying to restart at the wrong level.
- ofalkaed 4y ago
  As long as you are progressing I would not worry too much about it. Mix some easier pieces in so you also get practice at playing in/on time but keep at that harder stuff, you will not progress as a musician without pushing your boundaries. Personally I always have at least one piece which is completely beyond my ability that I work on, sometimes I give up on them, sometimes I get them down and I always learn a great deal from them.