4 ms·
This is a really interesting article. One thing is doesn't mention however, is when do you want a "juiced" emotional "soulful" interaction with your computer,
by crazygringo 4y ago
This is a really interesting article.
One thing is doesn't mention however, is when do you want a "juiced" emotional "soulful" interaction with your computer, and when you don't.
I think it's telling that most of the examples are coming from video games, where layered emotional experiences in a different world are the whole point.
In contrast, when I'm trying to be productive with a spreadsheet or a video editor or sending an email, juice/emotion/soul is the last thing I need. I'm focusing on my task and I want my tools to get out of the way, not draw emotional attention to themselves. Which is why flat design, the ultimate "anti-juice", has been so successful.
- hbn 4y agoI always thought there was something weird about how the change they made to the BSoD in Windows 8, where instead of looking like an actual OS crash it's a giant :( sad face with some cutesy text saying something like "we're collecting some error info"
- notduncansmith 4y agoThat is a valuable observation. Juice engages our senses and creates a more full-body experience. In a game, that level of immersion is desirable, because it puts us in a world we want to be in. I think it’s important to respect that not every person using a software wants to be doing so, and we should minimize the literal amount of time and energy it takes to use. Such apps can still be beautiful, of course (a job well done ought to look it) but with a quiet beauty that acknowledges their place in the hierarchy of importance to the user. This is why sometimes, for me, the juiciest feeling an app can give is just doing the thing I wanted instantly. The “pop” of new UI into place within milliseconds is very satisfying, especially if the layout doesn’t shift as a result.
- jkaptur 4y agoClearly a Mario-style "cha-ching" sound would be really annoying, but Excel's cursor is animated, Sheets slides tabs around when you reorder the sheet tabs at the bottom, there are all sorts of hover states and previews, the ctrl-f highlight has a little bounce to it, etc. I think you could even look at syntax highlighting, matching-paren-highlighting, and intellisense/autocomplete as a sort of juice - they're affordances that indicate that what you're doing is "good", and the app is "understanding you". Even more than a spectrum (where "pro apps" need "less juice"), it seems like there's just different juice for different apps. For example, it seems like some kind of better-designed juice could have saved Citibank a lot of money: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/02/citibank-just-got-a-500-million-lesson-in-the-importance-of-ui-design/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/02/citibank-just-go...
- JoeyJoJoJr 4y agoA good example of what you are talking about is usage of easing in UI animations. Good use of easing allows the animation to be perceived as natural, but if you apply the wrong kind of easing in the wrong context it causes the whole experience to feel clunky.