3 ms·
> red and blue America have very different ideas in mind when they use the terms woke/wokeness. This renders the two groups almost unable to communicate with ea
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
> red and blue America have very different ideas in mind when they use the terms woke/wokeness. This renders the two groups almost unable to communicate with each other
Whichever side (or both) then have poisoned the word as it can now never be used without being divisive — intentionally or otherwise. I'm not sure there is any other recourse but to abandon the word.
I don't think that would necessarily be a horrible thing to do — the idea can still exist (although Orwell might have believed otherwise).
It is unfortunate though that forces exist that would try and poison any discussion. Perhaps going after a specific word though is an easy means to do that?
- Nevermark 4y agoI am around enough people from different bands of the political spectrum that I avoid the word. Its definition varies wildly as a function of the listener. And, as demonstrated by both of the graphs, it is strongly associated with negative concepts. But that’s just my experience, in my context.
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago> It is unfortunate though that forces exist that would try and poison any discussion. Take "inherent white racism", for example. (That idea is out there. Whether it should properly be considered part of "woke" is not the point.) I mean, if I'm white, there's no way I can engage with that. If I disagree, someone holding the idea regards my disagreement as proving the correctness of their view. And if I agree, then I just categorized myself as the one having the flawed worldview, and therefore someone not to be listened to going forward. So that idea completely poisons the discussion. I don't think that just "woke" poisoned the discussion. I think it reflects that some of the ideas that people lump into "woke" are themselves poisonous to real discussion. You used the phrase "forces exist". It's a bit unclear whether you mean sociological dynamics, or whether you mean people. My own two cents: I think there are people on both sides who want to shut down discussion, for at least two reasons: because they think that they'll win more that way, and/or because it's easier to try to win by default than to actually win peoples' hearts and minds in an honest discussion. ("By default" meaning "the other side's position is completely unreasonable, therefore my position is the only one standing, therefore I win".) When too many people on both sides are engaged in such tactics (or too many who have the microphone), it becomes impossible to have a reasonable conversation on those topics. Reasonable people just tune out the shouting and shake their heads. All you can do is wait for the shouters to shut up and go away. Except they never will, because this has become part of electoral politics, and elections are every two years, and campaigns are nearly two years long, so it never really goes away. Which brings us to sociological dynamics. And I'm going to stop here, because I don't know what to say...
- jfengel 4y agoI'm not sure there is any other recourse but to abandon the word. I think it has long since been abandoned by the left. It was never really in wide use. It started as African-American slang, got a tiny bit of usage in popular music (by black artists) a decade ago, and never really got a lot of attention. I'm not certain I've ever heard the word as a live usage, only ever as a term of opprobrium. There's really nothing to abandon. The right will abandon it when they're done with it. But that won't have anything to do with whether or not progressives use it. They'll find some new word that a few progressives use and pretend that's Democratic policy.