8 ms·
> Afro-Asiatic and Eurasian have a common ancestor about 10,000 BC. > This is a really old word that appears to have a common root and got borrowed back into F
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> Afro-Asiatic and Eurasian have a common ancestor about 10,000 BC.
> This is a really old word that appears to have a common root and got borrowed back into French by accident... but that it got borrowed back by accident is because of its really old common ancestor.
If you think there's a relationship between the Latin and Syrian words, you wouldn't seek to explain it by common ancestry from 10,000 BC. No linguistic relationship exists at that temporal distance. You would either say that the word was borrowed from one language into the other (common in general; hard to say if it happened here), or that they are similar through pure coincidence (also common).
> Afro-Asiatic and Eurasian have a common ancestor about 10,000 BC.
You should know that that is a hypothesis; there is no evidence for it other than the assumption that all languages ultimately share a common origin.
- beezlewax 4y agoI don't think we can even assume that all languages have a common origin though. Maybe that is not the case.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoSo stated we already know it's false; Nicaraguan Sign Language emerged ex nihilo and has no ancestors. For something slightly less clear-cut than that, but also spoken, there are various creole languages around the world that show little to no grammatical relationship to their ancestors (though they are strongly related in terms of vocabulary). I did not intend to endorse the assumption that all languages have a common origin; I intended to impugn the claim that we can discern a relationship of any kind between Indo-European and Afro-Asiatic. We can't; the only relationship we can perceive between them is the one we begin by postulating. That said, we also can't disprove that all "traditional" languages go back to a common root. It's just a meaningless claim the evidence for or against which can't exist.
- shagie 4y agoThe root word 'gene' goes back to at least PIE as "give birth, beget" (it similarly shows up in Sanskrit (janati) and Welsh (geni) and several others) and the contemporary Semitic language. One could certainly argue that it is a loan word one way or the other between those to groups, yet this remains a very old word that is at least older than Proto-Indo-European, or Arabic, Aramaic, or Syriac. Jinn as found in Arabic has a relationship to genius in French. The word origins for genie (as in genius loci) can be traced back to PIE which puts it at 5000 BC in PIE. Prior to PIE is speculative, nonetheless Semitic languages show a similar word with similar meanings as the PIE genius loci spirit. It would be interesting to pursue that word through history to find if it prior to PIE or when it was borrowed from PIE into Semitic or from Porto-Semitic into PIE.