3 ms·
We simply have to say that a running computer has something that its otherwise identically configured recently broken remains do not. I don’t think that’s a s
by layer8 4y ago
We simply have to say that a running computer has something that its otherwise identically configured recently broken remains do not.
I don’t think that’s a substantive argument for needing a term like “soul”.
- macrolocal 4y agoAnd Joscha Bach might define "soul" in terms of computation.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoThat's not incompatible with this conception of souls. A sort of simple animism is fully compatible. A computer has a soul the way a rock has a soul: it manifests rock-ness in some way that is both unique to itself and different from what would be possessed by that same material as a pile of gravel, or lava. This is so different from the kind of soul a person or a forest has that it's not an extremely useful grouping in a lot of ways. But it's not a contradiction and there are cases where it is useful.