3 ms·
People are hardly restricted to governments to enact this sort of harm. Power seeks power, and power exerts power. It does so through markets, through crimina
by dredmorbius 4y ago
People are hardly restricted to governments to enact this sort of harm.
Power seeks power, and power exerts power. It does so through markets, through criminal organisations, through militaries (nationally-affiliated, mercenary, or any of a continuum of hybrid forms), and more.
Liberal democratic governments are at least in name and theory accountable to the governed, and even many less democratic forms still reflect the collective will of diverse groups within their societies.
The Max Weber dictum that's so often misquoted and mis-construed doesn't hold that government has a monopoly on force, but that it has the monopoly to the legitimate claim on same.
Weber, Max (1978). Roth, Guenther; Wittich, Claus (eds.). Economy and Society. Berkeley: U. California Press. p. 54.
<https://archive.org/details/economysociety00webe/page/54/mode/1up?view=theater https://archive.org/details/economysociety00webe/page/54/mod...>
Yes, limit government, and ensure that it is lawful and legitimate (as opposed to capricious and corrupt). But don't eliminate it, as then all that remains is violence used without legitimacy or restraint.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI never said that government is the only source of harm or that it should be eliminated. I'm not sure why you jump to that conclusion. It seems like you agree that there should be limits to the scope of government as well. We might differ on where those limits lie, but maybe not. My primary point is that these limits are what mitigate the damage misguided individuals can do to others.
- dredmorbius 4y agoFair enough. It's a frequently-enough expressed trope that I tend to anticipate it and act preemptively. Generalising the problem, what I see is the need to moderate power, and to balance power, in the sense of John Kenneth Galbraith's counterveiling power. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countervailing_power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countervailing_power> In the context of generative AI, the problem is of an unbalanced new power, that of generating text or speech that appears semantically meaningful, but whose purpose and intent are unclear, perhaps even to the parties operating the AI itself. More generally, however, within any communications channel in which social, political, economic, or other significant potential exists, you can be quite well assured that some entity, agent, or power, human, machine, or hybrid, will emerge to attempt to exploit that opportunity. I first saw this realised by my friend Woozle, after whom I've termed this "Woozle's Epistemic Paradox", first expressed on Google+, though now preserved in a Reddit post of mine: Our present epistemic systems are undergoing kind of the same shock that the online community underwent when transitioning from BBSs and Usenet to the commercial web to social media. We were used to a very high content-to-BS ratio because it took a certain amount of intelligence and intense domain-interest for people to be there in the first place -- and we've now transitioned to a situation where many people are there more or less accidentally and (the worst part), because of a high percentage of the population being present, there is now substantial power to be had by influencing the discussions that take place. <https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/5wg0hp/when_epistemic_systems_gain_social_and_political/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/5wg0hp/when_ep...>
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI stand by my position and think it is quite reasonable. Bad ideas and misinformation are plentiful. They have always been in different media environments, although the speed and fervor may change with time. If some people think that this puts democracy at risk, the solutions are the same. Firewalls and limitations to restrict the ability of others to impose their opinions on you. A Lynch Mob is a very democratic event. The only defense against Lynch Mob Behavior, especially in times of high suggestibility, is maintaining limits and reinforcing norms for what is off limits.
- dredmorbius 4y agoSpeed, scale, and efficacy all matter tremendously, of course. Something I've become exceptionally aware of in the past decade is that virtually every previous major shift in communications or informational capabilities has come with enormous disruption. Several of those occurrences were within the previous century. We've seen two or three in the present as well, so far. The concept is at the core of Elizabeth Eisenstein's work, The Printing Press as an Agent of Change, though that of course touches on only one such revolution itself. Previously: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34906482 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34906482>