11 ms·
I'd say trust your intuition more than the math, but I'm more physicist than mathematician. To prove Banach-Tarski, you need to assume Zermelo-Frankel set theo
by yummyfajitas 18y ago
I'd say trust your intuition more than the math, but I'm more physicist than mathematician.
To prove Banach-Tarski, you need to assume Zermelo-Frankel set theory (just ordinary set theory) plus the uncountable axiom of choice.
In my view, this means the uncountable axiom of choice is false. This actually breaks far less than you would expect. For most practical purposes, you only need the countable axiom of choice, which is the intuitively reasonable version.
The main thing the loss of the uncountable version breaks is the Hahn-Banach theorem on spaces of dimension higher than countable infinity. This in turn breaks quantum field theory on free space (not in a box), but that's broken anyway.