5 ms·
I love the Ars Technica headline: "Relativity Space has a successful failure with the debut of Terran 1" While technically a failure, it succeeded at many dif
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
I love the Ars Technica headline: "Relativity Space has a successful failure with the debut of Terran 1"
While technically a failure, it succeeded at many difficult tasks, like Max-Q, staging and not exploding. They got lots of data back and are in good shape for a second try.
Nobody has ever successfully launched a rocket to orbit on their first try, so Relativity was not expected to either. Some rockets have have succeeded on their first try, but no companies or space agencies have. For example Falcon 9's first try was successful, but they failed 3 times on Falcon 1 before its first success.
https://arstechnica.com/science/2023/03/relativity-space-has-a-successful-failure-with-the-debut-of-terran-1/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2023/03/relativity-space-has...
- dylan604 4y agoNASA considers Apollo 13 a successful failure. In fact, learning about Apollo 13 was the first time I had heard the reference.
- lmm 4y agoThis is a rewriting of history after the movie. At the time it was considered a regular failure.
- kens 4y agoI was curious so I investigated a bit. Commander Lovell called Apollo 13 a "successful failure" in 1970. https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19710038390 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19710038390 NASA also listed Apollo 13 as a "successful failure" in published documents: https://www.google.com/books/edition/NASA_Activities/pDrEu7PZgxIC?hl=en&gbpv=1&bsq=%22successful%20failure%22%20 https://www.google.com/books/edition/NASA_Activities/pDrEu7P...
- FredPret 4y agoPerhaps, but "successful failure" seems very apt. Part of your rocket explodes in space... and all three crew still makes it back alive. I've done much worse to my Kerbals. I bet Mission Control saw many high-fives when those astronauts touched down on Earth safely.
- Zeetah 4y agoThe Space Shuttle was launched successfully to orbit in it's first try. Ditto for Artemis. I haven't checked but I think there were a couple others, too.
- xoa 4y agoOP maybe didn't word it perfectly, but they were talking about organizations not rocket families. Space Shuttle was not exactly NASA's first rocket, just as F9 wasn't SpaceX's first rocket. I don't know if no organization at all has ever been successful on the first try with an orbital rocket or not. The quote Eric Berger at Ars has given was a lot more specific [0]: >No private company has ever launched its first independently developed, liquid-fueled rocket and had it reach orbit on the first try. And Relativity is pushing a lot of boundaries with its methane-fueled booster. Probably the biggest test here is whether the 3D-printed structure of Terran 1 can withstand the dynamic pressure of ascent through the lower atmosphere. At the same time though it's important to acknowledge that the "works on the first try" for typical Old Space projects came at absolutely enormous expense [1], and it's reasonable for expectations to be different for a project representing billions to tens of billions of expenditure and billion(s) per rocket vs a private company doing something for tens to hundreds of millions. A properly done hardware rich test program has a lot of advantages. ---- 0: https://arstechnica.com/science/2023/03/relativity-space-will-try-again-for-the-third-time-to-launch-wednesday/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2023/03/relativity-space-wil... 1: Not just in money either, but in terms of baking in bad designs until it was way too late to change them, which then could and did cause ongoing challenges for as long as the rockets were used. Like yes the first Space Shuttle made it, the design was made to work through heroic efforts, but the design also meant that heroic efforts were needed every single time. Which isn't very sustainable for something used for decades. And in turn we ended up losing multiple ones with humans on board and all lives lost.
- bigiain 4y ago> it's important to acknowledge that the "works on the first try" for typical Old Space projects came at absolutely enormous expense And, I suspect (as your footnote mentions), they took risks that would not be considered/permitted today. Modern "Human rated" space flights are very very different to the Gemini and Sputnik days.
- trollerator23 4y ago> Nobody has ever successfully launched a rocket to orbit on their first try This is just false. See Orbital Sciences Pegasus first flight, right off the top of my head. There are others.
- RandallBrown 4y agoWas Pegasus their first launch ever?
- bryanlarsen 4y agoYes it was, trollerator was right, I was wrong, at least as far as Pegasus goes. But the second part of his claim is wrong: AFAICT there aren't any others. Pegasus was solid fueled, which is an easier design than a liquid one, but it's not that much easier. Big props to Orbital Sciences (or at least what's left of them in the Northrop Grumman behemoth).
- trollerator23 4y agoYeah, if you are talking about organizations then that's possibly the only one. Seems strange though.