4 ms·
This comes at the price of now both OpenAI and Wolfram getting access to your queries (when you use the plugin, of course). I’m hoping we don’t slide into a fut
by layer8 4y ago
This comes at the price of now both OpenAI and Wolfram getting access to your queries (when you use the plugin, of course). I’m hoping we don’t slide into a future where you either have to give up on confidentiality and privacy or else can’t use any “modern” tools anymore.
- sebzim4500 4y agoHow is this different than Google/WA today?
- no_time 4y agoI can't speak for WA, but Google doesn't have my phone number, or any other PII. OpenAI does.
- layer8 4y agoThe data you enter in Google Search is much more limited (at least it is for me). None of the other Google services are essential. (Google Search isn’t essential as well, but it’s a distinctive kind of service in that it isn’t practical to self-host.) With “WA” I guess you mean WhatsApp. For messaging, E2E encryption is now standard, which is not possible for AI services (barring huge breakthroughs in homomorphic encryption). In addition, it’s easy to self-host messaging solutions without losing out on features much.
- sebzim4500 4y agoSorry, I should have specified WA means Wolfram Alpha. >barring huge breakthroughs in homomorphic encryption Actually this seems plausible to me without having to use those general purpose algorithms that cause a 1000000000x slowdown. For example, you can obscure the input to each matrix multiplication by shifting the input and outputs by a predetermined (user specific) constant. Maybe there are similar tricks for cross attention, although that might be a bit optimistic. Certainly you can do some amount of obfuscation by permuting the inputs, but I doubt that would achieve much.
- layer8 4y agoI’m pretty sure your query will effectively still be derivable on the server side, as it has to syntactically/semantically interact with the model. To truly disguise it, at least part of the model/weights would have to be transferred to the client side (so that the server doesn’t learn the adjustment), which would in turn leak the model.
- moshun 4y agoIt isn’t, this is literally the Google / Meta business model.
- sirsinsalot 4y agoWe have been there for quite some time. Both Google and the whole of the UK, US and AUS governments have access to my entire web history.
- crubier 4y ago> a future where you either have to give up on confidentiality and privacy are you a time traveller from the past?