3 ms·
Why should they be forced into giving me their content in a way they don't want to? Take a step back: the purpose of intellectual property law is to promote th
by modeless 15y ago
Why should they be forced into giving me their content in a way they don't want to?
Take a step back: the purpose of intellectual property law is to promote the creation of works. Assigning property rights to ideas is the means, not the end. If we believe compulsory licenses would ultimately promote the creation of more works, that trumps any property rights argument.
Would you be OK with the government saying "if a company won't release it's source code, you are ok to hack into their site to get it [...]
No, but I would be OK with the government saying "if a company won't release its source code, you are free to reverse engineer it."
- Terretta 15y agoAnd if you want to reverse engineer Chuck, have at it. Not being facetious -- this is what streaming aggregators like Netflix and Hulu are doing by buying and producing their own content.
- SoftwareMaven 15y ago"""the purpose of intellectual property law is to promote the creation of works""" Perhaps the whole problem would go (almost) away if IP terms were made a reasonable length again. No, I don't think so, either, but it should still happen. Copyright started at 14 years in the US. As distribution got better, it should have gotten shorter not longer. Maybe we really are reaching a point that IP should not be protected by law anymore. Coca Cola has kept their formula secret for over a hundred years. Many companies do not patent certain pieces of information, preferring to keep them trade secrets. The fashion industry never had IP protection (beyond trademarks that apply to everybody). This would mean 37 Signals can get angry about somebody using their design (like they (any clothing designer) did) but they would have no legal recourse to do anything. I don't know if 37 Signals has any legal plans, but it would surprise me (a lot...who wants that kind of distracting mess? Oh, wait, Apple seems to). Personally, as much as I love my iPhone, I couldn't care less if Cupertino no longer had a foundation (outside of trademark, which still has value, IMO) to sue over the iPad's and iPhone's design.