3 ms·
Compulsory licensing seems fundamentally broken in multiple ways. First, it provides an air of legitimacy for the claim that purchasing a copy doesn't automati
by JoshTriplett 15y ago
Compulsory licensing seems fundamentally broken in multiple ways. First, it provides an air of legitimacy for the claim that purchasing a copy doesn't automatically provide all the "license" you need to do whatever you want with it. It ought to suffice to purchase as many copies as you simultaneously stream; streaming should not require a magic "streaming license", especially not one that costs more than just buying a copy. And second, the concept of any kind of compulsory transfer of rights for a legislatively fixed amount of money seems fundamentally opposed to the concept of a market, and accepting that in the realm of copyright seems like a dangerous precedent.
- dantheman 15y agoIt's important to remember that copyright in and of itself is an antifreemarket creation. More specifically, it is a government granted monopoly (about as antifreemarket as you can get). I agree that the idea of compulsory licensing rubs me the wrong way, but pretending that we're actually operating in a freemarket is dangerous too.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoI agree with you entirely; I just think we don't want to set a dangerous precedent here.