4 ms·
> who elected these elites to decide what was and wasn't ethical and responsible? Nobody First: basically every American literally voted for that by repeatedly
by ben_w 4y ago
> who elected these elites to decide what was and wasn't ethical and responsible? Nobody
First: basically every American literally voted for that by repeatedly saying no to the alternative (the communist party) in every American election.
Second: what exactly and specifically are you suggesting here? Because even outside of capitalism, the alternative to "people deciding they personally don't feel it's safe to release a product they created and worked on and know more about than literally anyone else" sounds like actual literal insanity to me.
- modriano 4y agoTwo notes: 1) less than half of Americans vote in each election (less than 63% if you restrict to the voting-age population, less than 70% if you apply the scummy rules that restrict to the voting-eligible population) And 2) it's a false dichotomy to say that US elections have ever been "whatever we have now VS communism". Maybe you could say socialism was on the ballot all those times Eugene Debs ran for the presidency, but there hasn't ever been a communist on the ballot that I'm aware of. Also, it sounds like you would struggle to define communism if pressed. Regarding your second loose point, the US restricts the sale of a lot of products to the public (eg nuclear weapons, biological weapons, raw milk, copyrighted works you don't hold the copyright to, etc). Personally, I think it's pretty reasonable to restrict the sale of some things, even if the potential sellers know a lot about the product.
- ben_w 4y ago> it sounds like you would struggle to define communism if pressed Having read the Communist Manifesto, I think that description of me is both totally fair and would also apply to Karl Marx. Darn thing read like an unhinged run-on blog rant.
- nr2x 4y agoIt’s literally a manifesto.
- ben_w 4y agoAre you implying that all manifestos read like that?
- modriano 4y ago> basically every American literally voted for that by repeatedly saying no to *the alternative* (the communist party) in every American election. I had a good laugh playing with this ridiculous framing, thinking about all of the candidates we've said no to. * "Get out of here Donald Trump! We don't want communism, we want the alternative; Joe Biden!" * "Hit the bricks secret pamphlet-loving marxists John McCain and Mitt Romney, we'll take the singular alternative: Barack Obama" * "We love Jimmy Carter, he's the opposite of communism! Nothing like the alternative, an all-star college football player and rabid communist manifesto adherent named Gerald Ford." * and "We hate Jimmy Carter who must be a communist because of how hard we voted for the movie man." * "Give us Teddy Roosevelt, he'll smash up all of these monopolistic robber barons, because TR is the alternative to Marxism." * "FDR, we love you so much we'll elect you to the Presidency four times! We all thought Herbert Hoover was in the pocket of gilded age capitalists, but when Hoover drove us into the great depression, we realized he must have really been a bolshevik! Thank you so much for the massive welfare state expansion, FDR, you truly earned your nickname 'FDR: cure for the common communism'" Ridiculous. But in all earnestness, the communist manifesto has never been even remotely relevant to any US election ever. And I mean this with no malice, but if you think lobbing the label "communist" at something you don't like is an argument, vary up your media diet and be recognize when you use logical fallacies in arguments so you can slow down and debug your thought process.
- ben_w 4y agoI think you misunderstand; when I said communists, that wasn't a spicy republican hot take about the democrats or whatever, it was literally the communists: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communist_Party_USA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communist_Party_USA for example, or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutionary_Communist_Party,_USA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutionary_Communist_Party,... or even https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialist_Alternative_(United_States) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialist_Alternative_(United_... I think it's really obvious that Americans don't want those things, so one way to rephrase my original comment could be "the rejection of communism is why rich people get to own and control businesses".
- 4y ago
- nicky0 4y agoThe half that don't bother to vote forfeit their right to be counted.