3 ms·
It's not just word play. Cars go faster than humans can by themselves, under some specific conditions. Cars go slower than humans, or rather cannot go at all,
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
It's not just word play.
Cars go faster than humans can by themselves, under some specific conditions.
Cars go slower than humans, or rather cannot go at all, under other specific conditions. Two weeks ago my wife ran 30 miles on trails in southern Texas. A car could not have traversed any of the distance she travelled on, because a car cannot run.
Cars make it easier for people to move themselves and stuff when there are appropriate roads to travel on. They have enhanced our abilities to do this, but they cannot run.
You're squashing the meaning out words by trying to suggest that "running" is somehow equivalent to "any other method of a person moving from A to B". But that's not true.
We can acknowledge the greater ease of cars for moving people and stuff without squashing the meaning out of words.
Finally, even the notion that cars are "better" at moving people and stuff needs careful examination. Thus far I have said "make it easier" because I am aware that by a certain set of metrics (related to energy use, material use, impact on the environment) cars are actually worse most of the time.
- coldtea 4y ago>You're squashing the meaning out words by trying to suggest that "running" is somehow equivalent to "any other method of a person moving from A to B". But that's not true. That's just an accidental property of the english language. We can imagine a language where "runner" and "thing that moves from A to B fast" used the same term T, and if people referred to T with the english notion of "runner" (e.g. a person running in a marathon") it was just deduced from the context. There are many cases like that. In any case, the point is moot, as "thinking" doesn't have the same constraints. We might not call what a car does as running/runner (though we do use the former term) but we absolutely have considered AI as "thinking" and called AIs "thinking machines", even before AI (never mind AGI) even existed. >You're squashing the meaning out words by trying to suggest that "running" is somehow equivalent to "any other method of a person moving from A to B". But that's not true. This depends on the level of abstraction of the discussion. At some level of abstraction it's irrelevant if the move happened via running or via horse buggy or via a car. Sometimes we just care about the act of moving from A to B, and different methods to do so are only differentiated by their speed or other effectiveness. In that case, we can compare man and machine though, and just care for the speed (machine can answer in 0.1. secs, a man needs to think over 1-2 minutes to answer such questions) or effectiveness (e.g. machine is better at juggling many things at the same time when thinking, or man is better at subtle semantical nuance).
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoI already covered this in my post. Cars are an easier method to move people and stuff when there are suitable routes, where easier means "the journey will take less time, will require almost no human exertion by those moved, and will likely include weather protection". Nobody is going to disagree with this (they may raise the objections I did that cars are energetically, materially and environmentally less efficient than other means, but that doesn't invalidate "cars are easier for moving people+stuff"). But that's not running. I will concede that even in English, there are idioms like "Can you run me to town?" meaning "Can you drive me to town?", or "I'm just going to run to the store" meaning "I'm going take a short journey to the store". But this doesn't mean that cars are better at running than humans, it means that the english word run can be used in different ways. And you know exactly which way Lanier meant it.
- JoshCole 4y agoAre car parts car parts? Not according to an auto-mechanics, but according to the laymen. A radiator is not a battery or an engine. Are games games? Not according to a game theorist, but according to the the laymen. A game is not a play or a history. This isn't an accident of language. An example of an actual accident of language would be giving tanks instead of giving thanks. Are runners runners? Yes, according to you. A walker is a runner is a missile is a bowling ball rolling between places is light moving through a medium. No, according to a fitness coach, because a runner is not a tank is not a plane. When they say that a person should take up running they don't mean the person should melt down their body in a furnace and sprinkle their atoms into metal which is then pressed into iron plates that are attached to a tank which will then go running. Sometimes we need to be careful in language. For example, we probably don't want to confuse the process of being incinerated and pressed into iron plates with the process of a human exercising their muscles. The choice to be careful in this way is not an accident of language. It is a very deliberate thing when, for example, John Von Nuemann carefully explains why he thinks the laymen use of the word game has perilous impact on our ability to think about the field of game theory which he starts in his book about the same. I think you should make your point so as to disprove Nuemann, not pick on the straw man of running. Or you should argue against the use of the term radiator instead of car parts. It will better highlight your fallacy, because with running I have to make your position seem much more farcial then it is. We do gain something from thinking imprecisely. We gain speed. That can really get our thoughts running, so long as we don't trip up, but it calls to attention that when someone chooses to stop running due to the claim that the terrain isn't runnable, the correct response is not to tell them that running is accidental property. It is to be careful as you move over the more complicated terrain. Otherwise you might be incinerating yourself without noticing your error.