In both cases (this page, and the one you mention) I think you’re inferring the wrong context — which is reasonable because it’s a legitimate inference. I thin

In both cases (this page, and the one you mention) I think you’re inferring the wrong context — which is reasonable because it’s a legitimate inference. I think the context is “for this use case”. Neither are saying never use Redux or useEffect, but are more about the common problem of people reaching for solutions that aren’t a good fit for their problem.