5 ms·
In the blog past Coinbase General Counsel asks for "guidance". The guidance for future "crypto entrepreneurs" is going to come from the outcomes of these enfor
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
In the blog past Coinbase General Counsel asks for "guidance". The guidance for future "crypto entrepreneurs" is going to come from the outcomes of these enforcement actions.
CryptoExpert: "We want guidance. We want regulation."
SEC: "Your product/service is a security."
CryptoExpert: "No it's not!"
Damodoran called cryptocurrency "currency made by the paranoid for the paranoid." [paraphrase] Let's be honest, cooperating with the government is not high on the crypto nerd's list of priorities. The "cryptocurrency" concept seems to be based on a mistrust of government-issued currency and a mistrust of government more generally.
- joefigura 4y agoIt doesn't seem like the SEC has actually said what Coinbase is doing that is a security, or published regulations on how to determine which digital assets are securities and which are not "The SEC staff told us they have identified potential violations of securities law, but little more. We asked the SEC specifically to identify which assets on our platforms they believe may be securities, and they declined to do so" - https://www.coinbase.com/blog/we-asked-the-sec-for-reasonable-crypto-rules-for-americans-we-got-legal https://www.coinbase.com/blog/we-asked-the-sec-for-reasonabl... Coinbase seems to be trying their best to comply with regulation, but getting nowhere
- beaned 4y agoHow can you possibly be a fair "enforcer" of a law that you refuse to specify?
- Kye 4y agoLaw in the US is made by Congress. Federal agencies are given a fair amount of latitude in executing that law, but they're still bound by it. They can offer guidance as best as they can when Congress is slow to act, but that's about it. At the end of the day, they still have to convince a prosecutor if they want to make a federal case out of it.
- pavlov 4y agoRegulations and court precedents about what’s a security have been published since the 1930s. Lots of people have tried to work around it. Crypto isn’t the first attempt to create pseudo-securities where the layers of ownership and control are obfuscated. The rules aren’t really that complicated — it’s just that crypto people have a hard time facing the fact that practically everything in crypto meets the definition of a security. Coinbase’s lawyers are paid to come up with a paradigm where the tokens on their platform can continue to be sold to retail with the implied benefits of a security (“buy token X and the awesome work of our team will make you money!”) while hopefully skirting the regulations. The SEC’s lawyers’ job is not to help them craft that. It’s not like you can go to the police to repeatedly ask if your scheme to avoid the law is going to work this time. The IRS doesn’t offer that kind of tax avoidance planning feedback service either. If that’s what your business needs to operate, you’ll just have to trust your own lawyer about their interpretation of the law and why it doesn’t apply to you.
- jefftk 4y agoThe IRS gives lots of detailed guidance [1] on how to file your taxes, including specifically for cryptocurrency [2]. The SEC has given very little guidance here, mostly just repeating their normal non-cryptocurrency guidance in a way that wouldn't be informative to a securities lawyer [3], and especially hasn't addressed the way their current rules are incompatible with crypto. That Etherium, for example, has existed for a decade and become as big as it is without the SEC deciding whether it's a security makes it very hard for anyone to plan. (I don't own any crypto and haven't ever; generally anti-crypto.) [1] https://www.irs.gov/publications https://www.irs.gov/publications [2] https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/digital-assets https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe... [3] https://www.sec.gov/files/dlt-framework.pdf https://www.sec.gov/files/dlt-framework.pdf
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- _fizz_buzz_ 4y ago> It doesn't seem like the SEC has actually said what Coinbase is doing that is a security According to Coinbase…
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoOther parts of the government do not agree with that take: https://fortune.com/crypto/2023/03/08/stablecoins-ether-commodities-cftc-rostin-behnam-sec-gary-gensler/ https://fortune.com/crypto/2023/03/08/stablecoins-ether-comm... The CFTC has been regulating cryptocurrencies just like the SEC. Which part of the government has been breaking the law? HN legal experts will figure it out with snark.
- JohnFen 4y agoIn this sort of situation, it's usually the courts that make the ruling. In order for that to happen, someone has to get sued. It appears that's where this is headed. Clarity is coming.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> The "cryptocurrency" concept seems to be based on a mistrust of government-issued currency and a mistrust of government more generally. It certainly was. Some coins like monero still are all about that. Most of the cryptocurrency space turned into stocks though. They even reinvented banks.
- ignoramous 4y agotbf, recreating banks but without regulation is one way to go about orchestrating once-in-a-generation wealth transfer from... one LP to another.
- hungryforcodes 4y agoWhat does that even mean?
- jcpham2 4y agoIt means reinventing the wheel is going to yield a square. But not just a square but a new and exciting square where many people who once had money no longer have money because it was transferred to another pool of liquidity and those poor souls still left outside in the cold will not be made whole.
- hungryforcodes 4y agoOK. Clear as mud :)
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agohttps://finance.yahoo.com/news/coinbase-says-just-no-way-to-register-with-sec-amid-calls-for-compliance-161129587.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/coinbase-says-just-no-way-to-... Coinbase claims there is "no path to registration". But that is not the SEC's problem. If Coinbase runs its operation in a way that precludes it from being able to comply with securities laws, then that is a problem with Coinbase's operation, not the SEC. Ultimately whether or not something is a security is determined by the courts, not the SEC. The statute states that a security can be an investment contract. However "investment contract" is not defined. The definition is left to the courts. That's why the test for a security is based on a definition used in a 1946 decision, SEC v W.J. Howey. The SEC can state they believe crypto is a security. "Crypto experts" can state they believe crypto is not a security. But only a court can decide what actually is a security. The SEC cannot tell Coinbase if their products are securities, only a court can do that. The SEC can tell Coinbase that it thinks their products are securities. The SEC can decide to enforce the securities laws at its own discretion.^1 With the Wells notice Coinbase knows unequivocally that the SEC thinks its products could be securities. The ball is in Coinbase's court. The question is, then, if the SEC suggests that crypto is a security, or even that it ever might be one, what is the best course of action for a "crypto entrepreneur". (a) stop (b) continue (c) comply Coinbase and others are choosing (b). That is their decision to make. Maybe they think they can win against the SEC in court. One of the most well-known treatise authors on the subject of securities regulation, along with Louis Loss and Joel Seligman, is Thomas Lee Hazen at UNC Chapel Hill. He has weighed in on crypto. For example, see Hazen, T. L. (2018). Virtual or Crypto Currencies and the Securities Laws. SSRN Electronic Journal. doi:10.2139/ssrn.3257449 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3257449 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3257449 "Although some have argued that virtual or crypto currencies are not securities,36 The better view is that virtual or crypto currency transactions often, if not always, are subject to the securities laws.37" Personally I cannot read Hazen's article and conclude that it's prudent to assume crypto is not subject to securities laws. But then I am not being paid to argue in crypto's favour. IMO, much if not all of what we read in defense of crypto is written by folks who stand to gain from its popularity. That is not just limited to people who have spent money on it. 1. It does not need the CFTC's permission. For example, it served Paxos Trust with a Wells notice and Paxos stopped minting BUSD. CFTC might think BUSD is a commodity but that did not stop the SEC from acting to protect the public.
- haakon 4y ago> The "cryptocurrency" concept seems to be based on a mistrust of government-issued currency and a mistrust of government more generally. This is the classic notion of cryptocurrency, but the field has grown and changed a lot. People don't mint NFT collections and dabble in metaverse tokens as a middle-finger to the state. The VC-funded cryptocurrencies of the last cycle are obviously centralized and are far removed from any cypherpunk notion.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoAre you telling me Lindsay Lohan is not a cypherpunk.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoThey do it to make money without having to pay tax. Which is not quite a middle finger to the state, but it's certainly middle-finger-to-the-state adjacent.
- JohnFen 4y ago> This is the classic notion of cryptocurrency, but the field has grown and changed a lot Maybe? It's pretty hard to tell, though, because 90% of the cryptocurrency advocates I hear are from the "government is evil" crowd.
- mschuster91 4y ago> Damodoran called cryptocurrency "currency made by the paranoid for the paranoid." [paraphrase] Let's be honest, cooperating with the government is not high on the crypto nerd's list of priorities. The "cryptocurrency" concept seems to be based on a mistrust of government-issued currency and a mistrust of government more generally. Given the history of cryptocurrencies, that was indeed the base - Bitcoin really took off once Silk Road crossed the threshold from "only drug nerds know about this" to "everyone and their dog buys research chemicals on SR". Unfortunately, the best days of Silk Road were something like an Eternal September event, as people then discovered that Bitcoin might also be used for speculation...
- hackernewds 4y agoIt is a marketing tactic now that highly centralized capitalist companies pretend to be socialist decentralized warriors for the common people. https://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/1638674083817885697?s=20 https://twitter.com/brian_armstrong/status/16386740838178856... BA appears to be taking this head-on to go on the offensive.