5 ms·
> The whole regulatory infrastructure from the SEC expects a security to be backed by or representative of a physical asset of some sort - be it shares of a cor
by lmm 4y ago
> The whole regulatory infrastructure from the SEC expects a security to be backed by or representative of a physical asset of some sort - be it shares of a corporation with tangible assets, gold, or in the case of futures, a commodity. Even bonds are, they're securitized debts.
No it doesn't. Corporations are very obviously unphysical, as are debts. Securitizing e.g. music royalties is completely normal.
- dataflow 4y ago> Corporations are very obviously unphysical I think that misses the parent's point. Corporations own physical assets (like buildings) and things with accepted intrinsic value (fiat currency). but they also indirectly own rights to other things that are indirectly backed by physical stuff in a similar manner (like shares of other corporations, etc.). That's in contrast to something like Bitcoin which doesn't come with a direct or indirect right to anything with intrinsic value.
- lmm 4y ago> I think that misses the parent's point. Corporations own physical assets (like buildings) and things with accepted intrinsic value (fiat currency). but they also indirectly own rights to other things that are indirectly backed by physical stuff in a similar manner (like shares of other corporations, etc.). Not necessarily. Sometimes a corporation's value is based on something purely speculative, like a drug patent that may or may not work out, or even something that's widely thought to be worthless, like hot tips on the search for Bigfoot. That's completely normal.
- dataflow 4y agoDo you have any examples of this? A corporation that owns literally nothing, whose entire value is based on something speculative (like a drug patent), and who has a traded security?
- junofan 4y agoSPACs are just pieces of paper sitting in Delaware somewhere.
- Aloha 4y agoIP is a tangible asset, one that can even be given a value before proven.
- dataflow 4y agoThat has nothing to do with what I'm saying. If you invest in a company that "only" has IP, your invested cash itself is still part of the company's assets, so it's not like you're buying shares of vacuum. If the company liquidates itself - you get back your proportion of the company's assets. The situation is not the same with Bitcoin.
- Aloha 4y agoThat was my point more or less, is that Bitcoin is a publicly traded fiat currency.
- dataflow 4y agoYeah, it certainly has similarities to an unbacked currency. I wouldn't personally call it "fiat" currency (unless you think El Salvador making it legal tender makes the difference here), just some sort of unbacked digital currency. The IRS's characterization of it as a virtual currency seems like an accurate description to me (as I'm guessing it is to you) - and the SEC refusing to consider it a security also makes sense to me (for all the above reasons I've been trying to explain to the others here).
- danaris 4y ago...Which is more or less what many of us have been citing all along as a reason why cryptocurrencies are bullshit that shouldn't even be allowed to exist.