4 ms·
FTP is as obsolete as telnet and has no place being alive today. SSH and SCP provide a much more secure alternative. SFTP is a hack that suffers from all the s
by astrodust 15y ago
FTP is as obsolete as telnet and has no place being alive today.
SSH and SCP provide a much more secure alternative. SFTP is a hack that suffers from all the same problems.
- hackermom 15y agoHow do you mean, SFTP is a hack that suffers from all the same problems? SFTP is a new protocol, it's not the same as FTP. It doesn't concern itself with data port nonsense, and while it doesn't offer authentication or secure transfers in itself, there is - at least to my knowledge - no SFTP solution available that doesn't perform SFTP via an underlying mechanism for secure auth/transfer.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoFTP is platform agnostic. As uncool as it may be it's the only realistic choice for companies to share sensitive data.
- omh 15y agoSensitive data? Over an unsecured protocol?
- thristian 15y agoI work for a company that processes sensitive data, and almost all our interactions with clients and suppliers are over SFTP, which is more than platform-agnostic enough.
- roel_v 15y agoPlease, name me one platform in common use that doesn't have an implementation of ssh/scp.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoJava, C# which covers a good 80+ percent of enterprise software. Moving data from one company to another for processing is big, big business. The type of thing not discussed on HN because it's not relevant here, but it must happen for those types of companies and FTP is really the only thing you can ask a paying client to use without asking them to rely on unsupported/abandoned/old third party libraries.
- roel_v 15y ago-_- Java & C# are not platforms, they're programming languages. I'm making an effort here to understand you, but I don't see how a programming language can relate to the availability of file transfer tools.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoProgrammatic access is essential in such an environment. Here's a realistic scenario just to make it clearer. An email appending company lands a big client. The client wants to obtain its customers' email addresses on an ongoing basis. They'll send customer information to the email append company who will then send them back the appended files. Manually moving files is not an option on either side. What method other than FTP do you suggest here?
- regularfry 15y agoMost programming environments have SSH/SCP libraries. If you want to maintain a simple upload/download model, SCP is the way to do it. It's not entirely clear to me that an FTP-style upload/download model is best here, mainly because I haven't the faintest clue what an "email appending company" does.
- 15y ago