5 ms·
Why Android isn't gaining on Apple in the Enterprise
- newbusox 15y agoI feel like one of the major changes in a Steve Jobs-less Apple is going to be an increased emphasis on the corporate market. This was historically one of the major differences between Apple (focused on end-users) and Microsoft (primarily focused on corporate enterprises--Paul Allen has a lot to say about this in his recent biography). To see Apple succeeding in this market is pretty exciting for them.
- VengefulCynic 15y agoI've often heard it said that (nearly every time Apple in the Enterprise comes up) the conventional wisdom is that Apple doesn't experience larger gains in the enterprise because of the culture of secrecy whereby it doesn't give advance information to large corporate buyers any more than it does to the average consumer. It's something of a surprise to me that this wasn't mentioned in this article. Doubly so because a number of the other vendors of Android devices (Samsung, Sony, LG, ASUS) have a much more favorable history on releasing information about upcoming products so that enterprise support can be ready for them. Also, a lack of that culture of secrecy would seem to be more favorable for sharing more technical information up-front for deeper integration with corporate partners. Whereas I don't get the impression that Apple really views any enterprise customer as a partner, but rather as another customer.
- alttag 15y agoConversely, Apples does have a history of long-term support for the products they do release, so in that sense, the future is extremely predicable ... more so than other players in the mobile space. The predictability of support is perhaps more valuable than the predictability of new shininess.
- cageface 15y agoThis is much more the case for Apple in mobile than in their other products. The churn from OS 9 -> X, PPC -> Intel, and multiple breaking changes to APIs etc over the same time period made supporting Macs at the "enterprise" level quite challenging.
- potatolicious 15y agoI feel like there really only one primary cause of iOS's (unexpected) enterprise success: it's a prestige phone. We can wax poetic about the democratization of corporate IT processes, or specific technologies, but IMO those are all herrings, or minor causes at best. At the end of the day, Apple introduced an incredibly prestigious product at the very highest end of the market. It had cachet and desirability, and when your SVP buys that drool-worthy envy-of-the-office phone, he damn well wants to use it with his email, and damned what IT thinks of it. I suspect Android's success in the enterprise space hinges on a similar product - if someone can come up with the "oh my god I must have it" phone in Android-land, the enterprise support will follow.
- Duff 15y agoI disagree. They are the best product, without a big price premium. We have a strong preference for Verizon at my place, due to the geography of our operating area vs. coverage. We have about 5,000 devices, and we started introducing Android to replace Blackberries. It didn't go well -- more support calls, a pain to manage, and very inconsistent. If we issued users a phone that the vendor decided to not support, users were not happy. The iPhones just work. Users love them. Our guys have minimal support load, etc. The biggest problem is that people keep trying to do new things, so there's some chaos with apps, etc.
- WayneDB 15y agoNone of that rules out the iPhone status symbol angle. What the "best product" is, is so completely subjective and since when did that matter anyway? You probably think that Macs are the best computer...why aren't those the biggest in the enterprise space?
- beatle 15y agoThe fact is the iPhone is easier and more fun to use than Android phones and Blackberries.
- 15y ago
- swasheck 15y agoour company wont go android because of the inability to remote wipe and the open android app store.
- tensor 15y agoYou can remote wipe (among other enterprise things) using google apps for business and the google apps device policy app. http://support.google.com/mobile/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=190930 http://support.google.com/mobile/bin/answer.py?hl=en&ans...
- pinaceae 15y agoWorking for a company that serves big pharma, I have the following observations: The iPad is the game changer for the mobile worker (pharma reps). Companies are taking away their sales reps MS laptops/tablets and replacing them with iPads. Why? 1., Unbreakable compared to classic hardware. Both in hardware as in software. No moving parts, light, powerful enough, so easy to use that reps can't claim anymore to be baffled by it. Cheap. No enterprise MS tablet PC comes close. 2., Far lower TCO, as the IT overhead is far lower. Virus Scanners? Custom OS images? Gone. A fully controlled, curated environment. Even if a user installs something, it will not break the system or steal your data. If an iPad gets stolen/lost, remote wipe and buy a new one. Log in, restore, done. Apple suddenly allows for bring your own hardware - the wet dream of enterprise IT. 3., Completely homogenic hardware, globally. This is the most important point. Wherever you buy an iPad, from Brazil to Korea, it is exactly the same. Same hardware, same OS. With notebooks? Lenovo, HP, Dell. And they change their models all the time, warranting a new driver here, a different OS image there. 4., The death of Blackberry is on the wall, making the iPhone the natural successor - for the above points. Now, what about the MacBooks and iMacs? Looking at my company, once the iPad is in, those follow. If the majority of users is on iOS, there are no benefits of being on Windows. Most admins like Unix-style anyhow, and OSX is a great UI for that. Managers are the ones left, and here the MacBook Air is gaining traction. It is sleek, light, and works. Plus, IT can standardize on it. Also, as people create slide decks, Keynote is seriously cool shit. Those presentations work seamlessly on iPad, whereas PPT breaks. Strong incentive there to switch. The last big footholds of MS in the Office are Excel and Outlook. But both are available on OSX, and some argue in better shape than their Windows brethren. The biggest gap of Apple is Excel on the iPad. Whoever releases a fully compatible iOS Excel version/clone will accelerate the demise of MS in enterprise desktops. Servers are completely different discussion, the MS Exchange/Sharepoint/Dynamics/SQL Server behemoth is here to stay. This battleground will shift due to SaaS.
- johngalt 15y ago5., Apple convinced people to pay enough to get good equipment. An IT department implementing anything PC based is constantly fighting against the $300 acer netbooks on the shelves of the local best buy. Management will cut corners on a PC.
- stoked 15y agoThe fragmentation mentioned in the article to me highlights one of the main reasons why enterprises shy away from Android. On iOS, there is ONE email/calendar client with a known set of features/limitations. On android, almost every manufacturer has their own email client and their varying feature sets and bugs are not documented anywhere. For example: http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=4760 http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=4760 How many posts in there are from google employees stating that it's not their problem because the email client the person is complaining about isn't written by google?
- abruzzi 15y agoAs a member of an enterprise IT, and one that has been involved in out testing and decision making I'd put it down to three things: 1. Android support for Exchange is generally awful. I can't speak for ICS, but many of the android phones we tested wouldn't do calendar sync, or would randomly stop receiving emails, requiring hard resets, or would have little to no global address lookup. In contrast, iOS has had very good exchange support since at least iOS 3, and it is rock solid. 2. Android still doesn't work with our Cisco VPN, iOS has since at least v3. 3. Beyond the internet and PIM software, we have been more successful finding quality apps. Too many apps on both platforms are lightweight things without much use in a business environment, but there are some decent application to be found on iOS (the Omnigroup apps come to mind.). There is also better support from business focused companies like VMware, ESRI, Autodesk, and all the conferencing companies like WebEx.
- michaelcampbell 15y agoI must be walking under a silver lined cloud; I've had an original droid since launch day over 2 years ago, and now an ICS Galaxy Nexus since launch day, and the Exchange integration has been better than my Windows PC, by and large. I've never had any of the issues you mention. I don't doubt you've had them, but I have not. I frequently get "dinged" on my phone for new email before Outlook. (I will admit that deleting a mail on outlook takes up to 5 minutes to "be gone" on the Android.) But never any calendar issues. Never any dropped mails. Never any needs to "hard reset". Lookups work as well on my phone as they do on outlook, for me.