4 ms·
The IRA increased taxes. Taxes are the most effective means of fighting inflation.[1] Long term, the IRA will reduce energy prices. Energy is a huge compone
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
The IRA increased taxes. Taxes are the most effective means of fighting inflation.[1]
Long term, the IRA will reduce energy prices. Energy is a huge component of inflation.
1: https://www.slowboring.com/p/tax-increases-are-the-best-cure-for https://www.slowboring.com/p/tax-increases-are-the-best-cure...
- throwayyy479087 4y agoFor the rest of the class, this is an economic fringe theory taken by economists about as seriously as astronomers take flat earthers
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> this is an economic fringe theory Fiscal policy's monetary effects are not a fringe theory. Increasing taxes reduces the money supply, and a smaller money supply decreases price levels ceteris paribus. This is conventional economics. Modern monetary theory goes a step further, arguing deficits and debts don't matter, all that matters is inflation. Which is sort of true, in a way, but also useless since it provides us with no system for predicting when inflation might become problematic beyond deficits and debts.
- wolverine876 4y ago> Increasing taxes reduces the money supply I don't doubt it, but I'm curious about how it works: If I buy a car from GM, who then uses the money to buy things from suppliers, who use the money to pay some people and build a new factory, etc. - that all increases the velocity of money which increases inflation. If I pay the same amount to the government, who then uses the money to buy things from suppliers ... how does that have a different inflationary effect? I'd guess that the government, with less revenue than expenses, doesn't save the tax revenue. It's not stuffed in a giant mattress at the Treasury. I would guess that it's spent, pretty soon. In fact, there might be more velocity if I give the money to the government than to a company sitting on fat cash reserves. EDIT: I just realized: Higher taxes reduce return on investment and thus reduce investment. Is that the only mechanism in play?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> pay the same amount to the government, who then uses the money to buy things from suppliers The first part is tax. The second spend. There is no obligation for the government to tax everything it spends, or spend everything it taxes. In practice, governments will spend what they tax which is why we need an independent central bank.
- wolverine876 4y ago> The first part is tax. The second spend. True, but I don't see how that impacts inflation. They do spend it, as you say, which returns us to my original question.
- miley_cyrus 4y agoThis is gaslighting -- increased taxes without increasing spending might reduce inflation. But the IRA massively increased government spending, and government spending is a primary driver of inflation. [1] 1: https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/fiscal-policy-and-excess-inflation-during-covid-19-a-cross-country-view-20220715.html https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/fisc...
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe IRA increased taxes by 740B and increased spending by 440B. That's a net reduction.
- aidenn0 4y agoIf you transfer wealth from the rich (who mostly use money to invest in assets) and transfer it to the poor (who mostly use money to buy consumer goods), wouldn't that naturally reduce asset values while increasing prices of consumer goods?
- bryanlarsen 4y agoPerhaps, but the IRA doesn't do that, unless the poor are suddenly buying electric cars and wind turbines. Also remember the time impact. Taxes went up immediately, whereas the bulk of the IRA rebates will happen in a few years.