2 ms·
>But no, there is not anything anyone can do with the critique Critique doesn't just exist to be actionable. It can also exist (as in this case) to remind of
by coldtea 4y ago
>But no, there is not anything anyone can do with the critique
Critique doesn't just exist to be actionable.
It can also exist (as in this case) to remind of a possibility. Especially in this case, where the possibility is precluded.
In fact that was the very intended. Pre/post contamination could still have happened, we can't just exclude it because "protocols were followed". Protocols have been followed in other cases where errors got in the way to.
Perhaps you didn't wanted to see a general comment, but somebody spotting a specific error in a specific step of the actual process?
- craftsman 4y agoAs I said in another comment, you may be reading too much into the statement to the press as opposed to the actual paper. It's more likely that the author quoted as saying that something could be "ruled out" meant, more precisely, that the possibility of contamination is very small, but non-zero, and that the overwhelmingly more likely conclusion is the existence of said compounds.