3 ms·
> Imagine how ridiculous and insulting it would be for a seasoned lawyer, a doctor or a CPA, to endure this nonsensical, pointless scrutiny when interviewing fo
by ryandrake 4y ago
> Imagine how ridiculous and insulting it would be for a seasoned lawyer, a doctor or a CPA, to endure this nonsensical, pointless scrutiny when interviewing for a job.
Good examples, because lawyers, doctors, and CPAs all have formal exams and licensures, and a board that certifies that you have the qualifications to do your job. So when a hospital interviews a doctor, they don't have to go over first year anatomy to understand whether the doctor knows where the appendix is. The process certifies a base standard of knowledge.
Software engineers don't have this, and every time it's brought up in conversation, it gets poo-poo'ed. So, 1. Companies have no idea if you know how to even turn on a computer, and 2. Candidates have to start from scratch every time explaining what a linked list is.
Wouldn't it be great, both from an employer's POV and from the candidate's POV, if you could show that you passed the exam and received your license from the Coding Board, therefore you have some very basic set of skills? Then, you could both skip the fizzbuzz part of the interview and interview about more domain-specific questions. It would cut the interview time by probably 50-75%. But for reasons, HN commenters hate this idea, it's imposing "gatekeeping" and infringing on their freedom to pick up a Raspberry Pi and call themselves an engineer. So..... we all have to live with these incredibly inefficient and capricious hiring processes.
- jjav 4y ago> The process certifies a base standard of knowledge. It'd be great to have CS and software engineering board tests that can be taken once and then do away with all the interview nonsense like other professional fields.
- 908B64B197 4y ago> Wouldn't it be great, both from an employer's POV and from the candidate's POV, if you could show that you passed the exam and received your license from the Coding Board, therefore you have some very basic set of skills? There are some certification authorities in the US, but as far as I'm aware, the top programs haven't even bothered with it (MIT, Stanford, CMU...). The main issue is that all CS degrees aren't created equal. Someone can graduate without much programming at certain schools (where the degree is way more math focused). That's completely fine in itself, it's ok to have an option to focus on theoretical math, but it's not necessarily what employers are looking for. Abroad, like in France and Switzerland, they seem to have some certification body that checks the course curricula and determines if it passes the bar to be called engineering. Perhaps not the best example as these two countries are smaller and, at least for France, way more centralized than the US. To be completely honest, I fast track interviews for new grads of certain institutions because I'm familiar with their programs and I know what they studied.