4 ms·
>The problem is too much debt, full stop. The fair way to address this is a modern debt jubilee: everyone gets the same nominal payout, debtors must use the pay
by gruez 4y ago
>The problem is too much debt, full stop. The fair way to address this is a modern debt jubilee: everyone gets the same nominal payout, debtors must use the payout to pay off debt, non-debtors may keep the money and do what they please with it.
Doesn't this fuck over savers who have their money parked in fixed income securities, while giving a huge boon to anyone owning equity in indebted companies? On a comparative basis, it also hugely benefits people in their late twenties/thirties who were able to take out massive loans (ie. mortgage) while not doing much for everyone else.
- recursivedoubts 4y agoIndividuals (not corporations) get the same payout, rich, poor, everyone. If you don't have debt, you get that money free and clear. It does dig younger people out of crushing debt, yes. That's the point: they can start a life without exponentially increasing debt grinding them to dust. This lets them participate in the wealth of the nation and incentivizes them to work and build families, thus producing more real wealth, rather than checking out and making just enough to pay the interest and monthly subscriptions. There is no way out of this that doesn't involve helping young people throw off the yoke of crushing usury. A modern debt jubilee is the fairest way to do that: it rewards savers to an extent with free and clear money while paying off the debt of debtors.
- aqme28 4y agoSo debt has nothing to do with it, it’s a one-time universal payout?
- recursivedoubts 4y agoYes. Everyone gets the payment. The catch is that debtors must use the payment to extinguish their debt. Non-debtors get the money free and clear. This is as fair a mechanic as I have ever heard for a debt jubilee. Steve Keen is a genius.
- CamelCaseName 4y agoThis is simply a wealth transfer to institutions who lent money at low rates prior to the rate increases.
- recursivedoubts 4y agoIt is not simply that, although it does ensure that the money that those institutions lent is paid back, rather than defaulted on. But let's be honest: what's really going to happen in the case of defaults is that the banks will seize the real underlying assets and sell them at fire-sale prices to other rich people. The important part is that the borrower is now out from under exponential debt and can get on with their lives, and total debt in the economy is brought down to a sustainable level. Non-debtors get something too: free and clear cash. Is it perfect? No, of course not. Nothing this simple could be perfectly fair. But it is simple, hard to game, addresses the core problem (too much debt) and is probably as fair as it will get, practically. Certainly the elites would scream bloody murder if someone important legitimately proposed it. Keen has been ignored and mocked for years. That's evidence enough for me.
- shjake 4y agoIt also impossible to enforce. And is basically equivalent to “why don’t we just print more money and give it everyone?”. And anyway a terrible idea.. why do you want to penalize people who have low interest rate mortgages for instance? Anything they’d gain would be offset by inflation…
- lief79 4y agoGood point ... paying down my mortgage faster is a fairly poor use of the funds. However, if it can be used for regular payments or prepayments over a period of time, it's not a bad deal. I'd hope they'd also make exceptions for any loans under the current rate of inflation, but good luck getting that passed. Having to immediately pay off a 0% loan (if anyone still offers those) clearly is far from the optimal use of the money.
- mindslight 4y agoI haven't read the proposal directly, but by your description of it I don't know how it could possibly work. Even if debtors pay off a chunk of their debt, companies will be lining up to offer them new debt, especially as the chance of default goes down with the new precedent. The way a real debt jubilee has to work is that debt is repudiated, with the creditor left holding the bag - not made good on.