3 ms·
>You better alert the scientists that they missed something, then! That's some serious business, they must be alerted to their failings immediately! Yes, unima
by coldtea 4y ago
>You better alert the scientists that they missed something, then! That's some serious business, they must be alerted to their failings immediately!
Yes, unimaginable that scientists could have made a mistake that a layman could spot, or just said something to create good PR to their mission, even when it's inaccurate.
They also never unwittingly or intentionally BS in their research papers, right? And only a colleague (or a higher level intellect than theirs) could spot a mistake... /s
>Seriously though, do you really think these scientists are making claims, being widely reported, without having made the same conclusions and analysed the situation with all the data, not just that reported through a story on the Internet .. ?
Seriously, similar blunders have happened time and again.
In 1996, scientists at NASA declared that a 6.3-ounce
rock, broken off from a Mars meteorite discovered in
Antarctica in 1984, contained flecks of chemical compounds
— polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, magnetite, and iron
sulfide — that suggested the existence of bacteria on the
Red Planet 3.6 billion years ago. "August 7, 1996, could
go down as one of the most important dates in human
history," intoned one newspaper report. But within two
years the theory began to crack.
Traces of amino acids found in the rock, crucial to life,
were also found in the surrounding Antarctic ice. More
damning, other non-Martian rocks — rocks from the moon,
where it is clear life does not exist — showed the same
"evidence" of life. By November 1998 an article in Science
declared "most researchers agree that the case for life on
Mars is shakier than ever."
>Because it seems you're smarter than rocket scientists. Are you a brain surgeon, then?
This particular case aside, you appear to believe that you need to be smarter than X person to be able to spot an error they made. It doesn't take a very high IQ however to see the error in the above idea.
In any case, based on the insults, did you just wanted to lash out on someone to feel better for yourself?
- aa-jv 4y ago[flagged]
- permo-w 4y agoif you want people to engage with you seriously, perhaps avoid such a condescending tone. ditching the sarcastic italics could be a good place to start the way it currently reads is less like curiosity and more like “how dare you question the judgment of scientists”, as if questioning results isn’t the absolute bedrock of science in the first place
- lumb63 4y agoNowadays, to a lot of folks, questioning isn’t the bedrock of science. “Trusting the experts/science” is. That’s the root behind a lot of issues we’ve seen socially, especially over the last few years.
- craftsman 4y agoDisagree. It's trivial to question. It's non-trivial to do the work required to show evidence for or against some proposition. What is at "the root behind a lot of issues we've seen socially" is the easy path of questioning something without actually being able to do the work required to back up one's claims or counterclaims. So I believe the reaction which you think of as "trust the experts / science" is actually "do the work and show the evidence". If a paper is published which claims that such-and-such drug shows effectiveness against shingles, it's easy and trivial to say, "Not so fast my friend" followed by any number of statements about Big Pharma, citing previous situations in which a claim was later shown to be false, etc. But while all of those things may, in fact, be true, they don't bring to bear any actual evidence that this particular drug study is flawed and exactly how.
- coldtea 4y ago>It's trivial to question. It's also trivial to accept though. And in a world where you can't (for time and effort constrains) check every announcement personally, and where expert proclamations aren't always correct so thay you can just take them as granted, there are still reasons to have an estimation (as a layman but even as a scientist) of something being true or not summarily.
- craftsman 4y agoThe alternative I've suggested is rather different than the suggested alternatives of accepting results or taking them for granted. In another comment I said: > I'd suggest reading every paper critically, realizing (as most people do) that the results are tentative, and either letting it go at that, or dig in and do the hard work to figure out what may be flawed in the work presented. Then work with the authors or publish a paper of one's own pointing out the flaw and the new resulting analysis.
- coldtea 4y agoI know better than scientists have time and again made mistakes, and claimed something with certainty, even though it was wrong, despite, you know "actually working with the data and not just reading about it on the Internet". I also know that scientists have a bias to show impressive results, and that even NASA among others, in a similar case was all too fast to jump to conclusions and make a whole show about their 'findings' and annoucements to the press, and they still got it comically wrong, despite "actually working with the data and not just reading about it on the Internet.". Finally, I know that "we found RNA building blocks and B3" on a meteorite is less likely that contamination, so the story seems fishy and premature. Sorry that somebody even doubted than an announcement or a paper can ever be likely wrong without being on the team who wrote it. Now how about some apologies for your tone?
- craftsman 4y ago> Finally, I know that "we found RNA building blocks and B3" on a meteorite is less likely that contamination, so the story seems fishy and premature. Since you rightly encourage everyone to question claims, I question this claim. How do you know this, specifically? In other words, we have a situation where a team has done a bunch of experiments, data collection, and analysis, and then published a paper claiming "we found RNA building blocks and B3", right? And now your claim is "no, you're wrong about that," but without any experiments, data collection, and analysis. So if you're going to make a claim, provide the details, data, and evidence that substantiates your claim.
- coldtea 4y agoYou can call it a prior (like in Bayesian probability) on the probability of such an announcement being right. Same, to give an obvious extreme example, as I'd be sceptical about an annoucencement that "We found the perpetual machine, there was a major flaw in thermodynamics laws, here are our numbers and results", even if they're world reknown experts in physics saying it, and I don't have access to their data, or to the machine to try it myself - hell, even if I can't understand their formulas. One would still have a prior in this case, based on a general understanding of the the world, and the possibility range where this falls. You might have a more informed prior because you took more concrete information into account than mere experience of other such announcements being repeatedly proven wrong, the probability of RNA being found on a meteor sample, the probability of the team just being lax with their annoucement to get publicity and grants, and so on. Or, I guess, you think that we should never do that, and we should either do the research ourselves, or wait until someone else does, and at any point, whatever they say as their conclusion, them being experts and having done the work and everything, should be the final word. Which probably means that as you see it, it makes no sense, to have a belief on anything or its refutation as likely or unlikely, unless one has either replicated the study and checked the conclusions, or found specific actionable faults.
- craftsman 4y agoI think what the other poster is trying to say is something like the following: There was a team / teams who planned the mission, designed and built the spacecraft and its systems & instruments, designed and performed tests on the samples, analyzed the data, and published a paper with some claims. The paper outlines their methods, test results, data, and conclusions. Now, is it okay to question anything in the paper? Yes, absolutely. How probable is it that something in the paper is wrong or could be improved? Definitely non-zero, it happens a lot. People who understand various aspects of the instruments used, the tests, data analysis, etc, often find some minor or major flaw in scientific papers. Could it happen with this one? Yes, absolutely. How probable is it that someone on HN--knowing that there are lots of people on HN with diverse expertise--will find something wrong with the paper, and that the substance of the flaw they found is: > I seriously doubt that it could be "ruled out" just like that. > For one, the spacecraft (or the empty capsules) could have been pre-contaminated before their launch. > Second, the capsules could have been contaminated after arrival even if they were "sealed" (perhaps the seal had issues, or maybe it happened when they opened them, since one assumes they couldn't test still sealed capsules, they'd have to open them). Non-zero, but very low. Could it happen? Yes, it could very well be that the team(s) involved did not consider that contamination could occur before or after the sample was obtained and analyzed. How likely is it? Hard to say, but if it happened, the critique would not take the form of "Hey, it could have been contaminated!" Rather, it would take the form of "I notice in the sample handling procedure that such-and-such technique was applied. Further, in the data analysis, such-and-such test was not done, therefore one could not rule out ..." You get the idea.
- coldtea 4y agoMy claim wasn't that "the team(s) involved did not consider that contamination could occur before or after the sample was obtained and analyzed". I merely gave a trivial (even exhaustive!) enumeration of possible contamination cases that could still have happened (regardless of whether they are targeted against in their protocols), not some novel avenue for contamination that I claim to be "smarter than the scientists" to come up with. Of course they knew of those contamination possibilities. I didn't say anything about them having missed such basic contamination cases. What I did (and am) suggesting is that they probably are too confident in their protocols having been executed correctly and being 100% tight with no possibility of error. And that that those avenues of contamination are still a real possibility (protocols to prevent them be damned). Now, this might not be the case. This might indeed be space travelling RNA-combound and B3 vitamin. But I'd say that the probability of contamination being the case and someone (on HN or wherever) calling it correctly, is equal to the probability of the samples being contaminated. Which is not that small. Spotting some novel contamination route they haven't thought off would indeed be very rare and a major feat. But merely been less confident (that they are) in their thoroughness and in their preclusion of contamination, is much easier to claim and be correct while doing so.