4 ms·
What are some superior competing standards, and could they be implemented in a royalty-free way?
by nine_k 4y ago
What are some superior competing standards, and could they be implemented in a royalty-free way?
- WeylandYutani 4y agoIf they went extinct they were not superior.
- asah 4y agothe best tech doesn't always win, and in fact the "best" tech is typically promoted by people who focus more on the tech and less on go-to-market and competitive strategy. And thus, the "best" tech often loses to the tech that (for example) is better packaged or promoted. Python is a nice example: inelegant language with many deep flaws, but easy syntax and "batteries included" won the day.
- eddieroger 4y agoBetamax was superior to VHS, and it went the way of the dinosaur. Sometimes better means more expensive, and that's not always the popular choice. It wasn't the better survivor, but it was the better format. First to market, higher res, smaller tape, longer life, still lost. But don't take my word for it. https://kodakdigitizing.com/blogs/news/what-is-the-difference-between-betamax-and-vhs https://kodakdigitizing.com/blogs/news/what-is-the-differenc...
- bombcar 4y agoSuperior includes cost, and even things like number of suppliers.
- Sporktacular 4y agoThat's just not true. Shoddy builders put quality builders out of business all the time. Guess it depends on your faith in markets and your definition of superior.
- Sporktacular 4y agoThe point was more about competing technical choices made by designers, rather than the choice of standards made by consumers. For example TDMA can be arguably more scalable, bandwidth and energy efficient than CSMA/CD and can give consistent PL, PD and PDV, so might have even allowed early business grade voice. Variable header sizes would have allowed efficient use over bandwidth constrained media like radio. But the low cost and fast success of Ethernet formed a barrier to entry for competing LAN standards, where those arguably better technical choices may have found a footing. They eventually found application in other non-LAN standards, so guess royalties weren't an issue.
- RF_Savage 4y agoTDMA needs time synchronization and thus becomes more complex. Even in telecoms the packet switched connections are quickly replacing synchronous time division connections.
- jabl 4y agoThe recent-ish 10base-t1 uses something called PLCA instead of CSMA/CD which doesn't require time synchronization, and gives each node in a subnet a dedicated transmission slot.
- RF_Savage 4y ago10Base-T1L is point to point, 10Base-T1S is multidrop, but very limited in nodes and how long the branches/stubs can be. We'll see how it actually performs in field. Microchip seems to be in the T1S boat and TI+AD in T1L.
- xenadu02 4y agoNone of those things could be implemented in the 1970 or 1980s at reasonable cost so they're not actually solutions at all. Hell even making Ethernet fully switched didn't really happen until the 1990s thanks to Moore's law making the ASICs cheap enough. Without mass adoption there's no reason to invest. Look at Token Ring, Ethernet's only real competitor at scale: it quickly started to lag behind. Ethernet shipped 100Mbps several years before Token Ring. The 1Gbps Token Ring standard was never put to hardware.