6 ms·
It’s bizarre to point to criticism of the government to justify the failures of the government. What exactly are people supposed to do in response to public ser
by rayiner 4y ago
It’s bizarre to point to criticism of the government to justify the failures of the government. What exactly are people supposed to do in response to public services that are over budget and don’t serve their needs?
Surely the solution to criticism of government inefficiency is for government to operate well. If visiting San Francisco was like going to Tokyo or Copenhagen—clean, efficient, convenient—Fox News would lose credibility. At some point, people in Missouri would point to San Francisco and be like “that’s great, why don’t we do that here?”
- enraged_camel 4y ago>> It’s bizarre to point to criticism of the government to justify the failures of the government. This is precisely the conservative game plan though: starve the government of funds, force it to outsource as much as possible to the private sector, then when projects end up delayed and overbudget (or failing), point to lack of government efficiency and competence to justify further funding cuts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast This has been happening since basically the Reagan era. >> Surely the solution to criticism of government inefficiency is for government to operate well. No organization can operate well if it doesn't have necessary levels of funding, and the government is no exception. Said lack of funding is the primary cause of the inefficiencies, which often times manifest as lack of inhouse expertise that can provide strict analysis of and oversight for projects outsourced to the private sector.
- surement 4y ago> Said lack of funding is the primary cause of the inefficiencies No, the primary cause is politicians promising things that sound good so that they'll get reelected, because that's the number one thing they care about, not efficiency. On the other hand a private company will only build something that makes economical sense.
- Ozzie_osman 4y ago> On the other hand a private company will only build something that makes economical sense. Yes, economical sense to the company. But not all things that are good for society make economic sense for companies.
- prottog 4y agoYes, if lack of funding is the primary cause, then the federal government should be quite effective indeed, considering how much money it receives and spends.
- surement 4y agogovernment agencies are the only ones that get MORE money when they fail to deliver
- mrguyorama 4y ago"makes economic sense" is not a useful metric to build society on. There are so many things in our day to day life that should be considered well beyond "does this make a profit"
- surement 4y agolike what?
- dyno12345 4y ago> Said lack of funding is the primary cause of the inefficiencies San Francisco? Lack of funding? $14 billion isn't enough? The budget of San Francisco has roughly doubled in about the last ten years: is the government now twice as good at whatever it's supposed to do than it was ten years ago?
- greendave 4y agoIf anything the problem with San Francisco is that there is so much money that an entire ecosystem of nonprofits and contractors has evolved to feed off those funds.
- XorNot 4y agoThe expression is "not enough money to do it right, but enough to do it twice". You can easily blow out a budget with foolish upfront attempts to save money.
- misssocrates 4y agoHasn't the beast has grown far larger and more obese since then?
- rayiner 4y agoHow does that explain the situation in deep blue states with respect to services such as transit and education that are primarily state funded? Is the ghost of Reagan haunting California and keeping San Francisco from having well funded, efficient services like Copenhagen?
- AussieWog93 4y ago>It’s bizarre to point to criticism of the government to justify the failures of the government. I think that would be a fair statement to make in the global context, but Americans' distrust and paranoia around anything the Government does really is exceptional.
- calvinmorrison 4y ago9/11, Ruby Ridge, JFK, Tonkin Golf, Martin Luther King, Iran/Contra, yada yada yada yada yada yada yada yada
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoWar on drugs, 20yr of military involvement in the middle east, meddling in Latin America, three letter agencies manufacturing domestic terrorism of all types and the list goes on...
- ambicapter 4y agoWhat do any of those have to do with the government entities involved in infrastructure projects?
- calvinmorrison 4y ago9/11 had a large impact on infrastructure
- skissane 4y ago> I think that would be a fair statement to make in the global context, but Americans' distrust and paranoia around anything the Government does really is exceptional. I'm not sure how accurate that generalisation is. The US has a lot of government – in some ways, a lot more than many other countries do, because local government in the US has a lot of responsibilities which in other countries are centralised at the state/province or even national levels - such as law enforcement, courts and prosecutors, public education, correctional facilities. Much of the US has two layers of local government (county and municipal), some parts even have three layers (e.g. the state of New York has village governments underneath town governments underneath county governments), when many other countries only have a single layer. The US has lots of special-purpose local governments (school districts, drainage districts, emergency services districts, etc), where in many other countries those kind of functions would be performed by state/provincial/national agencies instead. Most of the anti-government rhetoric in the US is primarily directed at the federal government, not state or local governments. Even when state or local governments are targeted, it tends to be only directed at some of them. Some American conservatives will be very critical of the state governments of California or New York, but I doubt they'd be anywhere near as negative about the state governments of Florida or Texas or Utah or South Dakota. Or very critical of the county/city governments of big liberal-leaning urban areas like Los Angeles, New York, San Francisco, Chicago, but far less likely to criticise the local government of some rural "Red State" county or town. Despite its reputation for hyper-capitalism, the US is arguably "behind" much of the rest of the English-speaking world when it comes to asset privatisation, public-private partnerships, public funding of private schools (US % of K-12 students in private schools is significantly below the OECD average, and severely limited public funding for private schools is likely a big factor in that), etc – and those issues are far from being the top priority for contemporary American conservatism. Which suggest that the US is actually far less "anti-government" than its popular image suggests.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lmm 4y agoSure, but to operate well you need to be able to hire top talent (and therefore pay top dollar) and you need to give them the freedom to do what they think best without being micromanaged, both things that require a level of public trust. This seems to be one of those "multiple stable equilibria" problems - a government that is trusted can be effective and justify that trust, a government that is mistrusted will be ineffective and justify that mistrust.
- juve1996 4y agoI would always choose San Francisco over Missouri. Every day of the week. St Louis' crime rate dwarfs san francisco, and the economy is much weaker. You can cherry pick stats that support your cause all day. The fact is people in other states have infrastructure that some of my taxes went to. I will never use those roads. Perhaps we should all be selfish and just take more and more for ourselves? Principled, fiscal responsibility is a great thing and what I would champion - but these bad faith arguments are not fiscal responsibility. We need some level of service and infrastructure. Even if costs overrun, we still need highways.
- wincy 4y ago[flagged]
- mrguyorama 4y ago>Fox News would lose credibility. Fox news can openly tell a court that it knowingly lied to its audience and lose only ten percent or so of its audience. They faced bigger backlash being critical of Trump. Meanwhile there are 49 other states, some of which that do things well, but fox news doesn't talk about that because they don't run positive stories about government because of their ideology.
- another2another 4y ago>If visiting San Francisco was like going to Tokyo or Copenhagen—clean, efficient, convenient A lot of the positive traits of these cities come from the citizens themselves. It's them as much as the government of these places that want that - therefore they create a system that achieves what they want - 'the government', and are willing to cooperate with it to get what they want. If all San Franciscans wanted a clean, efficient and convenient city, I'm more than convinced that all citizens working towards that goal could readily achieve it, and would make a government tasked with those goals. Governments I would argue, since they're usually made up of the local people, reflect the goals of these people. And if 'good enough' is OK for them, then that's what they get.
- rayiner 4y ago> A lot of the positive traits of these cities come from the citizens themselves. It's them as much as the government of these places that want that - therefore they create a system that achieves what they want - 'the government', and are willing to cooperate with it to get what they want. I would agree with that. > If all San Franciscans wanted a clean, efficient and convenient city, I'm more than convinced that all citizens working towards that goal could readily achieve it, and would make a government tasked with those goals. I think you have to carry through your reasoning from the first point. People in San Francisco have different goals than those in Copenhagen or Tokyo. I strongly suspect that they also have differing (and lesser) ability to put aside their individual concerns to work together on a mass compromise like public transit inevitably must be. Which is a good reason for the rest of the country to not want to throw a bunch of money on transit projects. American infrastructure reflects the American psyche. We drive around in individual steel tanks on roads that can take us anywhere we want to go because that’s who we are as a culture.