3 ms·
Seems too sensationalist to be plausible...
by yan 18y ago
Seems too sensationalist to be plausible...
- ph0rque 18y agoI thought so too, but the article seems to make sense for a materials science angle...
- noonespecial 18y agoYep. Getting tired of the cycle. Every 3-6 months since 98 or so (when I started reading slashdot) there's a "major discovery that will revolutionize solar power!". The article spends three lines on a few pseudo-scientific generalizations and the rest gushing about how power generation companies' days are numbered. Its been a decade. Photo-voltaic solar still sucks just as much as it did before the turn of the century. I'm tired of hearing about anti-glare coatings, stupid mirror tricks, splitting water to get hydrogen with your solar power, etc. Sticking a plain old solar cell in your rube-goldberg is not a breakthrough. Call me when we get drastically more efficient silicon wafers. You can keep your mirrors. Sorry for the rant y'all.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoEnjoyed the rant. News is nothing without context. We get a lot of noise in this area, but no useful context. I'm just glad that fusion is only 20 years away, and has been for the last 40 years.
- DaniFong 18y agoFusion power yield has grown even faster than Moore's law. It just started really, really low.
- hugh 18y agoCall me when we get drastically more efficient silicon wafers Not gonna happen: we're already at 30%, and don't have room for a "drastic" increase. I'm far more interested in a drastic reduction in cost.
- DaniFong 18y agoAnd durability. Deserts would be perfect for solar power, were it not for sandstorms...
- DaniFong 18y agoI personally think almost every one of these advances should be covered by the media. I dislike the characteristic journalist euphoria that always accompanies the article, but it's always clear enough where fiction enters. I can always filter it out. And if they didn't hit the mainstream news channels, I probably would hear about it much later. Incidentally, any technology that can obviate the need for solar panels to tilt towards the sun will vast improve maintenance, installation, and probably manufacturing costs. The tilting super structure accounts for a large percentage of the cost in a solar power station (often in excess of 30%, according to DOE studies).