5 ms·
We should not forget that illicit images are easily 'found' in convenient places to get people put behind bars. I don't really blame this journalist for suspec
by londons_explore 4y ago
We should not forget that illicit images are easily 'found' in convenient places to get people put behind bars.
I don't really blame this journalist for suspecting the illicit images claim may not be as true as it appears.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoBased upon NPR's telling it seems like the editor was trying to hide details about a friend's story as long as possible, and not present the details of the story with skepticism like you're implying.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jstarfish 4y agoI know what you're referring to but don't think this is one of those cases. The affidavit is very thorough about what was found. Starts on page 3. https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1566416/download https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1566416/downl...
- TylerE 4y agoTo split the difference a bit... They have him "on tape" IMing multiple other suspects, talking extremely graphically about pedophilia, and exchanging images and video of same.
- briantakita 4y ago"on tape" meaning they have a video of him in front of a computer engaging in the conversation? I skimmed through the affidavit & couldn't find that claim. It was difficult to read the content so I didn't look to deeply into it. Could you post a quote of the claim if it's there?
- martinjacobd 4y agoThey don't claim to have video of him engaging in the conversation, but they do claim to have a pretty damning picture of him. To support the idea that it was he who engaged in these messages, they claim that you can only be logged in to kik on one device at a time and have evidence that he was using the device for other purposes around the same time and in the same location as kik for at least one of these conversations. That's my reading, anyways. Not a lawyer and have trouble with the stilted language in these kinds of things.
- TylerE 4y agoOn tape as in they have the phone with messages on it, and the ip addeess and device info used to send the messages. (As opposed to testimony, where you have someone else testifying that they SAW him doing it, but no way of proving that post facto)
- recyclelater 4y agoFYI to anyone curious, do not read the affidavit if you do not want to have pretty horrific images of infants etc in your mind.
- scythe 4y agoSo Dropbox found uploads, allegedly from Meek, containing CP. Then devices were found at Meek's residence containing CP. To there, you could fake it: pwn the box, open a Dropbox, upload pictures. Basic parallel construction. In items 30-53 we have an allegation that Meek exposed himself to children on Omegle. This is more damning. Included in the evidence are pictures apparently showing Meek naked. Harder to fake. His face does not seem to be visible in any of the images. Some legitimate communications of Meek are also on the phone, corresponding with his known whereabouts (and might be checked against the other end if possible). Conclusion: if this is a frame, it's a very well-made one. Why would he be framed, though? He made a documentary about a military embarrassment (the Tongo Tongo ambush), and many years ago he documented a case of apparent manslaughter (of an American) by a captain in Iraq. In short, he was not exactly a Seymour Hersh or a Glenn Greenwald. I just don't see the 3LAs going to this much trouble to bag a guy who wrote a story about Niger. So I conclude the case is probably real. Thought I'd put this down and save someone else the trouble.
- celdon25 4y agoThank you, it’s hard to find reasonably good arguments like this in the HN comments these days.
- penultimatename 4y agoIsn't it a reporters job to report the facts? The fact is the FBI was investigating them for a specific crime. It's already suspect that they left out that key fact. It's extra suspect when it turns out they had personal connections to the accused.
- sidewndr46 4y agoIf you think the government only reports facts, stop reading Rolling Stone. Read the FBI report.
- jstarfish 4y agoI'd give Rolling Stone a little bit of slack on this one. The last time they rushed to paint suspects as rapists ahead of any sort of actual trial, they got sued to hell for defamation when the allegations turned out to be fraudulent altogether. I could excuse them for being a little slower on the draw this time around. "Being investigated by the FBI" does not mean the subject is automatically guilty. My wife's ex was "being investigated by CPS" at one point. He didn't do anything, but it is/was humiliating for him nonetheless.
- brwck 4y ago[flagged]
- pr0zac 4y agoI'm really confused how you read that sentence as spinning Rolling Stone's actions positively?
- brwck 4y agoBut he used it as justification to "give Rolling Stone a little bit of slack on this one.". It's interesting how criticizing trash publications like the rolling stone with facts and truth gets your comment flagged. Makes one wonder...
- 4y ago
- john15 4y ago[flagged]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago> the investigation into James Gordon Meek, 53, of Arlington, was initiated from an investigative lead sent by Dropbox and ultimately received by the FBI Washington Field Office’s Child Exploitation and Human Trafficking Task Force.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoThe problem with stating stuff like this is it can be used as an example of how deep the conspiracy goes rather than a refutation.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoTo the conspiracy minded, sure. How can any discussion be had with these people who don't require evidence in order to make bold claims?
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoHonestly, no idea. Seems a fool's errand.
- ipaddr 4y agoDropbox working with the fbi is a fact here. Jumping to dropbox working with the fbi regarding other files is fact as well. Dropbox knowing what is in your files is known as well. It stops being a conspiracy when everyone admits to the facts
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoThe poster insinuated that the FBI planted CSAM on a reporter's devices.
- vuln 4y agoWell at one point they were paying GeekSquaders to _find_ and report it. > "how does the government intend to prove beyond any reasonable doubt that the Geek Squad employees themselves didn't put the alleged porn pictures on the device?" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13841504 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13841504
- tempsy 4y ago[flagged]
- version_five 4y agoIt's fucked up that a conspiracy theory gets the top post and actual criticisms of the reporting are at the bottom.
- rocket_surgeron 4y agoFirst day on HN? When you ask for examples of this happening they get really mad and try to hide your question by downvoting it.
- madeofpalk 4y agoSo then report on that?
- lalopalota 4y agoThe journalist quit after the pedophilla charges were edited out of the article.
- mrandish 4y agoIn an era of "insta-reputational death by accusation in media being the punishment", I want media to be cautious and skeptical when there are no real facts yet. An affidavit in support of a search warrant is little more than an unevidenced assertion. Compared to the often extreme punitive consequences of the mere accusation being widely spread it can be disproportionate. If the warrant produces actual evidence of wrongdoing it will later result in an indictment and ultimately a trial. That's the more appropriate time for media to consider those allegations as newsworthy. Sadly, there are documented examples of government (or individuals wielding the power of government) using extreme accusations in affidavits to intentionally inflict punishment. Rolling Stone choosing to not be unwitting 'judge-jury-executioner' at that early no-evidence stage doesn't mean they wouldn't report on an eventual indictment - when and if it happens.
- leephillips 4y agoYou make excellent points, and in a world were we know that people will remember accusations and not subsequent exonerations, it would be humane to delay reporting on the kind of accusation that will ruin a person’s life. The problem is that Rolling Stone plays favorites. In a recent incident they ran the false headline “CPAC Speaker Calls for Transgender People to Be Eradicated,” about someone that they didn’t like and who wasn’t a friend of the editor in chief. After being threatened with a lawsuit for this libel, they changed the headline. I don’t think they can be trusted.
- mcguire 4y agoSeems like that article is currently titled much more accurately: "CPAC Speaker Calls for Eradication of ‘Transgenderism’ — and Somehow Claims He’s Not Calling for Elimination of Transgender People".
- myko 4y agoThe speaker called for transgenderism to be eradicated. Consider headlines if AOC called for conservatism to be eradicated.
- burkaman 4y ago
- tqi 4y agoIn the absence of evidence, what is the line between a "reasonable suspicion" and a "conspiracy theory"?
- brookst 4y agoYou said it yourself -- it's the difference between a suspicion, aka hypothesis, and theory, aka explanation based on evidence. The problem with conspiracy theorists isn't that they think unlikely things might have happened, it's that they are 100% convicted that unlikely things are the only possible explanation, and (typically) that any evidence to the contrary is just part of the conspiracy.
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago> We should not forget that illicit images are easily 'found' in convenient places to get people put behind bars. "The CIA will dump kiddie porn on your computer if you cross them" is basically "the ATF will shoot your dog if you cross them" trope but for a different group of people. Based on other comments it seems like the accusations are a bit more substantial than a low effort frame. Nevertheless, there's a reason that the rest of the journalism industry basically dismissed it flat out. That said if this were anybody that wasn't part of the media "club" the media would not have extended them the benefit of the doubt and would have ran with the accusation in the title. That's the part that really bothers me. Screw them and their double standard.
- bsder 4y ago> "The CIA will dump kiddie porn on your computer if you cross them" is basically "the ATF will shoot your dog if you cross them" trope but for a different group of people. Except that we know, via Snowden, all manner of things that the TLAs can do and have done. "Child Porn" charges should ALWAYS be acknowledged with great skepticism given just how much damage even the accusation will do--especially if the investigation is focused on just one person (ie. not part of a broader sting or sweep). However, in this instance, the evidence looks pretty damning. I still don't like them reporting on it, though. The man deserves the opportunity to prove his innocence in court and reporting the accusations denies him that--even if he is found innocent (which admittedly looks unlikely), the reporting will destroy his life. > That said if this were anybody that wasn't part of the media "club" the media would not have extended them the benefit of the doubt and would have ran with the accusation in the title. That's the part that really bothers me. Screw them and their double standard. That is fair and hard to disagree with.