3 ms·
> It would be interesting to compare prices of privately funded projects vs publicly funded ones, both in terms of cost, over-budget amounts and time needed to
by mschuster91 4y ago
> It would be interesting to compare prices of privately funded projects vs publicly funded ones, both in terms of cost, over-budget amounts and time needed to complete the project.
Take for example the Munich "Luise Kiesselbach Tunnel": it finished early and under budget, and to my knowledge in its seven years of operation there was no apparent case of cutting corners or botched work. And now one may ask, how is that possible in the country that produced infamous disasters such as the BER airport, the Elbphilharmonie or the #2 S-Bahn tunnel under Munich?
The answer is, the funding makes no difference - the oversight of the funders over the construction process does. When you have to hire external consultants for each project, where the people keep on rotating, instead of having expert knowledge in-house that answers to you, you'll always end up with worse quality - and the external consultants may not have the political standing to override pushes for changes, which tend to be a massive issue in government-funded projects.
- Robotbeat 4y agoThe problem is that regulated “oversight” is no guarantee of cost reductions, either, and may be a significant portion of the cost increases. Incentive alignment is one of the main problems. When big projects become “job builders,” you’ve now completely misaligned your incentives.
- mschuster91 4y agoProper oversight and project leadership (as in, it goes beyond "call McKinsey and have them send over a couple of seniors") can save costs at many parts of the process: - catch politicians' bullshit before planning (plans that, say, lead directly through a nature reserve) or during construction (e.g. a new politician comes in and wishes some random shit to change just to be able to brag "I did something") and intervene - check bids on tenders if they are actually plausible or if they are so far under a realistic budget that there will be massive problems later on (e.g. the company threatening insolvency to demand re-negotiated higher rates) - check impediments if they are actually legitimate or if they are overblown and resolve them - keep vendors accountable to milestones You can forget about the first two points, which are the most critical, for external consultants.