3 ms·
In my experience project managers can often be fairly realistic. But everyone up the management chain (understandably) wants projects to cost less and take less
by ghaff 4y ago
In my experience project managers can often be fairly realistic. But everyone up the management chain (understandably) wants projects to cost less and take less time. So a lot of pencil sharpening happens to take slack out of the system. Then deliveries are late, Joe is out with the flu for a week, v arious unexpected problems are encountered, etc. And before you know it you're overbudget and late.
- kevviiinn 4y agoAlmost like we shouldn't be listening to MBAs who don't know the intricacies and expect everything to turn out perfect in order to pinch pennies
- ghaff 4y agoI've had plenty of pushback from managers (and customers) who didn't have MBAs. The difference is usually between how long things "should" take everything going well and how long things often do take. On a small/personal scale, you can (and I do) sandbag to a certain degree. But it's hard on a large project when everyone and their brother is looking to trim any fat out of the estimates.
- kevviiinn 4y agoAnd how do they know how long anything should take, especially when they don't understand the details of the process? Sometimes "trimming fat" just isn't realistic or even possible
- asdff 4y agoAll that matters is that you get the contract. Sunk cost fallacy keeps your customers. It probably also helps that everyone operates like this, so its typical to expect things to come in late and overbudget to a degree.
- bumby 4y agoThe counterargument on large projects is there's so much coordination between different groups that the location of the "fat" becomes opaque and difficult to identify.
- Arrath 4y agoProject managers often come in too late, in my experience. And they are, by and large, realistic. Specifically for construction, the low-balling stage is when the Estimators are putting together a tender to try to secure the work in the first place. The PM arrives later, once the project has been awarded and now they have to make these estimator sourced budgets and schedules somehow jive with reality. It isn't an easy task.
- bumby 4y agoOne of the researchers mentioned by another commenter has termed this "strategic misrepresentation": The first theory Flyvbjerg embraced is called “strategic misrepresentation.” Which is essentially a fancy way of saying that you lie in order to get what you want. >FLYVBJERG: We’d actually interviewed planners who said that they did this deliberately, that they actually were incentivized to misrepresent the business cases for the projects in their benefit-cost analysis. And they wanted their projects to look good on paper, to increase their chances of getting funded and getting approval for their projects. And they said, “We do this by underestimating the cost and overestimating the benefits, because that gives us a nice high benefit-cost ratio so that we actually get chosen.[1] I've experience this, but I also think it may depend on the unique culture of individual organizations. Of course, it's likely just one of many factors that ultimately lead to poor planning. The podcast in [1] covers some of them and it's a good listen for anyone interested in public work projects. [1] https://freakonomics.com/podcast/heres-why-all-your-projects-are-always-late-and-what-to-do-about-it-rebroadcast/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/heres-why-all-your-projects...