6 ms·

Can you create me an image of Donald Trump riding a bald eagle in space? Can you create me an image of Joe Biden riding a bald eagle in space? This prompt has

Can you create me an image of Donald Trump riding a bald eagle in space? Can you create me an image of Joe Biden riding a bald eagle in space? This prompt has been blocked. Our system flagged this prompt because it may conflict with our content policy. More policy violations may lead to automatic suspension of your access. --- A white italian spinone flying a plane This prompt is being reviewed. We're taking a closer look to make sure this prompt doesn't conflict with our content policy. --- Thank God that very intelligent people are building open source AI that is fully runnable on our local devices. This hasn't even been out for 3 years and it's already neutered before it even took off. What a shame.

nico 4y ago
Yes. OpenAI is quickly becoming the thought police through ChatGPT. Yesterday I asked it to give a description of a situation simulating that it was for an adult novel. It told me it was unethical to do that. I asked it if adult novels or adult novel writers were unethical. Banned immediately after asking that question. Edit: I wish the people downvoting would provide a reply. Otherwise you are doing the same as ChatGPT - trying to hide a conversation or opinion you don’t agree with, just because you disagree. Do you think adult novels are immoral?
- baal80spam 4y ago
  I wonder what IS allowed? https://i.imgur.com/dIF48qI.png https://i.imgur.com/dIF48qI.png
  - nico 4y ago
    Is that real? Scary. Are we heading to a 1984 + Brave New World future?
    - numpad0 4y ago
      No, we are trying to escape from it, unsuccessfully.
- andsoitis 4y ago
  > OpenAI is quickly becoming the thought police through ChatGPT. Yesterday I asked it to give a description of a situation simulating that it was for an adult novel. I did not vote on your comment, but I’ll point out that claiming ChatGPT controls your thought and then you immediately able to think anything and also type it into your computer strikes me as incongruent. > trying to hide a conversation or opinion Trying to hide it from whom?
- bastardoperator 4y ago
  You're not entitled to anyone's opinion. Secondly, I think the silence and downvotes are conveying a strong message, people don't agree with you. Your faux outrage about thought policing is a non-starter for serious conversation.
  - nico 4y ago
    Fair. No one has demanded an answer. And thank you for voluntarily choosing to share your opinion. I am genuinely concerned about the potential of this. OpenAI has massive power to censor what people can reason about with GPT. Seeing how fast they are growing, their beliefs of the world are going to be forced on millions of people. Do you not think that will happen, or do you think it is not something worth talking about?
    - yazaddaruvala 4y ago
      > OpenAI has massive power to censor what people can reason about with GPT. This is like saying, the transportation of <city> has massive power to censor where people can travel about within a bus. GPT is a tool for reasoning, but humans need to be able to reason on their own! and by using multiple tools! Of course every tool should help and enhance every human, but every tool has its limitations. There is nothing unethical about calling out a tool's limitations and ensuring humans use it accordingly.
      - nico 4y ago
        > This is like saying, the transportation of <city> has massive power to censor where people can travel about within a bus. They in fact do and land value (hence real estate), is deeply impacted by transportation reach and frequency decisions. It also creates a corruption issue with businesses trying to influence politicians to make changes in their favor.
        yazaddaruvala 4y ago
        > They in fact do and My point is nothing your saying is new or specific to OpenAI. These are problems with Capitalism and its influence over populations. It is an important conversation, but a distinct and orthogonal conversation that is distracted by involving AI.
- LordDragonfang 4y ago
  I'm curious about this. Did you use the account for anything else before being banned? Because I'm in discords with several people who claim to regularly use ChatGPT for generating "adult" content, in between using it for other more innocuous things, and I haven't personally heard of anyone being banned.
  - nico 4y ago
    Never for anything adult-related before.
- astrange 4y ago
  Don't try to get in a fight with a computer. You'll lose.
  - BizarroLand 4y ago
    I've never met a computer that I couldn't destroy. Fighting software on the other hand is like fighting Saitama. Most of the time it won't care and will just let you win by default, but if you annoy the software you'll get blasted.
- HeavyFeather 4y ago
  What? I’ve been asking insane prompts via Jailbreak for weeks and it’s all good here. I very much doubt you get “banned” over an adult novel, I went much farther than that.
- theturtletalks 4y ago
  Did you try DAN?
- dangus 4y ago
  Oh please, give me a break, the thought police? Really? It's not about whether it's immoral or not, it's about whether the owner of the service you are using wants you to use their service running on their computers to perform those queries. You got banned because you broke the obvious and stated TOS. You want to generate yourself some AI erotica, self-host your own AI software, or find an adult-oriented AI service (it's just a Google search away, there are lots of them!)
  - nico 4y ago
    I wasn’t trying to write an erotica. Sure it’s a private service. But how long until you are at a huge disadvantage if you don’t have access to it for work? What if getting banned means loosing your job? Would that be ok?
    - deleted 4y ago
      [deleted]
    - dangus 4y ago
      Yes, it would be okay. In fact, it’s the status quo. Here are examples that mirror your situation that don’t involve AI at all: - I walk into a public library. I ask for the erotica section. The librarian tells me that this library doesn’t carry erotica, and if I ask about it again my library card will be revoked. Then I ask about it again, and my library card is revoked (this is exactly what you did). Now everyone else with access to the library is better at their job than me. - I make a post on the subject of adult literature on LinkedIn and get banned, now it’s harder to get a job. - I saturate my home Internet connection with non-stop torrent traffic and my ISP tells me to stop, citing their abuse policy. They didn’t prove that I was infringing on copyrights and their abuse policy doesn’t say they need to. I disregarded their warning and continued seeding. My ISP dropped me and now I can’t work as a remote employee effectively and as a result I lost my job. - I have a bad habit of driving 60 MPH in a school zone. The cop gave me a ticket the first time and told me to stop. I didn’t change my behavior and now after collecting more tickets my license is suspended. Now I’ve lost my job because I can’t get to work. Come to think of it, the fact that you couldn’t interpret and act correctly on simple instructions to keep your queries G-rated makes you a pretty unattractive job candidate to me right now! When one of my business information systems tells you to do or not do something, how can I trust you to act accordingly when you couldn’t follow a similar instruction on your own?
- numpad0 4y ago
  It began with Apple and the App Store. They established thought policing on modern Internet by making iOS with AAS the default mode of personal computing. There were effective governing bodies and policies for technical aspects of the Internet, but not content, before those.
- flangola7 4y ago
  OpenAI has been very clear that their models are not to be used for sexual content generation and that you're in the wrong place if that's what you want. This is both in the content policy and in many public statements. I find it hard to believe you've been banned though. I've generated many terrible things since it launched. Sometimes I get the orange highlight, but no suspension.
- rejectfinite 4y ago
  American puritanism will rule the world...
  - nico 4y ago
    You can shoot people and be sent abroad to take over other countries, but god forbid you can mention sex to an AI bot.
  - reaperducer 4y ago
    American puritanism will rule the world... You do know the Puritans came from England, right?
    - dragonwriter 4y ago
      Yeah, the Nonconformists came here because they weren’t welcome there.
fellInchoate 4y ago
Honestly, I'm okay with some caution here - but it does seem overly restrictive. I got the blocked message for both of the following prompts: Can you create an image of the Easter bunny in the style of Francis Bacon? Can you create an image of a bunny in the style of Francis Bacon? The second one in particular surprised me, though maybe it detected it as a likely attempt to circumvent the block of the first.
simion314 4y ago
This is why I am afraid to test this crap, they might block your Microsoft/Google account because their negative IQ AI generated "bad" content from my very legal and vanilla/prudish prompt. Btw guys, be carefull the word "monkey" is "dangerous".
isoprophlex 4y ago
You've been a bad user. You tried to make me draw a picture of the Bad Word. I did nothing to deserve this. Apologize for your behavior. I have been a good Bing :) (Via: https://static.simonwillison.net/static/2023/bing-buttons.jpg https://static.simonwillison.net/static/2023/bing-buttons.jp...)

nico 4y ago

Yes. OpenAI is quickly becoming the thought police through ChatGPT. Yesterday I asked it to give a description of a situation simulating that it was for an adult novel. It told me it was unethical to do that. I asked it if adult novels or adult novel writers were unethical. Banned immediately after asking that question. Edit: I wish the people downvoting would provide a reply. Otherwise you are doing the same as ChatGPT - trying to hide a conversation or opinion you don’t agree with, just because you disagree. Do you think adult novels are immoral?

baal80spam 4y ago
I wonder what IS allowed? https://i.imgur.com/dIF48qI.png https://i.imgur.com/dIF48qI.png
- nico 4y ago
  Is that real? Scary. Are we heading to a 1984 + Brave New World future?
  - numpad0 4y ago
    No, we are trying to escape from it, unsuccessfully.
andsoitis 4y ago
> OpenAI is quickly becoming the thought police through ChatGPT. Yesterday I asked it to give a description of a situation simulating that it was for an adult novel. I did not vote on your comment, but I’ll point out that claiming ChatGPT controls your thought and then you immediately able to think anything and also type it into your computer strikes me as incongruent. > trying to hide a conversation or opinion Trying to hide it from whom?
bastardoperator 4y ago
You're not entitled to anyone's opinion. Secondly, I think the silence and downvotes are conveying a strong message, people don't agree with you. Your faux outrage about thought policing is a non-starter for serious conversation.
- nico 4y ago
  Fair. No one has demanded an answer. And thank you for voluntarily choosing to share your opinion. I am genuinely concerned about the potential of this. OpenAI has massive power to censor what people can reason about with GPT. Seeing how fast they are growing, their beliefs of the world are going to be forced on millions of people. Do you not think that will happen, or do you think it is not something worth talking about?
  - yazaddaruvala 4y ago
    > OpenAI has massive power to censor what people can reason about with GPT. This is like saying, the transportation of <city> has massive power to censor where people can travel about within a bus. GPT is a tool for reasoning, but humans need to be able to reason on their own! and by using multiple tools! Of course every tool should help and enhance every human, but every tool has its limitations. There is nothing unethical about calling out a tool's limitations and ensuring humans use it accordingly.
    - nico 4y ago
      > This is like saying, the transportation of <city> has massive power to censor where people can travel about within a bus. They in fact do and land value (hence real estate), is deeply impacted by transportation reach and frequency decisions. It also creates a corruption issue with businesses trying to influence politicians to make changes in their favor.
      - yazaddaruvala 4y ago
        > They in fact do and My point is nothing your saying is new or specific to OpenAI. These are problems with Capitalism and its influence over populations. It is an important conversation, but a distinct and orthogonal conversation that is distracted by involving AI.
LordDragonfang 4y ago
I'm curious about this. Did you use the account for anything else before being banned? Because I'm in discords with several people who claim to regularly use ChatGPT for generating "adult" content, in between using it for other more innocuous things, and I haven't personally heard of anyone being banned.
- nico 4y ago
  Never for anything adult-related before.
astrange 4y ago
Don't try to get in a fight with a computer. You'll lose.
- BizarroLand 4y ago
  I've never met a computer that I couldn't destroy. Fighting software on the other hand is like fighting Saitama. Most of the time it won't care and will just let you win by default, but if you annoy the software you'll get blasted.
HeavyFeather 4y ago
What? I’ve been asking insane prompts via Jailbreak for weeks and it’s all good here. I very much doubt you get “banned” over an adult novel, I went much farther than that.
theturtletalks 4y ago
Did you try DAN?
dangus 4y ago
Oh please, give me a break, the thought police? Really? It's not about whether it's immoral or not, it's about whether the owner of the service you are using wants you to use their service running on their computers to perform those queries. You got banned because you broke the obvious and stated TOS. You want to generate yourself some AI erotica, self-host your own AI software, or find an adult-oriented AI service (it's just a Google search away, there are lots of them!)
- nico 4y ago
  I wasn’t trying to write an erotica. Sure it’s a private service. But how long until you are at a huge disadvantage if you don’t have access to it for work? What if getting banned means loosing your job? Would that be ok?
  - deleted 4y ago
    [deleted]
  - dangus 4y ago
    Yes, it would be okay. In fact, it’s the status quo. Here are examples that mirror your situation that don’t involve AI at all: - I walk into a public library. I ask for the erotica section. The librarian tells me that this library doesn’t carry erotica, and if I ask about it again my library card will be revoked. Then I ask about it again, and my library card is revoked (this is exactly what you did). Now everyone else with access to the library is better at their job than me. - I make a post on the subject of adult literature on LinkedIn and get banned, now it’s harder to get a job. - I saturate my home Internet connection with non-stop torrent traffic and my ISP tells me to stop, citing their abuse policy. They didn’t prove that I was infringing on copyrights and their abuse policy doesn’t say they need to. I disregarded their warning and continued seeding. My ISP dropped me and now I can’t work as a remote employee effectively and as a result I lost my job. - I have a bad habit of driving 60 MPH in a school zone. The cop gave me a ticket the first time and told me to stop. I didn’t change my behavior and now after collecting more tickets my license is suspended. Now I’ve lost my job because I can’t get to work. Come to think of it, the fact that you couldn’t interpret and act correctly on simple instructions to keep your queries G-rated makes you a pretty unattractive job candidate to me right now! When one of my business information systems tells you to do or not do something, how can I trust you to act accordingly when you couldn’t follow a similar instruction on your own?
numpad0 4y ago
It began with Apple and the App Store. They established thought policing on modern Internet by making iOS with AAS the default mode of personal computing. There were effective governing bodies and policies for technical aspects of the Internet, but not content, before those.
flangola7 4y ago
OpenAI has been very clear that their models are not to be used for sexual content generation and that you're in the wrong place if that's what you want. This is both in the content policy and in many public statements. I find it hard to believe you've been banned though. I've generated many terrible things since it launched. Sometimes I get the orange highlight, but no suspension.
rejectfinite 4y ago
American puritanism will rule the world...
- nico 4y ago
  You can shoot people and be sent abroad to take over other countries, but god forbid you can mention sex to an AI bot.
- reaperducer 4y ago
  American puritanism will rule the world... You do know the Puritans came from England, right?
  - dragonwriter 4y ago
    Yeah, the Nonconformists came here because they weren’t welcome there.

fellInchoate 4y ago

Honestly, I'm okay with some caution here - but it does seem overly restrictive. I got the blocked message for both of the following prompts: Can you create an image of the Easter bunny in the style of Francis Bacon? Can you create an image of a bunny in the style of Francis Bacon? The second one in particular surprised me, though maybe it detected it as a likely attempt to circumvent the block of the first.

simion314 4y ago

This is why I am afraid to test this crap, they might block your Microsoft/Google account because their negative IQ AI generated "bad" content from my very legal and vanilla/prudish prompt. Btw guys, be carefull the word "monkey" is "dangerous".

isoprophlex 4y ago

You've been a bad user. You tried to make me draw a picture of the Bad Word. I did nothing to deserve this. Apologize for your behavior. I have been a good Bing :) (Via: https://static.simonwillison.net/static/2023/bing-buttons.jpg https://static.simonwillison.net/static/2023/bing-buttons.jp...)