3 ms·
"That's how web works." Nah. I make an HTTP request and I get a response. That's how the web works. Perhaps people can have different opinions on "how the w
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
"That's how web works."
Nah. I make an HTTP request and I get a response. That's how the web works. Perhaps people can have different opinions on "how the web works".
Web fingerprinting relies on a heap of assumptions. For example, that someone uses a web browser to make HTTP requests, that the web browser sends certain HTTP headers in a certain order, that the web browser runs Javascript, that it processes cookies, recognises HSTS response headers, and so on and so on.
If all the assumptions are true, maybe web fingerprinting is effective. But if the assumptions fail, maybe web fingerprinting does not work so well.
I have only ever read blog posts about web fingerprinting that take all the assumptions as true.
The majority of traffic on the internet is said to be "bots". Not web browsers running Javascript, processing cookies, and so on.
It seems to me that someone should discuss what happens when the assumptions fail.
Do advertisers care about computer users who do not use graphical browsers much. As such a user, IME, the answer is no.
(Interesting to see how defensive replies get. It's obvious the "tech" crowd intent to spy on web users is heavily reliant on certain assumptions to remain true forever. It shows that there is necessary pressure to keep web users using a "preferred" web browser and web ""features" that will subject them to "web fingerprinting". Perhaps the assumptions will always be true, conditions will never change, in the same way that interest rates could never change.)
- twelve40 4y ago> "bots". Not web browsers running Javascript, processing cookies, and so on even the simplest bots nowadays can run Javascript and process cookies. What's much harder for a bot (or some other actor that has been doing shady things across many websites) to uniquely fake are things like the graphics card (WebGL Vendor & Renderer), audio and other hardware, which gets queried during fingerprinting. Full fingerprinting is relatively expensive, so it originally was used by fintechs to combat fraudulent/automated signups, but with the third-party cookie situation it might be already economical to track regular users for ads/retargeting.
- JD557 4y agoI think you can still be fingerprinted without cookies or Javascript (e.g. with HSTS supercookies). It's obviously not as effective.
- bearmode 4y ago>Do advertisers care about computer users who do not use graphical browsers much. As such a user, IME, the answer is no. Almost nobody does this, so obviously not. You're probably in a group that makes up less than 0.0001% of web users. And that might even be generous.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoLet's take the CommonCrawl bot, "CCbot", as an example. There are no images, CSS, or JS files in the CommonCrawl archive. Is the CCbot running Javascript. Is it equivalent to a graphical web browser with all the same features. GPT-3 was trained on a filtered version of CommonCrawl. IMO, this is text-only web use. No (fingerprint-friendly) graphical web browser needed. Others may have different opinions. Perhaps I am biased as I use the web this way seven days a week.