4 ms·
This is extremely unhelpful headlinese 1) not all phones 2) chipsets in phones vary by where they are sold. 3) only exynos chipset phones are affected. in so
by ggm 4y ago
This is extremely unhelpful headlinese
1) not all phones
2) chipsets in phones vary by where they are sold.
3) only exynos chipset phones are affected. in some economies. sold by some vendors. Not all models with a given name and code number (pixel 7, samsung 22) will be affected. "it depends"
4) not all manufacturers declare their chipset so
5) it is almost impossible for anyone but the cogniscenti to know if they are exposed to the problem, and a huge amount of FUD is flying around right now about exactly which models, which versions, which economy variants are affected, patched, can be patched, will be patched
6) the "turn off" button has been removed from some phones, presumably at the behest of the carriers to have to gatekeep VoLTE and VoWIFI and decide if they want it on or not, and do not always permit users to decide this for themselves.
- 22c 4y agoIt's also not crystal clear which Exynos chipsets are affected. I have a Samsung Galaxy S10e and a Samsung Galaxy S2 which both have Exynos chipsets, but I can't tell if there's simply no mention of these being affected because they're older models, or if it's explicitly only the newer models that are affected.
- jhoechtl 4y agoJust to be sure. A Samsung Galaxy S2? This phone is like 15? years old and still in use?
- ipaddr 4y agoMy desktop has been running for longer
- elaus 4y agoPCs are much easier to upgrade than phones. I ditched my Galaxy S2 many many years ago, but my PC is still fine after a few upgrades (e.g. SSDs).
- prmoustache 4y agoI guess with battery replacement over the years it could still be usable as a dumb phone.
- hbossy 4y agoThere's not a single feature added to phones during that time worth replacing working device for average user.
- favaq 4y ago[flagged]
- _piif 4y agoFingerprint sensors. I don't miss the times where I had to always enter my passphrase on unlock at all, massive time saver. Also not being stuck on an ancient version of Android - though I don't know what the custom ROM community for that phone is like, perhaps some soul is still porting newer versions to it.
- leetcrew 4y agosecurity updates?
- mfru 4y agoseems to still be maintained by Replicant https://redmine.replicant.us/projects/replicant/wiki/GalaxySIIGTI9100 https://redmine.replicant.us/projects/replicant/wiki/GalaxyS... which seems to be outdated by about 5 years now https://redmine.replicant.us/projects/replicant/wiki/DeviceStatus#Replicant-60 https://redmine.replicant.us/projects/replicant/wiki/DeviceS... i admire how long devices could be used, if they just were to receive security updates...
- 22c 4y agoIf I had more time, I would've liked to create my own ROMs for some of my old devices (more specifically, kernels). If hardware manufacturers published a list of their own patches to the source tree (rather than the typical "single commit/zip file of the entire linux kernel") then it would make community maintenance of old devices much easier.
- 22c 4y agoI keep a few older phones updated for the purposes of travel, backup phones or in case a friend needs a phone temporarily etc. Some older but popular models still have community maintained ROMs. I try save them from the scrap heap if I can. The main annoyance is battery life and having to keep Micro-USB chargers around.
- wodenokoto 4y agoGiven 5, it sounds pretty reasonable to recommend everyone to turn it off. Given 6, it sounds difficult to follow that advice.
- smaudet 4y agoThis is exactly why kill switches an user-unlock-able boot-loaders should be the norm, not the exotic edge case. Phones (as they are today) are a massive exercise in insecurity and privacy violation, to the point where they are actually banned in some settings.
- saagarjha 4y agoThose are great things to have, but I'm not entirely sure how they would help at all here. An unlockable bootloader would let you install…what, exactly? The patches for this have not been disclosed. What would your kill switch do? Turn off cellular communication? Good luck being able to use your phone…
- smaudet 4y agoBootloader ROMs let you install open source Android, which typically you can arrange how you see fit. So, either patch the vuln yourself (extreme) or toggle a setting somewhere. Hardware switch lets you disable wifi completely - I own one phone like this actually, you can flip about 6-8 different seperate switches this way. Then just wait untill patch becomes available/you have time to configure properly, then this becomes trivially resolved, instead of pulling teeth to get your carrier to push an update, replace your whole phone, etc...
- saagarjha 4y agoRight but that’s exactly my point: you can’t patch the vulnerability yourself because you don’t know what it is, and the alternative of disabling radios is debilitating and you can do that in software too, since this isn’t a bug in that switch itself.
- 4y ago
- Arch-TK 4y agoI believe the VoLTE toggle's presence is controlled by whether there is any fallback from VoLTE. Apparently a substantial number of carriers don't offer anything other than VoLTE at this point. Turning off VoLTE when you are with an affected carrier is equivalent, at that point, to just turning off calls altogether.
- davideg 4y agoI greatly appreciate your nuance to cut through the FUD! I reflexively disabled Wi-Fi Calling on my Google Pixel 7 Pro phone. A cursory Google search indicates that exynos modems don't support CDMA (apparently it's too expensive to license from Qualcomm) and are largely sold outside the USA. As a Verizon customer in the US, I believe this means I'm in the clear. Like another commenter, a side effect of responding to this article was discovering that the March 2023 security patch is available (even though I didn't get a notification about it).