6 ms·
> In theory, VC's, investors, and founders are considered to be "sophisticated" investors. However, they deposited a significant portion or all of their money..
by crazygringo 4y ago
> In theory, VC's, investors, and founders are considered to be "sophisticated" investors. However, they deposited a significant portion or all of their money...
Depositors are not investors. They don't have equity in the bank.
You're supposed to do your research on a business when you invest in it. You're not supposed to have to do research into a bank's financials when you're just using it as a bank. You're supposed to be able to trust government regulators.
It's the same way you're not supposed to have to research the construction of each bridge before you drive over it.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoDepends if it’s a bail-in or a bankruptcy and depositors don’t get to pick which one is applied to their bank.
- favflam 4y agoI don’t understand how VC funds can be in the billions and yet outsiders must assume they do not know anything about: 1. bank failures in the US in the last 100 years 2. deposits being on a bank’s balance sheet, hence the terms credit and debit cards 3. creditor subordination in event of default Believing #3 especially makes no sense to me given the liquidity preference clauses I hear VCs have been writing into investment agreements with startups over the last few years. These two realities, naive depositor and liquidity preferenced multi-billion dollar VCs, do not square up in my head. FDIC protects naive depositors, not sophisticated financial professionals entrusted with billions of dollars of investment funds.
- Hermitian909 4y ago> I don’t understand how VC funds can be in the billions and yet outsiders must assume they do not know anything about: 1. bank failures in the US in the last 100 years 2. deposits being on a bank’s balance sheet, hence the terms credit and debit cards 3. creditor subordination in event of default Without offering judgment: VCs are concerned with many things that can kill the companies in their portfolio across multiple different verticals. I would assume a big part of how this happened is that of all the things that could kill their returns, banks were low enough on the list that they weren't regularly thinking about it. IMO there's a legitimate question about whether we believe it's good for one of the things VCs have to consider is bank failure risk as it will necessarily take attention away from other concerns more related to business and innovation.
- stevedewald 4y agoHedge fund manager here. Depositors and banks are counterparties, and every financial institution & fund I’ve ever encountered does significant and ongoing diligence on their multiple banking relationships. It’s hard to imagine how irresponsible these VCs and startups were.
- antiviral 4y agoThese 'startups' include small businesses like wineries and restaurants. They're not in finance and are not going to want to spend time becoming experts in banking due diligence. If we insist that they take on their bank's solvency risk as depositors, the rational decision for most of them will simply to be move to a systemically important bank that the govt will likely never let fail (Citi, BofA..). There's no reason for them to keep their business at a small bank and take on risk they don't need to. Regional banks would then wither, and the banking industry would become even more concentrated with a few too-big-to-fail banks becoming even more powerful. It would be a bad outcome for everyone. BTW, for anyone wondering which banks are considered to be 'systemically important', here's a convenient link to the list: https://www.fsb.org/wp-content/uploads/P211122.pdf https://www.fsb.org/wp-content/uploads/P211122.pdf And here's a link to the group that decided who goes on that list: https://www.fsb.org/ https://www.fsb.org/
- riffraff 4y agoDo SV restaurants have millions in cash? Cause up to 250k they were guaranteed. Those people I know who run restaurants basically have zero cash at hand and are constantly repaying some debts.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tomp 4y agoThese are more like “prime brokers” rather than “counterparties” in trade. How often do you assume that your prime broker will go out of business before your hedge fund does? Unless you’re a big one (Citadel, Millenium), probably “never” (it’s the same with startup companies).
- throwawaylinux 4y agoWhat do you mean you're supposed to trust government regulators though? Regulators don't prevent bank failures. What account holders can (more or less) trust is the deposit insurance scheme to insure them for a well-known amount. If somebody deposits significantly more than FDIC in a bank account, would you advise them to research the bank's financials or not?
- vkou 4y agoIf you are setting that as the bar for depositor competency, congratulations, you've just guaranteed that every single business and HNW individual will only bank with a too-big-to-fail bank.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoAccess to some basic understanding of financials and risk is not out of reach of many businesses and "NHW individuals" that would be inclined to deposit that much. Your assertion is false. You would do well to be quite certain of what you're talking before you try being snarky. And I am not setting any bar. That is the bar which has been set by the reality of things as they are. Don't complain to me if you don't like it.
- johngladtj 4y agoDepositors are investors, they're just not equity investors.
- crazygringo 4y agoNo they're not, that's not how the word is defined. You deposit money into a checking account, you don't invest money in a checking account. The same as when you deposit a retainer with a law firm you're not an investor in the firm. Or if you have a security deposit with your apartment's management company you're not an investor in that company. Words have definitions.