2 ms·
I am not a lawyer, but I wouldn't have thought that was relevant. This isn't like libel, where you have to show damages. As I understand it, if I wrote a manus
by jfengel 4y ago
I am not a lawyer, but I wouldn't have thought that was relevant. This isn't like libel, where you have to show damages.
As I understand it, if I wrote a manuscript that I didn't want published at all, my rights would still be violated if you published it. I didn't lose any money; I just wanted to assert my right to control it.
I could imagine this being an issue in the penalty phase, but they're not there yet. Can a lawyer explain why this is relevant here?
- thebooktocome 4y agoThis is answered in the article. Plaintiffs are alleging that they were damaged; judge pointed out their revenues spiked during the period in question. IA is sticking to a fair use defense, so showing damage was caused would hurt their defense.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jchw 4y agoIANAL but I do believe one of the factors of Fair Use is whether you are competing with the owner of the copyrighted work(s) in question; "the effects on the potential market." So if they're trying to make a case for or against IA's use of the copyrighted material constituting fair use, this seems relevant.
- jcranmer 4y agoAt its core, this case comes down to "is this fair use" (there's no claims that it's not copyright infringement, IIRC). And while fair use analysis considers the four factors, in actual practice, the four factors are merely a way to explain the reasoning behind the gut decision, which usually boils down to "did the copyright owner deserve to get paid?" The fourth factor is "the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work," which is where the monetary aspect is going to be considered. If the judge is pointing out that the publishers actually saw market growth as the Internet Archive expanded its lending, that could signal that they are going to find the fourth factor in favor of the Internet Archive--and that would utterly destroy the publishers' case here.
- jfengel 4y agoInteresting. It doesn't strike me as an especially airtight argument; I'm sure lots of people had time to read during lockdown and some chose to pay for books. It's challenging to prove the counterfactual one way or the other. But that's why they hired lawyers and I'm merely a logician.
- themoonisachees 4y agoNot a lawyer either, but the fair use doctrine isn't exactly airtight to begin with.
- akira2501 4y ago> my rights would still be violated if you published it. I would think that depends on how I gained access to it and whether my work was transformative or not. Merely publishing a copy is a clear violation, but publishing an annotated critique of the work might not be. Public interest may bolster this, and expectation of privacy may tempter it. > to assert my right to control it. If you sold it to me then those rights don't exist without a separate contract. Copyright is a two way street.
- VanTheBrand 4y agoPurchasing a manuscript doesn’t give you the copyright to it. So it would be you that needed a separate contract in this example.
- akira2501 4y agoI'm referencing the first sale doctrine. You maintain copyright but not control of the sold copy itself.
- mcv 4y agoBut that's not the same issue. These are publishers who do want the books published, but they argue IA hurts their profits and they can't show that it does. It's that particular argument that doesn't work for them. Others still may.